G R E Y wrote:Nuntius wrote:G R E Y wrote:Are there no other famous works of art, non-religious, from which to choose? Are there sensitivities around other religious works that, had they been recreated/lampooned instead, would have been as safe to do so - in today's France? That's a lot of good points that work a big circle around the hub, which is that is IS a centrally religious symbolic piece of art. As you acknowledge. But there's also a reason France has banned all religious exterior symbols in schools (paraphrasing) and only one religion was lampooned, despite it being a country of many faiths, of course. Something is being ignored-to-minimized here, even as I support the right to blaspheme in general.
Are there famous non-religious works of art? Of course there are. Would recreating/paying homage to/lampooning a non-religious work of art showcase France's laïcité? No, it wouldn't.
Remember, the whole point of Olympic opening ceremonies (other than to officially indicate the start of the Games) is to showcase the host country's culture. Laïcité is a key component of French culture. Laïcité is the reason why the use of religious symbols in public places was banned. Laïcité is part of what makes France, well, France.
I realize that this could be seen as offensive to Americans (or people from other similarly religious countries) but France does have the right to showcase their culture during the opening ceremony they are hosting.
As I've stated before, France has strong representation of all the Abrahamic faiths.
France has strong representation of the Christian faith. About 50% of the population identifies as Christian. Around 5% identifies as Muslim. Only 1% are Jewish. So, to lump all of them together as Abrahamic faiths when Christianity represents around 90% of the adherents of Abrahamic faiths is a bit disingenuous.
France is a Christian-majority country so it is only natural that the religion that they're going to recreate/pay homage to/lampoon is going to be their majoritarian religion. That's what normally happens, everywhere around the world. Recreating/paying homage to/lampooning a minority religion would be the weird part.
I get what you're trying to imply here, G R E Y, but I fully disagree.