RealGM's College Football All-American Team (QB Voting)

[A.J.]

Well, with the regular season over the All-American teams are coming out, so why not have our own college football forum all-american team. I will start a poll with the question who is your vote as First-Team All-American at each position (QB, RB, WR, TE, OT, OG, DE, DT, OLB, ILB, CB, S, K, P, RS). For positions where 2 players must be selected (RB, OT, OG, DE, DT, OLB, CB, and S) the 2 highest vote-getters will be placed on the college football forums all-american team. Each poll will be run for 2 days, with 8 nominees as your options in the polls. Hopefully this will be a good segment, that should spark some good, clean discussion and a fun thing to do.

Well first up is QB, and (in no order) the 8 nominees are

Sam Bradford, Oklahoma

48 TD's passing, 6 interceptions, 302-442 (68.3 completion %), 4,464 yards passing (343.4 per game), 10.1 yards per attempt, 186.30 passer rating, 40 carries, 65 yards, 1.63 yards per carry, 5 TD's

Colt McCoy, Texas

32 TD's passing, 7 interceptions, 291-375 (77.6 completion %), 3,445 yards passing (287.1 per game), 9.2 yards per attempt, 179.20 passer rating, 128 carries, 576 yards, 4.50 yards per carry, 10 TD's

Tim Tebow, Florida

28 TD's passing, 2 interceptions, 174-268 (64.9 completion %), 2,515 yards passing (193.5 per game), 9.4 yards per attempt, 176.75 passer rating, 154 carries, 564 yards, 3.66 yards per carry, 12 TD's

Graham Harrell, Texas Tech

41 TD's, 7 interceptions, 406-568 (71.5 completion %), 4,747 yards passing (395.6 per game), 8.4 yards per attempt, 163.04 passer rating, 35 carries, -58 yards, -1.66 yards per carry, 6 TD's

Zac Robinson, Oklahoma State

24 TD's passing, 8 interceptions, 177-264 (67.0 completion %), 2,735 yards passing (227.9 per game), 10.4 yards per attempt, 178.01 passer rating, 130 carries, 508 yards, 3.91 yards per carry, 7 TD's

Nate Davis, Ball State

26 TD's passing, 7 interceptions, 249-372 (66.9 completion %), 3,446 yards passing (265.1 per game), 9.3 yards per attempt, 164.05 passer rating, 57 carries, 277 yards, 4.86 yards per carry, 5 TD's

Chase Daniel, Missouri

37 TD's, 15 interceptions, 358-484 (74.0 completion %), 4,135 yards (318.1 per game), 8.5 yards per attempt, 164.76 passer rating, 60 carries, 252 yards, 1 TD

Notable Emissions
David Johnson, Tulsa
Mark Sanchez, USC
Daryll Clark, Penn State
Max Hall, BYU
Chase Clement, Rice
Case Keenum, Houston
Tim Hiller, Western Michigan
Todd Reesing, Kansas
Matt Stafford, Georgia
Joe Ganz, Nebraska
Trevor Vittaoe, UTEP

Vote Away!

[El Turco]

bradford.

[A.J.]

My vote has to be Bradford also. The guy was great this season. And winning the heisman won't hurt either.

[hermes]

harrell, because someone has too

[studcrackers]

bradford

[Da Schwab]

Colt McCoy

He should've won the Heisman, least I can do is give him my A-A vote.

[craig01]

Tebow.

Not taking away anything from the other guys, but the poll is about who is the best QB, and not the best passer.

[Da Schwab]

Tebow.

Not taking away anything from the other guys, but the poll is about who is the best QB, and not the best passer.

McCoy was a better game manager, and rushed for more yards and TDs than Tebow did.

[A.J.]

Can someone break the tie please? LOL

[El Turco]

i thought we were voting for a qb not a runningback.

[A.J.]

i thought we were voting for a qb not a runningback.

We are, but I posted the top 2 voter getters for QB will win,.

[Da Schwab]

i thought we were voting for a qb not a runningback.

We are, but I posted the top 2 voter getters for QB will win,.

Well that went over your head.

[El Turco]

i thought we were voting for a qb not a runningback.

We are, but I posted the top 2 voter getters for QB will win,.

i was referring to the notion of "running qb makes a better qb"

[LAKESHOW]

mark sanchez

[craig01]

LOL^^^^^^

Somehow I knew that was coming.

[craig01]

Tebow.

Not taking away anything from the other guys, but the poll is about who is the best QB, and not the best passer.

McCoy was a better game manager, and rushed for more yards and TDs than Tebow did.

Still doesn't matter.

Tebow was the best QB in the country this year.

It's about quarterbacking, not stats.

[El Turco]

this season bradford was better than tebow at everything quarterback should be doing which means he was better at "quarterbacking".

[Icness]

Apparently the poll ended already.

I would vote for Colt McCoy for doing more with less than Bradford or Tebow. Real strong year for college QBs.