arkuo wrote:Here's a rather difficult question that's I've come across online today.
If the situation came to this, would you trade KP for Ben Simmons straight up?
With KP we would be hoping he could get back to the player he was last year. At age 25 that doesn't seem impossible and that makes him an All-Star some years.
With Simmons we would be hoping he develops part of his game that coaches have been trying to get him to develop for the the past 5 years. If he does that, he goes to the Hall of Fame.
Simmons has much higher risk given he needs to do something he has never done before. KP less risk, but also less upside.
And there is one more factor. I think Simmons has a much better chance of succeeding if he is a the 3rd star on a team vs the 2nd star. Take the scoring pressure off him and let him be a Dennis Rodman type player. As his problems are likely mostly mental, less pressure might allow him to actually shoot the ball without fear that every one won't go in.
So, I would love to have Simmons to go along with Luka and KP. I would be very worried that Simmons could handle the pressure if he was the 2nd star to Luka.