Who Would You Rather Have: Tyrese Haliburton or Devin Booker?

WillyJakkz · Post #1 » by **WillyJakkz** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 3:51 am

*Disclaimer: Let me preface this by saying I'm not that high on Devin Booker but alot of people are*

Let's switch this comparison to the Guards.

23yr old Tyrese Haliburton is having a fantastic breakout yr while 27yr old Devin Booker is playing steady ball as usual. Both scorers, both shooters, and Hali who hardly turns over the basketball with now Booker being more of a facilitator.

Who Would You Rather Have: Tyrese Haliburton or Devin Booker?

Tyrese Haliburton

https://www.basketball-reference.com/players/h/halibty01.html

Devin Booker

https://www.basketball-reference.com/players/b/bookede01.html

Hook_Em · Post #2 » by **Hook_Em** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 4:03 am

I’d take Haliburton over Booker, Shai and Fox. The only guard i wouldn’t take over him going forward is Luka.

NBA4Lyfe · Post #3 » by **NBA4Lyfe** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 4:32 am

Hook_Em wrote:I’d take Haliburton over Booker, Shai and Fox. The only guard i wouldn’t take over him going forward is Luka.

No I love Halliburton but Shai is clearly the best guard in the league right now.

Beethoven · Post #4 » by **Beethoven** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 4:34 am

I'd take Booker for lakers

Marvin Martian · Post #5 » by **Marvin Martian** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 4:45 am

Haliburton would be a cheat code at 27

1993Playoffs · Post #6 » by **1993Playoffs** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 4:46 am

Shoot , Hali seems better than Shai

Post #7 » by **bwgood77** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 4:51 am

Would be nice to have them both on the Suns instead of passing on the sliding Haliburton for Jalen Smith, particularly since the Suns biggest need was a young pg for the future.

lonzo_pelota · Post #8 » by **lonzo_pelota** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 5:03 am

I'd take Domantas Sabonis over him said a Sac King GM once, smh

Memories · Post #9 » by **Memories** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 5:06 am

Tyrese easily.

Tyrese I can build a team around. And he makes everyone better. At 23 years old he’s already the best passing point guard in the league. While being a great scorer and shooter.

This dude in 5 years will have every single team clamoring for him when he’s a free agent and inevitably leaves Indiana.

EmpireFalls · Post #10 » by **EmpireFalls** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 5:07 am

Y'all really need to start valuing defense more.

JordansBulls · Post #11 » by **JordansBulls** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 5:24 am

Devin Booker put 47 on Lebron and put him out in round 1 when the Lakers were the favorites.

Memories · Post #12 » by **Memories** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 5:27 am

EmpireFalls wrote:Y'all really need to start valuing defense more.

Is that supposed to be an argument in favor of Booker? Because his defense…oh boy. Have you ever watched a Suns game before?

jourdy · Post #13 » by **jourdy** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 6:52 am

Never seen Haliburton in the playoffs.
But probably won't have any performance that gets drilled in your brain like Booker's G7 2022 performance.

0/7 in the first half. Scored only in garbage time. Something I will never forget. Especially after all the trash talking

CobraCommander · Post #14 » by **CobraCommander** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 7:00 am

NBA4Lyfe wrote:
Hook_Em wrote:I’d take Haliburton over Booker, Shai and Fox. The only guard i wouldn’t take over him going forward is Luka.

No I love Halliburton but Shai is clearly the best guard in the league right now.

SGA a monster- I’m with you- SGA both ends and no drama...willing teammate - give me him

CobraCommander · Post #15 » by **CobraCommander** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 7:03 am

jourdy wrote:Never seen Haliburton in the playoffs.
But probably won't have any performance that gets drilled in your brain like Booker's G7 2022 performance.

0/7 in the first half. Scored only in garbage time. Something I will never forget. Especially after all the trash talking

So you forgot last year...take your time...you not gonna find any with better stats than this in playoffs
https://www.statmuse.com/nba/ask/devin-booker-2023-playoffs-stats

No body....this is LAST year - y’all kill me acting like you waiting for some players to evolve and saying they still young but some other players your write off after one game

Mr Peanut · Post #16 » by **Mr Peanut** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 7:14 am

This is the definition of a RealGM reactionary poll.

Wargreymon · Post #17 » by **Wargreymon** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 7:32 am

Lol. Booker is so beneath Haliburton. Like comparing Steve Francis to Magic Johnson. Hali all day

RRR3 · Post #18 » by **RRR3** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 7:40 am

JordansBulls wrote:Devin Booker put 47 on Lebron and put him out in round 1 when the Lakers were the favorites.

You never post about anything besides LeBron. Stop it. Get some help

iggymcfrack · Post #19 » by **iggymcfrack** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 7:45 am

EmpireFalls wrote:Y'all really need to start valuing defense more.

I feel like EPM evaluates them pretty fairly:

Haliburton: +9.4 offense (100th percentile), -2.2 defense (5th percentile), +7.2 overall (99th percentile)

Booker: +5.6 offense (98th percentile), -0.8 defense (41st percentile), +4.8 overall (97th percentile)

Also, remember Haliburton’s 23. When Booker was 23, his defense was terrible. Booker is pretty close to his peak now and he’s a borderline top 10 player. Haliburton’s super young, getting better by the day, and he’s already a top 5 player easy. His floor is higher than Booker’s ceiling.

ROballer · Post #20 » by **ROballer** » Fri Dec 8, 2023 7:50 am

It's a legit question considering Booker is 4 years older.

Lol at using the playoffs argument. How soon we forget.

I still vividly remember Booker being called out as a career loser in this place before CP3 came to the Suns.

23-59
24-58
21-61
19-63
34-39

First 5 years in the league.