ImageImageImageImageImage

Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better?

Moderators: DG88, niQ, Duffman100, tsherkin, Reeko, lebron stopper, HiJiNX, Morris_Shatford, 7 Footer

PushDaRock
RealGM
Posts: 13,721
And1: 10,398
Joined: Jun 22, 2011

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#481 » by PushDaRock » Mon Mar 31, 2025 2:44 pm

ConSarnit wrote:
PushDaRock wrote:Maybe we can look at Deni Avdija as a possible example of someone that looked fairly hopeless as a shooter and has turned it around. His first 3 seasons, he shot 31.5%, 31.7% and 29.7% from 3 all on 1 make per game. Last 2 seasons, he's improved to 37.4% on 1.2 makes and this season 36.9% on 1.7 makes. Being at least a passable 3 point shooter has also opened up Avdija's driving game as he gets to the rim more and draws a lot more fouls since improving his shooting. In doing so, he went from sub 53 TS% career in his first 3 years to 60 TS% in his last 2 years. Not saying this is likely for Scottie but it is in the realm of possibility.


I’d say it’s possible but I’d add a caveat: Avdija is a case where he’s shifted the majority of his 3’s to “wide open” attempts. Here are his “wide open” stats over the years:

32%
39%
33%
44%
35%

Now compare that to Barnes:

29%
30%
39%
30%

The fact that Barnes can’t even hit in wide open situations is concerning. Even if we try and shift Barnes 3pt attempts to only “wide open” it still doesn’t really extrapolate to even an “average” 3pt shooter. Barnes is starting from an even lower place than Avdija. Now, we can definitely cut out some of Barnes ATB 3’s but then he get shifted to the corner (there are other guys much more suited for that role) and his corner shooting is way below league average so I worry he won’t get guarded at all from there either. It is currently looking like a difficult road to get Barnes to a player that needs to be guarded from 3 (I say this more in terms of playoffs. If he can shoot 33% in the regular season we can survive that).

I worry that we’d have to drop his 3pt volume so low that he’s still a complete non-factor. If he’s only taking 2 3pa per36 that is such low volume that I doubt it moves the needle at all. Barnes need to be able to make 35% of his 3’s and be taking at least 3-4 per game to make any kind of dent. It’s sort of the JV corollary: being able to hit 0.7 3’s per game isn’t really valuable because there are still far more possessions the defense will benefit from not guarding you at all. Effective 3pt shooting is both volume and 3pt%.


Honestly he's just a frustrating player to try and build an offense around, fair question would be if we would even try to if he didn't have his draft pedigree and now a max contract pending. With his current skill set, we are trying to squeeze blood from a stone. There's just nothing he does at an above average level we can increase the frequency of sustainably, the best thing he does is score on size mismatches which isn't something you can design an offense around. Simply put, he needs to improve his shooting. You need to be a Zion or Giannis, basically be a freak of nature to overcome a lack of shooting as a non C.
User avatar
Hero
RealGM
Posts: 38,322
And1: 53,515
Joined: Apr 05, 2012
Location: Edward Gardens
 

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#482 » by Hero » Mon Mar 31, 2025 3:14 pm

DKB333 wrote:I am worred. He has not taken a step, little own a leap and we are nearing the end of year four. He fluctuates between good seasons and bad seasons. Is it time to just admit he is a great player but not going to ever be the guy? A rich mans Odom/Iguodala.


Are we even sure he will be a rich man's Iguoadala. It isn't looking that promising.
johanliebert
RealGM
Posts: 10,516
And1: 6,017
Joined: Jun 16, 2015
 

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#483 » by johanliebert » Mon Mar 31, 2025 4:00 pm

It took a few years for this board to have realistic expectations.

Some went as far as downplaying how good Bosh was or slandering DeRozan for the new toy. Thats why this team has no culture.
User avatar
Indeed
RealGM
Posts: 21,722
And1: 3,623
Joined: Aug 21, 2009

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#484 » by Indeed » Mon Mar 31, 2025 4:08 pm

Oakvillehoops wrote:Every day I wish we had traded Rookie Scottie for KD.

Imagine watching

FVV/OG/KD/Siakam/Poetl over the pathetic going no where rebuild we’ve been doing. Would have been a real contender.

We still could have unloaded that entire team for assets to start again at anytime.


To match the salary, we will need to give up either Anunoby or Siakam or VanVleet, so it is just more of a rumour.
User avatar
Tha Cynic
RealGM
Posts: 26,690
And1: 28,607
Joined: Jan 03, 2006
Location: Starin' at the world through my rearview
     

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#485 » by Tha Cynic » Mon Mar 31, 2025 4:51 pm

Indeed wrote:
Tripod wrote:Honest question, who on the Raps draws teams top defenders?


Barrett so far was guarded by the opposing best player most of the time, mainly before we were fully healthy.
His TS% dropped around the time we started to tank (or since Quickley came back and took some of his usage?), but his TS% was around average (not your 1st option around 60%, but around 57%/58%) with transition and PnR type of offense.



Where are you getting this from? Teams are definitely not using their best defender on Barrett. In fact defenses typically don’t overreact to RJ as his game is pretty limited so they play him for the drive and generally seem fine letting him score if he does get there.
Kobe Bryant:You asked for my hustle - I gave you my heart, because it came with so much more."~Kobe #MambaOut
gbball
Starter
Posts: 2,208
And1: 2,393
Joined: Oct 23, 2009

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#486 » by gbball » Mon Mar 31, 2025 4:52 pm

Barnes is getting better, he is putting himself in better position for good shots, BUT, he is very bad at converting. The thing that I find concerning is his lack of touch at the rim. He smokes a lot of easy layups...but I do think he'll improve.

He's not a natural though, everything he gets he's going to have to work hard for. The process is improving and he's getting to better spots and at least giving himself pretty good looks.

There's no guarantee he ever finds a spot where he's automatic. Even on layups. I hope he figures it out though, progression isn't linear.
tsherkin
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 92,454
And1: 32,021
Joined: Oct 14, 2003
 

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#487 » by tsherkin » Mon Mar 31, 2025 5:03 pm

gbball wrote:Barnes is getting better, he is putting himself in better position for good shots, BUT, he is very bad at converting. The thing that I find concerning is his lack of touch at the rim. He smokes a lot of easy layups...but I do think he'll improve.

He's not a natural though, everything he gets he's going to have to work hard for. The process is improving and he's getting to better spots and at least giving himself pretty good looks.

There's no guarantee he ever finds a spot where he's automatic. Even on layups. I hope he figures it out though, progression isn't linear.


All of this very clearly paints the picture that he isn't That Guy (TM). Aka, he isn't an intelligent option as a volume scorer.
User avatar
Indeed
RealGM
Posts: 21,722
And1: 3,623
Joined: Aug 21, 2009

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#488 » by Indeed » Mon Mar 31, 2025 5:16 pm

Tha Cynic wrote:
Indeed wrote:
Tripod wrote:Honest question, who on the Raps draws teams top defenders?


Barrett so far was guarded by the opposing best player most of the time, mainly before we were fully healthy.
His TS% dropped around the time we started to tank (or since Quickley came back and took some of his usage?), but his TS% was around average (not your 1st option around 60%, but around 57%/58%) with transition and PnR type of offense.



Where are you getting this from? Teams are definitely not using their best defender on Barrett. In fact defenses typically don’t overreact to RJ as his game is pretty limited so they play him for the drive and generally seem fine letting him score if he does get there.


Gosh, people don't watch games and claim he wasn't guarded by the best defenders?
Please go watch the games, I fking watched every single Raptors games this year (except the last 3 not finished).
YogurtProducer
RealGM
Posts: 30,112
And1: 32,899
Joined: Jul 22, 2013
Location: Saskatchewan
       

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#489 » by YogurtProducer » Mon Mar 31, 2025 5:22 pm

Indeed wrote:
Oakvillehoops wrote:Every day I wish we had traded Rookie Scottie for KD.

Imagine watching

FVV/OG/KD/Siakam/Poetl over the pathetic going no where rebuild we’ve been doing. Would have been a real contender.

We still could have unloaded that entire team for assets to start again at anytime.


To match the salary, we will need to give up either Anunoby or Siakam or VanVleet, so it is just more of a rumour.

Yeah it was like Barnes AND fvv AND og if I remember correctly. Salaries didn't work any other way.

It was never just Barnes for KD.
What an absolute failure and disaster this franchise is, ran by one of the most incompetent front offices in the league.
- Raptors RealGM Forum re: Masai Ujiri - June 2023
tsherkin
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 92,454
And1: 32,021
Joined: Oct 14, 2003
 

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#490 » by tsherkin » Mon Mar 31, 2025 5:39 pm

YogurtProducer wrote:
Indeed wrote:
Oakvillehoops wrote:Every day I wish we had traded Rookie Scottie for KD.

Imagine watching

FVV/OG/KD/Siakam/Poetl over the pathetic going no where rebuild we’ve been doing. Would have been a real contender.

We still could have unloaded that entire team for assets to start again at anytime.


To match the salary, we will need to give up either Anunoby or Siakam or VanVleet, so it is just more of a rumour.

Yeah it was like Barnes AND fvv AND og if I remember correctly. Salaries didn't work any other way.

It was never just Barnes for KD.


It's moot now, anyway. Though to be fair, not everything is some tragic secret failure on Masai's behalf. Sometimes, it just really didn't make sense at the time with the actual salary considerations, for sure.
dballislife
RealGM
Posts: 14,667
And1: 5,716
Joined: Jan 24, 2010

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#491 » by dballislife » Mon Mar 31, 2025 5:57 pm

before this season, inside my mind i thought scottie would be 21ppg, i cant believe he probably end it at 18 something
adhir
Sophomore
Posts: 126
And1: 186
Joined: Jan 24, 2014
     

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#492 » by adhir » Mon Mar 31, 2025 6:05 pm

based solely on the eye test (advanced stats guys - dont blast me)

he is the new Lowry - but he needs a Kawhi - hes Draymond Green on steroids. He will defend for you - score when he has to - and need to be respected on offence. He can be the heart of the team - but needs a true best player. Get him his Kawhi and we will shoot right back up the rankings and become a contender. He is effectively the second best player on a championship level team.
tsherkin
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 92,454
And1: 32,021
Joined: Oct 14, 2003
 

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#493 » by tsherkin » Mon Mar 31, 2025 6:14 pm

adhir wrote:based solely on the eye test (advanced stats guys - dont blast me)

he is the new Lowry


Gently, there isn't really much to suggest that he's got that sort of potential. Lowry had a BUNCH of things going for him before he started to get settled and have the opportunity to show through. In particular, he had some specific skills to draw upon which made for a strong foundation to lever as a decent scorer. That's the stuff Barnes lacks. Kyle was quick, handled well, and was extremely good at drawing fouls. Scottie doesn't have any of that, although he isn't a BAD ball-handler, and has improved a little there.

- but he needs a Kawhi - hes Draymond Green on steroids.


And again, there isn't a ton supporting that. Draymond is a former DPOY, and while Scottie's good, he isn't that level of defender. So the idea that he's Draymond on steroids because he shoots more at crap efficiency isn't really a viable comparison.

He will defend for you - score when he has to - and need to be respected on offence. He can be the heart of the team - but needs a true best player. Get him his Kawhi and we will shoot right back up the rankings and become a contender. He is effectively the second best player on a championship level team.


And again, "second best player on a championship level team" seems very generous right now. He looks like a 3rd or 4th guy right at the moment. Leastwise without LARGE changes in his offensive profile.
Tripod
RealGM
Posts: 12,649
And1: 12,091
Joined: Aug 13, 2021
 

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#494 » by Tripod » Mon Mar 31, 2025 9:32 pm

Indeed wrote:
Tha Cynic wrote:
Indeed wrote:
Barrett so far was guarded by the opposing best player most of the time, mainly before we were fully healthy.
His TS% dropped around the time we started to tank (or since Quickley came back and took some of his usage?), but his TS% was around average (not your 1st option around 60%, but around 57%/58%) with transition and PnR type of offense.



Where are you getting this from? Teams are definitely not using their best defender on Barrett. In fact defenses typically don’t overreact to RJ as his game is pretty limited so they play him for the drive and generally seem fine letting him score if he does get there.


Gosh, people don't watch games and claim he wasn't guarded by the best defenders?
Please go watch the games, I fking watched every single Raptors games this year (except the last 3 not finished).

So...conflicting opinions. I know against Memphis it was JJJ on Barnes. Against NY it was OG.

I am wondering what the STATS say.
dballislife
RealGM
Posts: 14,667
And1: 5,716
Joined: Jan 24, 2010

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#495 » by dballislife » Mon Mar 31, 2025 9:38 pm

Tha Cynic wrote:
Indeed wrote:
Tripod wrote:Honest question, who on the Raps draws teams top defenders?


Barrett so far was guarded by the opposing best player most of the time, mainly before we were fully healthy.
His TS% dropped around the time we started to tank (or since Quickley came back and took some of his usage?), but his TS% was around average (not your 1st option around 60%, but around 57%/58%) with transition and PnR type of offense.



Where are you getting this from? Teams are definitely not using their best defender on Barrett. In fact defenses typically don’t overreact to RJ as his game is pretty limited so they play him for the drive and generally seem fine letting him score if he does get there.


sometimes, i remember playing magic and franz was on rj and when playing hawks dyson was on rj
Tripod
RealGM
Posts: 12,649
And1: 12,091
Joined: Aug 13, 2021
 

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#496 » by Tripod » Mon Mar 31, 2025 9:56 pm

dballislife wrote:
Tha Cynic wrote:
Indeed wrote:
Barrett so far was guarded by the opposing best player most of the time, mainly before we were fully healthy.
His TS% dropped around the time we started to tank (or since Quickley came back and took some of his usage?), but his TS% was around average (not your 1st option around 60%, but around 57%/58%) with transition and PnR type of offense.



Where are you getting this from? Teams are definitely not using their best defender on Barrett. In fact defenses typically don’t overreact to RJ as his game is pretty limited so they play him for the drive and generally seem fine letting him score if he does get there.


sometimes, i remember playing magic and franz was on rj and when playing hawks dyson was on rj

Yeah maybe it depends on other teams top defenders and if they are guards or forwards.

I was just wondering what the stats say...and if it was 50/50, 60/40, 70/30...and for who. Not sure if there is a stat that would give us that info.

Either way, adding BI is going to help everyone as he likely will get that top attention next year.
tsherkin
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 92,454
And1: 32,021
Joined: Oct 14, 2003
 

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#497 » by tsherkin » Mon Mar 31, 2025 10:13 pm

Tripod wrote:Either way, adding BI is going to help everyone as he likely will get that top attention next year.


BI is definitely going to positively alter our spacing and change defensive attention.

What worries me is that Scottie wasn't actually efficient even in his first two seasons, when he was taking 12, 13 FGA/g and had no reputation at all. I have to wonder how much BI will do for Barnes' scoring when he wasn't any good even when he had no real responsibility.
User avatar
Tha Cynic
RealGM
Posts: 26,690
And1: 28,607
Joined: Jan 03, 2006
Location: Starin' at the world through my rearview
     

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#498 » by Tha Cynic » Mon Mar 31, 2025 10:36 pm

tsherkin wrote:
Tripod wrote:Either way, adding BI is going to help everyone as he likely will get that top attention next year.


BI is definitely going to positively alter our spacing and change defensive attention.

What worries me is that Scottie wasn't actually efficient even in his first two seasons, when he was taking 12, 13 FGA/g and had no reputation at all. I have to wonder how much BI will do for Barnes' scoring when he wasn't any good even when he had no real responsibility.


The team has 3 offense first (maybe even offense only) guys in the starting lineup. It’s not much of a concern at all. Barnes has always been more willing to expend his energy on defense while becoming more aggressive in spurts on offense. This is essentially how he was used for his entire time under Nurse, other than the first season after Van Vleet left. They changed that back too when Siakam didn’t do too well standing in the corners. It’s not like we’re built around one guy. The other guys like to score more than defend. Seems like it will work out fine.
Kobe Bryant:You asked for my hustle - I gave you my heart, because it came with so much more."~Kobe #MambaOut
tsherkin
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 92,454
And1: 32,021
Joined: Oct 14, 2003
 

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#499 » by tsherkin » Mon Mar 31, 2025 10:40 pm

Tha Cynic wrote:The team has 3 offense first (maybe even offense only) guys in the starting lineup. It’s not much of a concern at all. Barnes has always been more willing to expend his energy on defense while becoming more offensive aggressive in spurts on offense. The other guys like to score more than defend. Seems like it will work out fine.




Mmmm. At a quarter of the cap, his contract and value start to change my thinking on that. A defensive player who will have the ball less and less (and will lose even further value without the ball because it will eat into his playmaking) shouldn't be taking up that much of our pay roll, I guess is the thought.

Otherwise, he's literally nothing but a defensive roleplayer who can't space.
User avatar
Tha Cynic
RealGM
Posts: 26,690
And1: 28,607
Joined: Jan 03, 2006
Location: Starin' at the world through my rearview
     

Re: Elephant in the room but isn't Barnes suppose to be getting better? 

Post#500 » by Tha Cynic » Mon Mar 31, 2025 10:43 pm

tsherkin wrote:
Tha Cynic wrote:The team has 3 offense first (maybe even offense only) guys in the starting lineup. It’s not much of a concern at all. Barnes has always been more willing to expend his energy on defense while becoming more offensive aggressive in spurts on offense. The other guys like to score more than defend. Seems like it will work out fine.




Mmmm. At a quarter of the cap, his contract and value start to change my thinking on that. A defensive player who will have the ball less and less (and will lose even further value without the ball because it will eat into his playmaking) shouldn't be taking up that much of our pay roll, I guess is the thought.

Otherwise, he's literally nothing but a defensive roleplayer who can't space.


Good thing is there’s tons of room for growth. They have him trying different things on offense rather than just bottling him up. Typically the guys who stop developing are guys teams put into a box and have them focus on a couple of things as role players. That’s where people disagree. I don’t think he’s just always going to be inefficient as he has been taking the shots he will need to take to get to the next level. We’ll see what happens. We’re not a team that will be impatient with the development of the accuracy imo.

I think there’s a lot of doom and gloom over nothing. The player is a very good player lol
Kobe Bryant:You asked for my hustle - I gave you my heart, because it came with so much more."~Kobe #MambaOut

Return to Toronto Raptors