Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Moderator: bwgood77
Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,135
- And1: 1,745
- Joined: Mar 28, 2013
Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
I've only watched a few Chiefs' games but it feels like Mahomes has lost his big arm.
He is known to have the biggest arm in the NFL but it feels like this year, the zip on his throws seems to be one notch down?
I could be wrong, but that throw he hit Worthy on, it look like he gave it his all and barely cleared 60 yards, while he has been known 80 yards. I remember he played Atlanta once and hit Tyreek on a 75yr TD.
Have any Chiefs fans noticed anything with Mahomes arm strength this year or is it just me?
He is known to have the biggest arm in the NFL but it feels like this year, the zip on his throws seems to be one notch down?
I could be wrong, but that throw he hit Worthy on, it look like he gave it his all and barely cleared 60 yards, while he has been known 80 yards. I remember he played Atlanta once and hit Tyreek on a 75yr TD.
Have any Chiefs fans noticed anything with Mahomes arm strength this year or is it just me?
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,233
- And1: 5,099
- Joined: Nov 20, 2014
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Mahomes is 29 years old. If anything he’s getting better.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
- Micah Prescott
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,575
- And1: 1,725
- Joined: Aug 25, 2021
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Mr B wrote:Mahomes is 29 years old. If anything he’s getting better.
Yes age wise a QBs prime is probably around 32-33.
But Mahomes clearly has had an off year. And IMO it looks like he has allowed his fame and success to get to his head and he probably doesn't train or focus as much as he used to. He probably had the mindset of "I am going to win because I always do" walking into the SB.
Hopefully for his sake this loss was a wake up for him and a reminder than he still has to try to compete.
I think Russ Wilson suffered this as well.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,233
- And1: 5,099
- Joined: Nov 20, 2014
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Micah Prescott wrote:Mr B wrote:Mahomes is 29 years old. If anything he’s getting better.
Yes age wise a QBs prime is probably around 32-33.
But Mahomes clearly has had an off year. And IMO it looks like he has allowed his fame and success to get to his head and he probably doesn't train or focus as much as he used to. He probably had the mindset of "I am going to win because I always do" walking into the SB.
Hopefully for his sake this loss was a wake up for him and a reminder than he still has to try to compete.
I think Russ Wilson suffered this as well.
Every QB has a down year. Even Brady had down years between his two dynasty runs.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
- Cactus Jack
- Forum Mod - Supersonics
- Posts: 31,659
- And1: 15,910
- Joined: Feb 25, 2015
- Location: The Last of Us Part II
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Micah Prescott wrote:Mr B wrote:Mahomes is 29 years old. If anything he’s getting better.
Yes age wise a QBs prime is probably around 32-33.
But Mahomes clearly has had an off year. And IMO it looks like he has allowed his fame and success to get to his head and he probably doesn't train or focus as much as he used to. He probably had the mindset of "I am going to win because I always do" walking into the SB.
Hopefully for his sake this loss was a wake up for him and a reminder than he still has to try to compete.
I think Russ Wilson suffered this as well.
Sometimes we put too much blame on an individual. When it was clear that his supporting cast wasn't as good this year. That includes the OL, and missing guys like Rashee Rice.
Did he play great? No. But the Eagles clearly had the better roster from top to bottom.
Russ always had certain limitations in his game due to his size. He also put on weight as he aged & lost his mobility. Which took away what made him great. You can't play backyard Football all the time if you're a step slower.
Dominater wrote:Damn Cactus jack takin over
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,135
- And1: 1,745
- Joined: Mar 28, 2013
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Brady doesn't have a big arm and can't run, he lives off of his IQ and pre snap reads. Mahomes lives off of his big arm, so what will happen when that goes away?
When Brett Favre lost his big arm in his 30s, he became a very average QB.
When Brett Favre lost his big arm in his 30s, he became a very average QB.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- Starter
- Posts: 2,202
- And1: 737
- Joined: Aug 15, 2023
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Cactus Jack wrote:Micah Prescott wrote:Mr B wrote:Mahomes is 29 years old. If anything he’s getting better.
Yes age wise a QBs prime is probably around 32-33.
But Mahomes clearly has had an off year. And IMO it looks like he has allowed his fame and success to get to his head and he probably doesn't train or focus as much as he used to. He probably had the mindset of "I am going to win because I always do" walking into the SB.
Hopefully for his sake this loss was a wake up for him and a reminder than he still has to try to compete.
I think Russ Wilson suffered this as well.
Sometimes we put too much blame on an individual. When it was clear that his supporting cast wasn't as good this year. That includes the OL, and missing guys like Rashee Rice.
Did he play great? No. But the Eagles clearly had the better roster from top to bottom.
Russ always had certain limitations in his game due to his size. He also put on weight as he aged & lost his mobility. Which took away what made him great. You can't play backyard Football all the time if you're a step slower.
Yep. Honestly, the eagles were in his face almost every drop back, that would make any qb have an off game. It didn’t exactly help that the chiefs only called 7 run plays all game either, not that it would’ve mattered against that run defense.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
- Cactus Jack
- Forum Mod - Supersonics
- Posts: 31,659
- And1: 15,910
- Joined: Feb 25, 2015
- Location: The Last of Us Part II
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Jaydubb wrote:Cactus Jack wrote:Micah Prescott wrote:Yes age wise a QBs prime is probably around 32-33.
But Mahomes clearly has had an off year. And IMO it looks like he has allowed his fame and success to get to his head and he probably doesn't train or focus as much as he used to. He probably had the mindset of "I am going to win because I always do" walking into the SB.
Hopefully for his sake this loss was a wake up for him and a reminder than he still has to try to compete.
I think Russ Wilson suffered this as well.
Sometimes we put too much blame on an individual. When it was clear that his supporting cast wasn't as good this year. That includes the OL, and missing guys like Rashee Rice.
Did he play great? No. But the Eagles clearly had the better roster from top to bottom.
Russ always had certain limitations in his game due to his size. He also put on weight as he aged & lost his mobility. Which took away what made him great. You can't play backyard Football all the time if you're a step slower.
Yep. Honestly, the eagles were in his face almost every drop back, that would make any qb have an off game. It didn’t exactly help that the chiefs only called 7 run plays all game either, not that it would’ve mattered against that run defense.
7 runs plays? Did Andy hire Ryan Grubb to call plays?
I kid. But obviously that's not a winning formula. It didn't help matters that they dug themselves a hole.
Dominater wrote:Damn Cactus jack takin over
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
- QB_Eagles
- Starter
- Posts: 2,413
- And1: 800
- Joined: Jul 24, 2023
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Nah, he's fine.
It's just when people crowned him the new GOAT they overlooked that he was surrounded by great offensive players and coaching.
Tyreek and Travis were Top 3 players at their position and the OL was good if not better.
Now his WR are underwhelming, Kelce lost a step, and the OL mediocre.
Additionally this Super Bowl Andy Reid forgot all about the run game like he used to do 20 years ago.
It's just when people crowned him the new GOAT they overlooked that he was surrounded by great offensive players and coaching.
Tyreek and Travis were Top 3 players at their position and the OL was good if not better.
Now his WR are underwhelming, Kelce lost a step, and the OL mediocre.
Additionally this Super Bowl Andy Reid forgot all about the run game like he used to do 20 years ago.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,233
- And1: 5,099
- Joined: Nov 20, 2014
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
atlantabbq99 wrote:Brady doesn't have a big arm and can't run, he lives off of his IQ and pre snap reads. Mahomes lives off of his big arm, so what will happen when that goes away?
When Brett Favre lost his big arm in his 30s, he became a very average QB.
Mahomes also has the highest football IQ currently in the NFL. They has QB’d his team to 5 SB’s. You seriously think he’s lost his arm strength at 29 years old? Lol
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
- QB_Eagles
- Starter
- Posts: 2,413
- And1: 800
- Joined: Jul 24, 2023
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Mr B wrote:atlantabbq99 wrote:Brady doesn't have a big arm and can't run, he lives off of his IQ and pre snap reads. Mahomes lives off of his big arm, so what will happen when that goes away?
When Brett Favre lost his big arm in his 30s, he became a very average QB.
Mahomes also has the highest football IQ currently in the NFL. They has QB’d his team to 5 SB’s. You seriously think he’s lost his arm strength at 29 years old? Lol
No, Tanner McKee has the highest football IQ.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- Starter
- Posts: 2,202
- And1: 737
- Joined: Aug 15, 2023
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
QB_Eagles wrote:Mr B wrote:atlantabbq99 wrote:Brady doesn't have a big arm and can't run, he lives off of his IQ and pre snap reads. Mahomes lives off of his big arm, so what will happen when that goes away?
When Brett Favre lost his big arm in his 30s, he became a very average QB.
Mahomes also has the highest football IQ currently in the NFL. They has QB’d his team to 5 SB’s. You seriously think he’s lost his arm strength at 29 years old? Lol
No, Tanner McKee has the highest football IQ.

Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,553
- And1: 8,393
- Joined: Sep 10, 2021
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
I mean... He was pretty underwhelming all season long.
QB A: 3,928 yards - 26 TD 11 INT - 67.5 completion %
QB B: 3,878 yards - 25 TD 8 INT - 68.4 completion %
One of these guys got the absolute dog piss knocked out of them all night in SB 59 once the refs finally stopped extending their drives for them and the other guy is Derek Carr.
QB A: 3,928 yards - 26 TD 11 INT - 67.5 completion %
QB B: 3,878 yards - 25 TD 8 INT - 68.4 completion %
One of these guys got the absolute dog piss knocked out of them all night in SB 59 once the refs finally stopped extending their drives for them and the other guy is Derek Carr.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- Starter
- Posts: 2,202
- And1: 737
- Joined: Aug 15, 2023
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
JujitsuFlip wrote:I mean... He was pretty underwhelming all season long.
QB A: 3,928 yards - 26 TD 11 INT - 67.5 completion %
QB B: 3,878 yards - 25 TD 8 INT - 68.4 completion %
One of these guys got the absolute dog piss knocked out of them all night in SB 59 once the refs finally stopped extending their drives for them and the other guy is Derek Carr.
Kellen Moore looking at Derek carr like

Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
- Cactus Jack
- Forum Mod - Supersonics
- Posts: 31,659
- And1: 15,910
- Joined: Feb 25, 2015
- Location: The Last of Us Part II
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Jaydubb wrote:JujitsuFlip wrote:I mean... He was pretty underwhelming all season long.
QB A: 3,928 yards - 26 TD 11 INT - 67.5 completion %
QB B: 3,878 yards - 25 TD 8 INT - 68.4 completion %
One of these guys got the absolute dog piss knocked out of them all night in SB 59 once the refs finally stopped extending their drives for them and the other guy is Derek Carr.
Kellen Moore looking at Derek carr like
This tells me that Geno will be MVP of the league with Klint Kubiak as his OC.
Dominater wrote:Damn Cactus jack takin over
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
- hermes
- RealGM
- Posts: 96,157
- And1: 25,414
- Joined: Aug 27, 2007
- Location: the restaurant at the end of the universe
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/1in0fz7/the_2024_kansas_city_chiefs_had_the_highest/
if you go by expected pythagorean win percentage, the chiefs outperformed their expected record by even more than the 2022 vikings did - who everyone and their brother called a fraudulent team
looking at that, the chiefs were probably really lucky they even made it to the super bowl
if you go by expected pythagorean win percentage, the chiefs outperformed their expected record by even more than the 2022 vikings did - who everyone and their brother called a fraudulent team
looking at that, the chiefs were probably really lucky they even made it to the super bowl

Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- Starter
- Posts: 2,202
- And1: 737
- Joined: Aug 15, 2023
Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
hermes wrote:https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/comments/1in0fz7/the_2024_kansas_city_chiefs_had_the_highest/
if you go by expected pythagorean win percentage, the chiefs outperformed their expected record by even more than the 2022 vikings did - who everyone and their brother called a fraudulent team
looking at that, the chiefs were probably really lucky they even made it to the super bowl
The chiefs had 10 different 1 score games, 11 if you include the bills game in the AFCCG, so really things could’ve gone the other way but just so happened to bounce their way every single time.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
- RaoulDuke79
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,811
- And1: 5,057
- Joined: Jul 31, 2006
- Location: purchasing stunning amounts of pudding.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
It's the broccoli top. That **** will **** your head up...literally.
We watched the tragedy unfold. We did as we were told, we bought and sold. It was the greatest show on Earth...but then it was over.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 25,628
- And1: 10,881
- Joined: Jul 04, 2013
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
His arm looked fine on the two long TD passes.
He’s put on weight compared to even a couple of years ago but he still runs for big yards.
Maybe the pick 6 he threw, running right and throwing back towards the middle, isn’t an int a couple of years go when he’s lighter and throwing harder.
He misses Kelce from a couple of years ago who put up huge RAC. Let’s face it, ever since he got with Taylor, he’s not half the weapon he used to be. We can joke about the sex wearing him down but it’s age and probably focus, not being as hungry to be great.
He’s put on weight compared to even a couple of years ago but he still runs for big yards.
Maybe the pick 6 he threw, running right and throwing back towards the middle, isn’t an int a couple of years go when he’s lighter and throwing harder.
He misses Kelce from a couple of years ago who put up huge RAC. Let’s face it, ever since he got with Taylor, he’s not half the weapon he used to be. We can joke about the sex wearing him down but it’s age and probably focus, not being as hungry to be great.
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,395
- And1: 5,792
- Joined: Feb 10, 2021
-
Re: Is Patrick Mahomes on the Decline?
Mahomes was 8th in QBR this season and last season. He very clearly hasn't been the best QB the last two years. Allen and Lamar have surpassed him.
He's got limitations. Those other two have evolved and he's stayed the same. The problem for him is that you can only keep getting lucky for some. You can only have your special teams block game winning kicks, and win by single score games for so long. Eventually, those skill players on offense and defense get older.
He's got limitations. Those other two have evolved and he's stayed the same. The problem for him is that you can only keep getting lucky for some. You can only have your special teams block game winning kicks, and win by single score games for so long. Eventually, those skill players on offense and defense get older.
Return to The General NFL Board