if timmy only wins 15 games

[TruE SExy]

but still leads the nl in era and strikeouts...does he have a good chance to win cy young? logic says of course, but i cant remember the last time a 15 game winner won it.

look at clemens in 2005...far and away the best pitcher but didnt get the wins, and bartolo colon wins it with like twice the era

[shazam_guy]

He won't win the CY again unless he wins all his last starts with shutouts. They won't give it twice in a row to an under-20 wins guy unless the stats are irresistible. And he'll split votes with Cain from local (West Coast) writers.

IMO.

[bill curley II]

I don't think anyone would vote Cain over Lincecum, but regardless, Carpenter will win the Cy Young. He'll be on a first place team with better or at least comparable ERA and WHIP numbers and more wins. Timmy will have more K's but that's about it.