ImageImageImageImageImage

Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league

Moderators: DG88, niQ, Duffman100, tsherkin, Reeko, lebron stopper, HiJiNX, Morris_Shatford, 7 Footer

Do you think Scottie Barnes can be the best player on a championship team?

Yes
107
36%
No
191
64%
 
Total votes: 298

Harcore Fenton Mun
RealGM
Posts: 14,380
And1: 8,457
Joined: Jul 17, 2006

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#601 » by Harcore Fenton Mun » Sat Aug 9, 2025 6:48 pm

DreamTeam09 wrote:
Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:
HangTime wrote:I think people are so confused by Scottie, and the group of players we have, because they are so focused on the current style of play.

There is so many interesting combinations here for a futuristic style, on both sides of the ball.

Scottie/Ingram/CMB might be my favourite trio. The traditional three point doesn't bother me one bit, even with Jakob in there.

For as much as they like to pass, I don't think there will be "over passing" between Scottie and CMB.

If we aren't paying BI 47M going forward. He's basically a two year rental.


Bi is owed 38 40 41, Barnes will touch 47 for one yr of his deal, the last yr, 5yrs from now.
No need to embellish

BI's got two and a player option. Rich Paul's his agent. It writes itself imo.
Image
User avatar
Thaddy
Head Coach
Posts: 6,806
And1: 3,959
Joined: Dec 12, 2022

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#602 » by Thaddy » Sat Aug 9, 2025 7:45 pm

Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:
DreamTeam09 wrote:
Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:If we aren't paying BI 47M going forward. He's basically a two year rental.


Bi is owed 38 40 41, Barnes will touch 47 for one yr of his deal, the last yr, 5yrs from now.
No need to embellish

BI's got two and a player option. Rich Paul's his agent. It writes itself imo.

He's also a poor man's Durant. It's a worthy risk to take. If we can load manage him we will have him fresh for the play in. It'll also give us more of a developmental curve. We will have CMB, Mogbo, Agbaji, Dick, and Walter who can slide in (due to Barnes versatility).

I would say this was well thought out and the numbers have been proven to be meaningless by several posters. I would also gauge the numbers based on league wide reports of other new deals. It's not the right way to do it, you need to look at it against the overall percentage.

That being said I don't expect Ingram to be someone who gets a finals MVP and lead us into contention. I think it's a good short range move to go from lottery team to pretender. We need to make that leap and establish a winning culture again. Then look at how we can make another jump.

The ultimate hope should be that CMB and Dick can develop into all star talents which can then be paired with Scottie. This isn't a terrible plan if Dick and CMB show they can be top 5 from their strong draft classes. It would give us 3 players in Barnes, CMB, and Dick who can be the stars and we can deal our other assets like Ingram, IQ, and RJ for pieces to put around them.
Harcore Fenton Mun
RealGM
Posts: 14,380
And1: 8,457
Joined: Jul 17, 2006

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#603 » by Harcore Fenton Mun » Sat Aug 9, 2025 9:36 pm

Thaddy wrote:
Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:
DreamTeam09 wrote:
Bi is owed 38 40 41, Barnes will touch 47 for one yr of his deal, the last yr, 5yrs from now.
No need to embellish

BI's got two and a player option. Rich Paul's his agent. It writes itself imo.

He's also a poor man's Durant. It's a worthy risk to take. If we can load manage him we will have him fresh for the play in. It'll also give us more of a developmental curve. We will have CMB, Mogbo, Agbaji, Dick, and Walter who can slide in (due to Barnes versatility).

I would say this was well thought out and the numbers have been proven to be meaningless by several posters. I would also gauge the numbers based on league wide reports of other new deals. It's not the right way to do it, you need to look at it against the overall percentage.

That being said I don't expect Ingram to be someone who gets a finals MVP and lead us into contention. I think it's a good short range move to go from lottery team to pretender. We need to make that leap and establish a winning culture again. Then look at how we can make another jump.

The ultimate hope should be that CMB and Dick can develop into all star talents which can then be paired with Scottie. This isn't a terrible plan if Dick and CMB show they can be top 5 from their strong draft classes. It would give us 3 players in Barnes, CMB, and Dick who can be the stars and we can deal our other assets like Ingram, IQ, and RJ for pieces to put around them.

Rich man's Lou Williams. With Rich Paul as an agent.

If you remember Rich Paul before Masai, it can get ugly.
Image
User avatar
Thaddy
Head Coach
Posts: 6,806
And1: 3,959
Joined: Dec 12, 2022

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#604 » by Thaddy » Sat Aug 9, 2025 9:59 pm

Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:
Thaddy wrote:
Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:BI's got two and a player option. Rich Paul's his agent. It writes itself imo.

He's also a poor man's Durant. It's a worthy risk to take. If we can load manage him we will have him fresh for the play in. It'll also give us more of a developmental curve. We will have CMB, Mogbo, Agbaji, Dick, and Walter who can slide in (due to Barnes versatility).

I would say this was well thought out and the numbers have been proven to be meaningless by several posters. I would also gauge the numbers based on league wide reports of other new deals. It's not the right way to do it, you need to look at it against the overall percentage.

That being said I don't expect Ingram to be someone who gets a finals MVP and lead us into contention. I think it's a good short range move to go from lottery team to pretender. We need to make that leap and establish a winning culture again. Then look at how we can make another jump.

The ultimate hope should be that CMB and Dick can develop into all star talents which can then be paired with Scottie. This isn't a terrible plan if Dick and CMB show they can be top 5 from their strong draft classes. It would give us 3 players in Barnes, CMB, and Dick who can be the stars and we can deal our other assets like Ingram, IQ, and RJ for pieces to put around them.

Rich man's Lou Williams. With Rich Paul as an agent.

If you remember Rich Paul before Masai, it can get ugly.

A bigger rich man's Lou Will is worth the money and what we gave up.
Harcore Fenton Mun
RealGM
Posts: 14,380
And1: 8,457
Joined: Jul 17, 2006

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#605 » by Harcore Fenton Mun » Sat Aug 9, 2025 10:07 pm

Thaddy wrote:
Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:
Thaddy wrote:He's also a poor man's Durant. It's a worthy risk to take. If we can load manage him we will have him fresh for the play in. It'll also give us more of a developmental curve. We will have CMB, Mogbo, Agbaji, Dick, and Walter who can slide in (due to Barnes versatility).

I would say this was well thought out and the numbers have been proven to be meaningless by several posters. I would also gauge the numbers based on league wide reports of other new deals. It's not the right way to do it, you need to look at it against the overall percentage.

That being said I don't expect Ingram to be someone who gets a finals MVP and lead us into contention. I think it's a good short range move to go from lottery team to pretender. We need to make that leap and establish a winning culture again. Then look at how we can make another jump.

The ultimate hope should be that CMB and Dick can develop into all star talents which can then be paired with Scottie. This isn't a terrible plan if Dick and CMB show they can be top 5 from their strong draft classes. It would give us 3 players in Barnes, CMB, and Dick who can be the stars and we can deal our other assets like Ingram, IQ, and RJ for pieces to put around them.

Rich man's Lou Williams. With Rich Paul as an agent.

If you remember Rich Paul before Masai, it can get ugly.

A bigger rich man's Lou Will is worth the money and what we gave up.

Everybody's going to love the offense when he plays. But if the future ask is 47M+, like he wanted. We're going to ultimately be sellers.
Image
DreamTeam09
RealGM
Posts: 17,581
And1: 10,948
Joined: Jan 06, 2009
Location: Scarborough
 

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#606 » by DreamTeam09 » Sat Aug 9, 2025 11:03 pm

Thaddy wrote:
Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:
Thaddy wrote:He's also a poor man's Durant. It's a worthy risk to take. If we can load manage him we will have him fresh for the play in. It'll also give us more of a developmental curve. We will have CMB, Mogbo, Agbaji, Dick, and Walter who can slide in (due to Barnes versatility).

I would say this was well thought out and the numbers have been proven to be meaningless by several posters. I would also gauge the numbers based on league wide reports of other new deals. It's not the right way to do it, you need to look at it against the overall percentage.

That being said I don't expect Ingram to be someone who gets a finals MVP and lead us into contention. I think it's a good short range move to go from lottery team to pretender. We need to make that leap and establish a winning culture again. Then look at how we can make another jump.

The ultimate hope should be that CMB and Dick can develop into all star talents which can then be paired with Scottie. This isn't a terrible plan if Dick and CMB show they can be top 5 from their strong draft classes. It would give us 3 players in Barnes, CMB, and Dick who can be the stars and we can deal our other assets like Ingram, IQ, and RJ for pieces to put around them.

Rich man's Lou Williams. With Rich Paul as an agent.

If you remember Rich Paul before Masai, it can get ugly.

A bigger rich man's Lou Will is worth the money and what we gave up.


His floor is already being a way better passer than Lou will ever was, that's not a good comparable, clearly homeboy is down, which is his prerogative, when we are good I just hope everyone admits it & doesn't move the goal post in some silly manner
Image

In Raptor Ball I Trust
DreamTeam09
RealGM
Posts: 17,581
And1: 10,948
Joined: Jan 06, 2009
Location: Scarborough
 

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#607 » by DreamTeam09 » Sat Aug 9, 2025 11:17 pm



- Took too many pull up 3s (I think that's a good thing in a transition year, should drop back down with a healthy Bi n Quickly)
- Wasn't really good as the PnR ball handler (Again, more reps in a lost year)
- Exceptional defender, future all NBA defender,
- able to sag off and get back out to the perimeter
-Great ball denier while having a high usg
-Bi will make Scottie better because now teams gotta put their best defender on BI
-Scottie will blow by bigs and bully smaller players
-Gotta keep his dribble alive more because he's deadly going down hill, exceptional driver
-teams can't help off of BI at the nail, can't help off of quickly, RJ will have to hit 3s continue to cut & finish
-Good repport with Jakob
.
+ Many many more
Image

In Raptor Ball I Trust
bartron_44
Junior
Posts: 267
And1: 178
Joined: Oct 30, 2018
     

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#608 » by bartron_44 » Sat Aug 9, 2025 11:28 pm

The question isnt BI’s offense. Its can they get him to play the kind of defense we saw in SL from the backups. Same question I have about Quickley…and to a lesser extent, Barrett. If they can, they will be worth the price. If they can’t, they are just sever overpays they will need to get rid of. And considering they traded OG and Siakam for those guys, I really hope at least one or two work out.
User avatar
LBJKB24MJ23
RealGM
Posts: 23,332
And1: 21,682
Joined: Jan 22, 2014
Location: Bermuda
     

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#609 » by LBJKB24MJ23 » Sun Aug 10, 2025 2:54 am

i think thats why they got Ingram.
raf1995 wrote:I just don’t think he has that kind of potential. I think we will regret not trading him for a haul in a few years when he’s a mid-tier starter with nice playmaking and defense and a shaky jumper.
Harcore Fenton Mun
RealGM
Posts: 14,380
And1: 8,457
Joined: Jul 17, 2006

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#610 » by Harcore Fenton Mun » Sun Aug 10, 2025 3:22 am

LBJKB24MJ23 wrote:i think thats why they got Ingram.

Superstar!
Image
Image
Image
dballislife
RealGM
Posts: 14,763
And1: 5,781
Joined: Jan 24, 2010

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#611 » by dballislife » Sun Aug 10, 2025 4:09 am

scottie has all nba defense, he can also drop 6 dimes maybe even 7 in prime, can grab 8 boards too, and potentially avg around that rare 1.5 1.5 stocks

barnes with all of this going on, he can give you a efficient 18-20 at ages 25-32 and be a superstar

he just needs a great franchise to put the correct help around him, and so far we doing a good job, hes surrounded by a lot of young scoring and shooting
Los_29
RealGM
Posts: 15,245
And1: 13,860
Joined: Apr 10, 2021

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#612 » by Los_29 » Sun Aug 10, 2025 4:26 am

dballislife wrote:scottie has all nba defense, he can also drop 6 dimes maybe even 7 in prime, can grab 8 boards too, and potentially avg around that rare 1.5 1.5 stocks

barnes with all of this going on, he can give you a efficient 18-20 at ages 25-32 and be a superstar

he just needs a great franchise to put the correct help around him, and so far we doing a good job, hes surrounded by a lot of young scoring and shooting


He’s never been an efficient scorer in his career. That’s the one concern. He wasn’t even efficient when his role was reduced.

I’m optimistic that with BI and IQ healthy, Scottie will be more efficient in a reduced role. Combine that with his defense and that’s a great player.
dballislife
RealGM
Posts: 14,763
And1: 5,781
Joined: Jan 24, 2010

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#613 » by dballislife » Sun Aug 10, 2025 5:10 am

Los_29 wrote:
dballislife wrote:scottie has all nba defense, he can also drop 6 dimes maybe even 7 in prime, can grab 8 boards too, and potentially avg around that rare 1.5 1.5 stocks

barnes with all of this going on, he can give you a efficient 18-20 at ages 25-32 and be a superstar

he just needs a great franchise to put the correct help around him, and so far we doing a good job, hes surrounded by a lot of young scoring and shooting


He’s never been an efficient scorer in his career. That’s the one concern. He wasn’t even efficient when his role was reduced.

I’m optimistic that with BI and IQ healthy, Scottie will be more efficient in a reduced role. Combine that with his defense and that’s a great player.


at his developing 20-24 years in league though, so yes his efficiency hasn't been great.....we not asking for a efficient 23-25, but a efficient 18-20 in his prime years is totally possible
tsherkin
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 92,570
And1: 32,091
Joined: Oct 14, 2003
 

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#614 » by tsherkin » Sun Aug 10, 2025 9:38 am

dballislife wrote:at his developing 20-24 years in league though, so yes his efficiency hasn't been great.....we not asking for a efficient 23-25, but a efficient 18-20 in his prime years is totally possible


It is, however, quite unlikely unless something very significant about him changes. Meantime, "hasn't been great" is a little bit of a euphemism. In two of his seasons, he's been DISASTROUSLY inefficient, not "hasn't been great." One at reduced volume, one at volume. The main hope at this point is that he can become a league-average-efficiency scorer, so he could potentially become a reasonable second or third option. And that's likely to be a long wait, given what skills and tools he has and hasn't shown. How long do we want to wait to see if he can turn himself into Demar on offense, statistically speaking? Or do we want to pivot now, and start working on ways to make him viable in his role at the 4, functioning as a connecting passer and a strong defensive presence, so we can start getting value out of him earlier, you know what I mean?
YogurtProducer
RealGM
Posts: 30,159
And1: 32,932
Joined: Jul 22, 2013
Location: Saskatchewan
       

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#615 » by YogurtProducer » Sun Aug 10, 2025 3:16 pm

ConSarnit wrote:
YogurtProducer wrote:
ConSarnit wrote:Tailoring his shot diet doesn’t breed much optimism in my mind. We’re having the same talks about RJ. So now instead of having guys who create advantages for other players we’re talking about having to put players in roles to help themselves instead of the team as a whole.

I get we have to work with what we’ve got but it’s not overly confidence inspiring. If we’re paying guys $25m+ we need improvement, not mitigation.

I mean, yeah, why wouldn't we want to put guys in positions for them to succeed rather than in a role above their capabilities?

Getting Ingram, as well IQ back from injury, should in turn help RJ and Barnes both slot in more naturally on a pecking order. Ingram and IQ are by far our best 2 creators on the team, and that should mean the "harder" possessions get soaked up by them and hopefully it means efficiency gains for RJ + Barnes.

That is not "mitigation" it is just better utilization.


How is putting Barnes in the corner better for us? He’s being put there by default because he’s terrible ATB. So in an effort to bump up Barnes’ efficiency we have to put him in the corner where he is also a below average 3pt shooter. How does that help the rest of the team? Trying to boost Barnes efficiency doesn’t help the rest of the team. It’s pretty clear that reducing the offensive roles of guys like Barnes or Barrett is not conducive to helping a team overall. They aren’t good off-ball players and as such that creates other down stream issues for everyone due to lack of spacing. If the idea is “boost their efficiency to up their trade value” then it makes sense but if the idea is “give poor off ball players more off ball possessions” then that’s not really helping the team.

If Barnes gets an uptick in 3pt% because he’s relegated to the corner that’s not overly helpful if teams are still cheating off of him or even when he makes the shot it’s still a below average offensive outcome for the shot type.

Barnes isn’t going to be relegated to the corner, but even for arguments sake, he is a career 35% corner shooter which would be a nice uptick over his sub 30% from ATB.

But that isn’t what’s going to happen. Hes going to just not be the one taking some bail out shots, initiating offence, etc. which overall will have massive gains to our offensive efficiency.

I don’t know how you possibly think that replacing Barnes and RJs offensive output with guys more suited to on-ball creative roles ISNT going to help our team as a whole. Barnes/RJ as a 1/2 were giving us like 55TS%. Ingram/Quickley in those same roles hopefully get us 58-60TS% from those same possessions, and you hope RJ/Barnes as a 3/4 option offensively gives you better offensive output than the guys we had as a 3/4 last year (Dick, Shead, Olynyk, etc.)

It’s prettt clear how rearranging the pecking order will help everyone.
What an absolute failure and disaster this franchise is, ran by one of the most incompetent front offices in the league.
- Raptors RealGM Forum re: Masai Ujiri - June 2023
Harcore Fenton Mun
RealGM
Posts: 14,380
And1: 8,457
Joined: Jul 17, 2006

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#616 » by Harcore Fenton Mun » Sun Aug 10, 2025 3:32 pm

So, let's say.. BI 21-23ppg, IQ 14-21ppg, RJ 19-21ppg. That leaves Scottie the "facilitator" Barnes at 14-19ppg
Image
DreamTeam09
RealGM
Posts: 17,581
And1: 10,948
Joined: Jan 06, 2009
Location: Scarborough
 

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#617 » by DreamTeam09 » Sun Aug 10, 2025 4:36 pm

Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:So, let's say.. BI 21-23ppg, IQ 14-21ppg, RJ 19-21ppg. That leaves Scottie the "facilitator" Barnes at 14-19ppg


4 20pt scorers is only 80pts, there's still another 30-35-40 pts to get to. You guys a worrying about things that don't need to be worried about,

I get it tho, it's August. I hope everyone is enjoying the summer.

If the best defender is covering BI, you guys are anticipating Barnes production to drop? That makes sense to y'all?
Image

In Raptor Ball I Trust
DreamTeam09
RealGM
Posts: 17,581
And1: 10,948
Joined: Jan 06, 2009
Location: Scarborough
 

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#618 » by DreamTeam09 » Sun Aug 10, 2025 4:47 pm


.
Relevant notes

-Orbital fracture which would affect depth perception
-Ankle injury which would limit burst
-Wrist contusion, which would affect shooting mechanics
Image

In Raptor Ball I Trust
Harcore Fenton Mun
RealGM
Posts: 14,380
And1: 8,457
Joined: Jul 17, 2006

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#619 » by Harcore Fenton Mun » Sun Aug 10, 2025 6:00 pm

DreamTeam09 wrote:
Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:So, let's say.. BI 21-23ppg, IQ 14-21ppg, RJ 19-21ppg. That leaves Scottie the "facilitator" Barnes at 14-19ppg


4 20pt scorers is only 80pts, there's still another 30-35-40 pts to get to. You guys a worrying about things that don't need to be worried about,

I get it tho, it's August. I hope everyone is enjoying the summer.

If the best defender is covering BI, you guys are anticipating Barnes production to drop? That makes sense to y'all?

Just one ball. Not enough touches.
Image
User avatar
LBJKB24MJ23
RealGM
Posts: 23,332
And1: 21,682
Joined: Jan 22, 2014
Location: Bermuda
     

Re: Scottie isn't going to be a #1 option superstar in this league 

Post#620 » by LBJKB24MJ23 » Sun Aug 10, 2025 7:34 pm

DreamTeam09 wrote:
Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:So, let's say.. BI 21-23ppg, IQ 14-21ppg, RJ 19-21ppg. That leaves Scottie the "facilitator" Barnes at 14-19ppg


4 20pt scorers is only 80pts, there's still another 30-35-40 pts to get to. You guys a worrying about things that don't need to be worried about,

I get it tho, it's August. I hope everyone is enjoying the summer.

If the best defender is covering BI, you guys are anticipating Barnes production to drop? That makes sense to y'all?


when you're holding opponents to league best 79 points, its all good.
raf1995 wrote:I just don’t think he has that kind of potential. I think we will regret not trading him for a haul in a few years when he’s a mid-tier starter with nice playmaking and defense and a shaky jumper.

Return to Toronto Raptors