Getting close to the end of the season wondering who you all think would be a good fit for the blue jays.
I think Ron Gardenhire would be a great manager for the team but hes not leaving the Twins any time soon so.
Next Manager of the Jays
Moderator: JaysRule15
Next Manager of the Jays
-
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,145
- And1: 1
- Joined: Mar 16, 2010
Re: Next Manager of the Jays
- satyr9
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 3,892
- And1: 563
- Joined: Aug 09, 2006
-
Re: Next Manager of the Jays
There are 4-5 guys out there with significant careers left who are cream of the crop(another 5 ancient guys who were great but are retiring or done IMO), but they aren't going anywhere and I'd probably include Gardenhire in that group (Gardenhire, Scoscia, Girardi, Maddon).
This is a pretty big hire IMO. Hopefully the big scouting staff has been used on some managerial prospects too, 'cause I don't see the Jays poaching an established guy or drawing the biggest names with so many vacancies up this year. The inter-cito years were so full of coaching changes, I'd sure like to see AA find the guy who can do the job for the next decade. I have no idea how likely this is, but some stability (and a little creativity?) at the spot sounds great to me.
This is a pretty big hire IMO. Hopefully the big scouting staff has been used on some managerial prospects too, 'cause I don't see the Jays poaching an established guy or drawing the biggest names with so many vacancies up this year. The inter-cito years were so full of coaching changes, I'd sure like to see AA find the guy who can do the job for the next decade. I have no idea how likely this is, but some stability (and a little creativity?) at the spot sounds great to me.
Re: Next Manager of the Jays
- Hummus
- Senior
- Posts: 619
- And1: 1
- Joined: Oct 25, 2008
- Contact:
Re: Next Manager of the Jays
If we are promoting a guy from nowhere, he has to be able to command respect from the team. As much as I liked Gibby, he was destined to fail because he was never more than a backup catcher and bullpen coach. An established coach would be my preferred route, but as satyr said - too many vacancies in big markets (including some possibly opening up (Boston?))
If the Cubs don't hire Ryne Sandberg, I would definitely look at him.
If the Cubs don't hire Ryne Sandberg, I would definitely look at him.

Re: Next Manager of the Jays
-
- Junior
- Posts: 411
- And1: 26
- Joined: Jul 23, 2008
Re: Next Manager of the Jays
Ryno is a candy ass - he won't succeed as a manager.
Key challenges for the next Jay manager is to keep Yunel Escobar from flaking out, motivating Vernon Wells to stay in shape, getting Arencibia/Snider into everyday roles, and manage whatever goat rodeo of a bullpen he's endowed with in 2011. I think only a manager who's won at least a few playoff series will have the necessary credibility.
Getting Hill and Lind back on track is not something a manager can do - just gotta throw them out there and hope for the best.
Key challenges for the next Jay manager is to keep Yunel Escobar from flaking out, motivating Vernon Wells to stay in shape, getting Arencibia/Snider into everyday roles, and manage whatever goat rodeo of a bullpen he's endowed with in 2011. I think only a manager who's won at least a few playoff series will have the necessary credibility.
Getting Hill and Lind back on track is not something a manager can do - just gotta throw them out there and hope for the best.
Re: Next Manager of the Jays
- U_Mad
- Senior
- Posts: 548
- And1: 83
- Joined: Jul 15, 2010
Re: Next Manager of the Jays
Bobby Valentine
Re: Next Manager of the Jays
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,394
- And1: 2
- Joined: Jan 23, 2006
Re: Next Manager of the Jays
U_Mad wrote:Bobby Valentine
that was a name that Dan Shulman brought up with Bobcat