Do you deal for Cliff Lee or Roy Halladay?

[Dr. Detfink]

So much for the great Philadelphia Experiment. The additions of Roy Oswalt, Roy Halladay, & Cliff Lee have added up to ZERO championships. The fightin' Phils are 33-38. Oswalt is now in Texas. Roy Halladay is 4-5 with 3.98 ERA. Cliff Lee is 0-3 with 3.48 ERA.

I can't see the Phillies not wanting to unload payroll especially with 10-3 Cole Hamels an impending free Agent.

If you were Brian Cashman, you had a second chance to nab a competitive SP to deepen a mixed rotation of youth & experience...would you for one more shot at a World Series?

Let's say the Yanks add Lee or Halladay...that would be #2...and then the rotation looks like this:

1. Sabbathia
2. Halladay or Lee
3. Kuroda
4. Nova
5. Pettitte

Hughes to the pen...

Looks a little more sturdy at the top right? Your thoughts...

[Christophersp10]

Neither but if and only if the Yankees can trade damage goods like Banuelos or Betances. Phillies would want too much and Cliff Lee burned his bridge with NY.

[moocow007]

Or...they can offer the same money that they would have to pay Halladay or Lee if they traded for him to Hamels as a free agent.

[Dr. Detfink]

Hamels in NY...interesting. Can he handle pressure?