tedbrogen wrote:
A few guys on that list are only top 25 when they have the ball in their hands (Booker, Beal, Mitchell, Irving, KAT, Westbrook, Young) and their overall impact is not legit top 25 when accounting for the fact they give some to a lot of it back on defense. I'd much rather have Jrue's two way impact over most of those type of players. Especially when pairing him with a couple ball dominant guys in Giannis and Middleton. (Not at all saying Jrue is a better asset than anyone listed, but he appears to me to be a better fit than almost anyone who isn't in the top 15 of that list)
Also, you listed Lowry in the top 20 and in the still on the board category. He's good but he's not two spots in the top 25 good.
My mistake on Lowry. Fixed it.
With that being said, fit vs. legitimate top 25 player, those are two separate arguments. I, personally, would take a guy like Beal over Holiday without giving a second thought to it. We've all seen Middleton's warts when it comes to ball dominance, and I think most would agree, that he's not the entirety of the answer when it comes to playoff time, so I guess I wouldn't consider Middleton's fit when it comes to adding another ball dominant player, given Middleton is more than capable of playing off the ball as well.
















