Scizzup wrote:mdenny wrote:Scizzup wrote:
OKC is not trading both Chet and JDub for anyone not named Wemby lol. Trading that for Giannis makes them a worse team now and the future. In the playoffs half court creation matters more and Giannis is not a top guy when it comes to it, its why Bucks have had troubles vs great defense in past. Shai does not shoot enough 3s for that duo to just out talent you. Teams would be able to defend them even easier.
if I am OKC I get a big movement wing shooter, they don't need another star. They have dominated this series despite being 1-2 and likely will still win it. If Presti got a Trey Murphy or even Cam Johnson, they are up 3-0. consolidate 2 role players for a better one.
Respectfully disagree. Chet and Jdub are at the very peak of their hype years. All that hype turns to jaded disappointment for 4th and 5th year players. Scotty is a good example. A year ago ppl were talking about him potentially being top 10 (which was crazy). Now many ppl are saying he isn't the worth the max rookie extension (also crazy).
This pattern is like clockwork.
You just wrote **** that is not based in logic. Chet is 22 and JDub is 23 years old. They are not even close to their peak. Jdub is better than Shai was at the same age btw, not that progression is linear.
Chet is the 2nd best defender in the league healthy and he has not even put on weight or improved his creation yet. Who tf is saying Chet or Jdub ain't worth the 25% max? Chet has a higher ceiling than Mobley/Barnes to me. The injury this year really hurt his development but as a rookie he had a defensive season as good as Mobley best and a better season than Barnes ever did, period. Chet ceiling is an all time defender that can punish mismatch and space the floor. These freak rim protectors that can hold up in switches are unicorns (defending the rim is the most impactful part of defense). You have to look at Chet value from the defensive end. He is not a
number 1 option on offense.
OKC is down this series because they have made stupid clutch mistakes and shot the 3 ball poorly. They have shot the 3 ball 4% worse than Nuggets and made 1 less 3 pointer. This should not be the case looking at both rosters so maybe shooting variance flips soon.
Edit: seen this is more of a Scottie post, well I never envisioned Scottie as a top 10 player. He does not check any of the boxes when it comes to super elite defense, playmaking, or self creation. Chet and even Mobley does with defense.
Chet is 23 and Jdubs is 24. Jdubs is actually older than Scottie.
Chet put up nearly identical numbers to last year and has had issues staying healthy in the past. You’re wildly overrating Chet. You’re looking at shot blocking and ignoring many other aspects to good defensive play. Look at how easily Jokic backed down Chet. Same with AG. He’s a great defender, no doubt but not DPOY upside.
And no, Jdubs was not better than Shai at the same age. Jdubs relies heavily on SGA. The whole team does. The increased boxscore numbers were a result of more volume, his efficiency got a lot worse.
We know what kind of players these guys are. Both of them are fantastic players but neither have top 10 upside.
I certainly wouldn’t trade both for Giannis though. One of them along with a guy like Ihart and picks make it work. It could even involve less.