prime1time wrote: All your point does is confirm my overall argument that Rui haters have never been objective.
You weaken your own arguments by being disagreeable. And projecting your own lack of objectivity onto others by being over-sensitive when your personal fan crush suffers under valid critique. I get it, being fanatic about a particular player makes it hard to be objective about them. So, you cherry pick the stats you like, and hunt for ancient news articles about how he has 'improved' at a thing that most players who make it to the NBA are already proficient at. Anybody who watches the game knows he is deficient in team defense and is better at one-on-one defense. A player who is actually good at these things does not hear news stories about how they are getting better. From Scott Brooks, who consistently had the the worst team defense in the league. With Rui as his starting 4.
Rui has earned his critique, he is now earning appreciation. If this track continues it leads to, I dunno, a starting role. And eventually a winning record. Rui is a back-up PF on a losing team, who was judged undesirable even as trade ballast for a malcontent. It is entirely possible that you know better than pro scouts and GMs whose families eat or starve based on their ability to evaluate talent. But then you might as well label the entire NBA 'haters'.
Or I dunno. Perhaps reality hates Rui's defense. Mathematics is a Rui hater. Pick a defensive stat:
How about
Defensive real plus/minus:
Rui is 71 of 72 power forwards. One spot BELOW Isaiah Todd. Only saved from being dead last by the cadaver of Taurean Prince.
Defensive rating: Of 490 NBA players. Rui is 315th.
You can run through a long list of defensive measures: rebounds, blocks, steals -- for his career Rui shows up sub par for his position, whether you call him a SF or PF. He has had a string of good games, they have lifted his average to --not quite average, but better than they were. Call it a win and move on. The guy you like is getting better. Fans of the Team can appreciate it as well as fans of the Player. And shoot there are plenty of reasons to be a fan of the player.
Rui is a good kid, nice guy, and carries a heavy emotional load given who he is and where he is from. I appreciate that he both struggled emotionally and showed great strength in coming back to the spotlight. It shows serious character to publicly melt down, but fight back into the public view and improve on shortcomings. Other players have come apart under that strain. To improve mid-season, after coming back from injury, is not common. A good sign. Shows character.
I suspect he's an interesting guy, seems an introvert but gives an impression of being genuinely kind. Wants to please. Wants to show up for his teammates. Family. Fans. Country. And he is remarkably talented in the gifts that cannot be taught. The rest are skills that can be improved over time. But to say he is deficient in key basketball fundamentals is not being a 'hater'. It is setting a bar for him that starts with: playable. Then sets the expectation for improvement, to 'good' then 'starter' and potentially 'star'. Fans of the player see what they hope he will be, it is fair and reasonable to say he's not there yet.