Did he say "No"?!
Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
Moderators: HomoSapien, Michael Jackson, Ice Man, Tommy Udo 6 , kulaz3000, fleet, DASMACKDOWN, GimmeDat, AshyLarrysDiaper, coldfish, RedBulls23
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
- DRoseCantStop
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,014
- And1: 3,371
- Joined: Feb 17, 2013
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
- Axl Rose
- Head Coach
- Posts: 6,844
- And1: 4,093
- Joined: Jul 03, 2013
- Location: Superunknown
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
Droseisthe1 wrote:Not sure but owner Les Alexander seemed a bit disappointed here...
http://instagram.com/p/p9h44yEMJs/?modal=true
looks like a man that was told "thanks for the lunch.....but im taking my talents to the windy city"
I don't do the dishes, I throw them in the crib
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
RememberLu
- RealGM
- Posts: 14,877
- And1: 8,448
- Joined: Feb 22, 2014
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
WinCity wrote:Magilla_Gorilla wrote:GetSeven wrote:
He's obviously excited by the fact that the guy that helped Chicago get all their rings is now running the Knickerbocker organization. Knicks fans can't help but at least be slightly encouraged.
I might be excited if that guy got rings running the Bulls, or any organization. But does anyone think Jerry West or Jerry Krause were deferring to Phil on personnel?

Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
- DuckIII
- Retired Mod

- Posts: 72,024
- And1: 37,470
- Joined: Nov 25, 2003
- Location: On my high horse.
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
ophdog wrote:Well rings do play into this.
Good.
If the bulls were in the finals recently then melo could make the argument that he is the piece to put them over the top.
That makes no sense. A team doesn't have to have been in the Finals to become a Finals favorite by adding a superstar. Finals teams virtually never add superstars.
The Knicks have been a mess the last year admittedly. However we just changed regimes. You cannot overlook the fact that the coach and mastermind with the most rings ever is running our franchise.
I don't overlook it. When he signed on, I immediately put the Knicks back in the driver's seat, between Phil's cache and the extra money.
You guys have own way more games the last 2 years than you should of thibs has done an amazing job but is he seriously better than pjax?
He's infinitely better, considering that Phil Jackson isn't the Knicks' coach.
Of all teams you should give us credit on that one
I give you credit that Phil's reputation and importance will be a factor in Melo's decision. I think it matters to him. Had the Knicks not hired him, I would have given the Knicks zero chance at resigning Melo. As it stands, I view them as the clear favorite.
Once a pickle, never a cucumber again.
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
- Magilla_Gorilla
- RealGM
- Posts: 32,059
- And1: 4,481
- Joined: Oct 24, 2006
- Location: Sunday Morning coming down...
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
DRoseCantStop wrote:http://instagram.com/p/p9l1OhkMAr/?modal=true
Did he say "No"?!
Melo hates Houston and its citizens!
Sham - Y U NO sell me a t-shirt? Best OB/GYN Houston
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
IndianPlaya17
- Pro Prospect
- Posts: 825
- And1: 476
- Joined: Mar 26, 2011
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
DRoseCantStop wrote:http://instagram.com/p/p9l1OhkMAr/?modal=true
Did he say "No"?!
So he's done with Houston?
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
Indomitable
- RealGM
- Posts: 26,431
- And1: 6,907
- Joined: Jul 11, 2001
- Location: Yelzenbah!
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
Magilla_Gorilla wrote:GetSeven wrote:RememberLu wrote:
What do rings have to do with anything in this context? Look at it objectively, Chicago has been on another level compared to the Knicks just the past 4 years. The Bulls, with their team and their front office, have shown a remarkable degree of consistency, stability, and have managed to maintain a certain level of performance regardless of circumstances, injuries, etc.
The Knicks have just been a complete mess. If they're not trading half the roster away one year, they're firing a coach in another or somehow still not managing to make the playoffs in a historically awful eastern conference
He's obviously excited by the fact that the guy that helped Chicago get all their rings is now running the Knickerbocker organization. Knicks fans can't help but at least be slightly encouraged.
I might be excited if that guy got rings running the Bulls, or any organization. But does anyone think Jerry West or Jerry Krause were deferring to Phil on personnel?
Phil had no say.
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
Droseisthe1
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,381
- And1: 1,783
- Joined: Aug 13, 2010
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
HTowns Finest wrote:ChiCitySPORTS#1 wrote:Defense wins championships.
Put that **** on a billboard. Perfect fit man. Perfect.
Defense does not win championships but it helps. You can't win a ring in the NBA today only scoring 70 points in games. That's not going to cut it against the elite teams. It's about buckets and defense.
You're not gonna win championships giving up 103 ppg either which the Rockets did.
Kris Bryant will go down as the greatest Chicago athlete after MJ
edit 7/30/21: okay maybe not, but it was a fun ride nonetheless
edit 7/30/21: okay maybe not, but it was a fun ride nonetheless
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
- DuckIII
- Retired Mod

- Posts: 72,024
- And1: 37,470
- Joined: Nov 25, 2003
- Location: On my high horse.
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
AirGordon7 wrote:Droseisthe1 wrote:Not sure but owner Les Alexander seemed a bit disappointed here...
http://instagram.com/p/p9h44yEMJs/?modal=true
looks like a man that was told "thanks for the lunch.....but im taking my talents to the windy city"
For some reason I cannot access that link. What is in it?
Once a pickle, never a cucumber again.
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
MoneyMitch
- Banned User
- Posts: 2,284
- And1: 1,562
- Joined: Apr 27, 2014
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
The thing you guys have over everyone is Thibs
As much of an odd-couple he and Melo may seem I think there's a true connection it seems
It's actually reminding me of Chris Paul and Doc Rivers last year where they both wanted each other and the Clippers made it happen
As much of an odd-couple he and Melo may seem I think there's a true connection it seems
It's actually reminding me of Chris Paul and Doc Rivers last year where they both wanted each other and the Clippers made it happen
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
Proven_Winner
- RealGM
- Posts: 15,634
- And1: 3,964
- Joined: Jun 02, 2013
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
Magilla_Gorilla wrote:Proven_Winner wrote:Dwight is depressed because if Melo comes he knows that means he gets less shots
Either that or he just got a look at this months child support bill.
You and this child thing with Howard is killing me.
To add on maybe he just found out he got another kid.
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
ingvald
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,516
- And1: 1,861
- Joined: Jun 20, 2014
- Location: the 920- a wretched hive of scum and villany
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
MoneyMitch wrote:The thing you guys have over everyone is Thibs
As much of an odd-couple he and Melo may seem I think there's a true connection it seems
It's actually reminding me of Chris Paul and Doc Rivers last year where they both wanted each other and the Clippers made it happen
I hope you're right but Carlisle ain't shabby.
Honesty is my only excuse.

BullsFan88- the Sig Mamba

BullsFan88- the Sig Mamba
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
Betta Bulleavit
- General Manager
- Posts: 7,805
- And1: 2,903
- Joined: Oct 29, 2004
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
Someone shake the hell out of me if this seems like bias. But Melo seemed very underwhelmed and in a hurry to get the hell out of there. Just didn't scream...this was a freakin awesome visit. In fact, none of the parties involved seemed all that enthusiastic about how everything went. Again..if that's my bias, shake me, slap me, and tell me to shut the hell up.
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
WinCity
- Banned User
- Posts: 8,488
- And1: 1,688
- Joined: Mar 18, 2011
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
MoneyMitch wrote:The thing you guys have over everyone is Thibs
As much of an odd-couple he and Melo may seem I think there's a true connection it seems
It's actually reminding me of Chris Paul and Doc Rivers last year where they both wanted each other and the Clippers made it happen
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
ingvald
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,516
- And1: 1,861
- Joined: Jun 20, 2014
- Location: the 920- a wretched hive of scum and villany
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
Proven_Winner wrote:Magilla_Gorilla wrote:Proven_Winner wrote:Dwight is depressed because if Melo comes he knows that means he gets less shots
Either that or he just got a look at this months child support bill.
You and this child thing with Howard is killing me.![]()
To add on maybe he just found out he got another kid.
No, he just found out that girl from a month ago was only 16.
Honesty is my only excuse.

BullsFan88- the Sig Mamba

BullsFan88- the Sig Mamba
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
RememberLu
- RealGM
- Posts: 14,877
- And1: 8,448
- Joined: Feb 22, 2014
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
The most important personnel decision made back then was made by Rod Thorn when he drafted Michael Jordan.
I'd say Phil pretty much had no say in that.
but he does have rings, yes, many of them. He's excellent at managing ego's, I dom't know how excellent he is at GMing. I'll tell you if he gives Melo the max for 5 years I'll question his first big decision as a GM, thats a dumb move to me.
I'd say Phil pretty much had no say in that.
but he does have rings, yes, many of them. He's excellent at managing ego's, I dom't know how excellent he is at GMing. I'll tell you if he gives Melo the max for 5 years I'll question his first big decision as a GM, thats a dumb move to me.
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
Droseisthe1
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,381
- And1: 1,783
- Joined: Aug 13, 2010
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
Betta Bulleavit wrote:Someone shake the hell out of me if this seems like bias. But Melo seemed very underwhelmed and in a hurry to get the hell out of there. Just didn't scream...this was a freakin awesome visit. In fact, none of the parties involved seemed all that enthusiastic about how everything went. Again..if that's my bias, shake me, slap me, and tell me to shut the hell up.
I'll say the leaders right now are
1.NY/CHI
2.DAL (even before their meeting!!)
3.HOU (don't think it went great)
4.LAL
Kris Bryant will go down as the greatest Chicago athlete after MJ
edit 7/30/21: okay maybe not, but it was a fun ride nonetheless
edit 7/30/21: okay maybe not, but it was a fun ride nonetheless
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
ChiCitySPORTS#1
- RealGM
- Posts: 20,289
- And1: 5,551
- Joined: Jul 02, 2006
- Location: West Loop
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
HTowns Finest wrote:ChiCitySPORTS#1 wrote:Defense wins championships.
Put that **** on a billboard. Perfect fit man. Perfect.
Defense does not win championships but it helps. You can't win a ring in the NBA today only scoring 70 points in games. That's not going to cut it against the elite teams. It's about buckets and defense.
Well no ****, you cant be putrid offensively. Defense does win championships. History speaks for itself
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
MoneyMitch
- Banned User
- Posts: 2,284
- And1: 1,562
- Joined: Apr 27, 2014
-
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
ingvald wrote:MoneyMitch wrote:The thing you guys have over everyone is Thibs
As much of an odd-couple he and Melo may seem I think there's a true connection it seems
It's actually reminding me of Chris Paul and Doc Rivers last year where they both wanted each other and the Clippers made it happen
I hope you're right but Carlisle ain't shabby.
I like Carlisle too I just don't see Melo being as infatuated with him as he seems with Thibs
I think he'd rather work with Thibs than Phil tbh
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
-
Proven_Winner
- RealGM
- Posts: 15,634
- And1: 3,964
- Joined: Jun 02, 2013
Re: Melo #13: Believe in Joakim Noah & Crew
It's so hot he got the sleeves rolled up.








