Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!!

Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285

TreymondGreen
Junior
Posts: 410
And1: 361
Joined: Oct 08, 2014
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#181 » by TreymondGreen » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:46 am

Damn those warriors for playing unselfish, fundamental basketball!

How dare they move off the ball and not be allowed to run without being held!

NBA sucks and is rigged!!!
User avatar
Impuniti
General Manager
Posts: 9,885
And1: 7,809
Joined: Jan 18, 2016

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#182 » by Impuniti » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:48 am

TreymondGreen wrote:Damn those warriors for playing unselfish, fundamental basketball!

How dare they move off the ball and not be allowed to run without being held!

NBA sucks and is rigged!!!

Image
User avatar
Luigi
General Manager
Posts: 8,027
And1: 3,590
Joined: Aug 13, 2009
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#183 » by Luigi » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:49 am

TreymondGreen wrote:Damn those warriors for playing unselfish, fundamental basketball!

How dare they move off the ball and not be allowed to run without being held!

NBA sucks and is rigged!!!


Lol, nobody has said anything close to that. Who are you responding to?
In '03-'04, Jerry Sloan coached the ESPN predicted "worst team of all time" to 42-40.
Par36
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,156
And1: 4,024
Joined: Oct 10, 2015
   

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#184 » by Par36 » Wed Oct 10, 2018 6:27 am

Call moving screens and this rule works.. otherwise it's a joke.
User avatar
Side beard
Analyst
Posts: 3,600
And1: 2,301
Joined: Jan 16, 2010
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#185 » by Side beard » Wed Oct 10, 2018 6:59 am

Harden is about to average 30 FTA a game.
Hugi Mancura
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,936
And1: 1,174
Joined: Dec 05, 2017

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#186 » by Hugi Mancura » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:11 pm

Side beard wrote:Harden is about to average 30 FTA a game.


Not really, because he handles the ball and you haven't been able to touch ball handler couple year all ready. He doesn't really do that much off the ball, so this rule really doesn't affect his game.
User avatar
Heej
General Manager
Posts: 8,469
And1: 9,170
Joined: Jan 14, 2011

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#187 » by Heej » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:18 pm

When you have guys like Jordan Bell that can back their ass into someone and scoot both of them away without any whistles during a crucial Game 7 in the WCF, people are rightly gonna complain that a rule which favors the already overpowered screening offensive sets has just been put into place. It seems like they'll call offensive fouls more readily on guys who hook and grab while screening, but they still refuse to address the elephant in the room of NBA players not knowing how to set legal screens
LeBron's NBA Cup MVP is more valuable than either of KD's Finals MVPs. This is the word of the Lord
GoGreen
Analyst
Posts: 3,050
And1: 3,487
Joined: Jul 19, 2017
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#188 » by GoGreen » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:30 pm

This preseason has been such a full fest.
NBA, take it from the NFL, DO NOT MICROMANAGE. The last thing I want is constant stoppage in play
michaelm
RealGM
Posts: 12,169
And1: 5,219
Joined: Apr 06, 2010
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#189 » by michaelm » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:31 pm

letskissbro wrote:Not surprised that Golden State fans are literally the only ones overwhelmingly in favor of this change

You don’t think GSW fans could possibly have been slightly triggered by the thread title?.

I am a GSW fan who actually would not proclaim deep faith in the integrity of those who run the NBA in almost any circumstance, and am fairly indifferent to the rule change, although I consider some of the pictures of Steph Curry in this thread to resemble the result of a cat fight more than “tough” defense in an NBA game.

We will see how it all works anyway, the rule touted as the anti-Harden rule before a recent season (? last season) seemed to have little impact and is little discussed now.
Hugi Mancura
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,936
And1: 1,174
Joined: Dec 05, 2017

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#190 » by Hugi Mancura » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:37 pm

johanliebert wrote:
Lenneth wrote:Never understood why that was not enforced heavily before.

It’s to counteract moving screens which we all know won’t be addressed.

Another rule in favour of offense. So now defenders can’t grab and got to do deal with moving screens all game to free up shooters.


This does favour the offense, but holding has never been a counteract on moving screen. Teams use moving screens on pick & roll situations as well and in those situations you can't hold the ball handler. You will get called a foul. So teams playing lot pick & rolls have had the benefit of moving screens and other team unable to hold your stars as much they want.

Would I like to see refs start calling moving screens? Yes, I would, but every team does moving screens, so it has never given any team any advantage. But situation where you can't touch the ball handler, but can hold as much you want off the ball players have given clear advantage to teams that play lot of ISO and P&R. So in the end this just moves team oriented offenses on the same starting line where ISO or p&r offenses all ready were.

I do understand why people hate that this rule is removed, because it does help team offense to become better, so team playing without ball movement does lose their ground against team oriented offense. This means players like Harden, Westbrook and Lebron loses little bit their ground against GSW, but maybe GSW biggest opponents will be Utah or Boston, who both have ball movement more. **start of sarkasm** And maybe they add this rule because Lebron's Lakers start to play with ball movement and Lebron wanted to make his life easier and thus asked NBA to add this rule. **end of sarkasm**
User avatar
John Murdoch
RealGM
Posts: 10,250
And1: 7,720
Joined: Sep 16, 2013
         

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#191 » by John Murdoch » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:40 pm

Hand checking sure, but I actually dont like this tbh. It would be like banning the shoulder to shoulder rule in soccer nearly impossible to stop guys at that point
Magic#1 wrote:We have won two playoff games in two years. If we decide to keep this team for the next two years, maybe it will feel like we won a series.
michaelm
RealGM
Posts: 12,169
And1: 5,219
Joined: Apr 06, 2010
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#192 » by michaelm » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:47 pm

Hugi Mancura wrote:
johanliebert wrote:
Lenneth wrote:Never understood why that was not enforced heavily before.

It’s to counteract moving screens which we all know won’t be addressed.

Another rule in favour of offense. So now defenders can’t grab and got to do deal with moving screens all game to free up shooters.


This does favour the offense, but holding has never been a counteract on moving screen. Teams use moving screens on pick & roll situations as well and in those situations you can't hold the ball handler. You will get called a foul. So teams playing lot pick & rolls have had the benefit of moving screens and other team unable to hold your stars as much they want.

Would I like to see refs start calling moving screens? Yes, I would, but every team does moving screens, so it has never given any team any advantage. But situation where you can't touch the ball handler, but can hold as much you want off the ball players have given clear advantage to teams that play lot of ISO and P&R. So in the end this just moves team oriented offenses on the same starting line where ISO or p&r offenses all ready were.

I do understand why people hate that this rule is removed, because it does help team offense to become better, so team playing without ball movement does lose their ground against team oriented offense. This means players like Harden, Westbrook and Lebron loses little bit their ground against GSW, but maybe GSW biggest opponents will be Utah or Boston, who both have ball movement more. **start of sarkasm** And maybe they add this rule because Lebron's Lakers start to play with ball movement and Lebron wanted to make his life easier and thus asked NBA to add this rule. **end of sarkasm**

Kerr could have run a fairly unstoppable Durant/Curry pick and roll every play but seemed to consider same ideologically unsound.
User avatar
John Murdoch
RealGM
Posts: 10,250
And1: 7,720
Joined: Sep 16, 2013
         

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#193 » by John Murdoch » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:50 pm

Side beard wrote:Harden is about to average 30 FTA a game.

He doesnt even play off ball, if anything it guys like Reddick , Klay, Korver who will be the biggest beneficiaries
Magic#1 wrote:We have won two playoff games in two years. If we decide to keep this team for the next two years, maybe it will feel like we won a series.
spicy6
Starter
Posts: 2,003
And1: 1,841
Joined: Apr 21, 2017
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#194 » by spicy6 » Wed Oct 10, 2018 12:59 pm

Call moving screens then for gods sake. Literally the warriors bread and butter especially in the 2016 WCF. This rule literally makes it easier for them score great job for the competition lmao.
User avatar
Side beard
Analyst
Posts: 3,600
And1: 2,301
Joined: Jan 16, 2010
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#195 » by Side beard » Wed Oct 10, 2018 1:56 pm

Hugi Mancura wrote:
Side beard wrote:Harden is about to average 30 FTA a game.


Not really, because he handles the ball and you haven't been able to touch ball handler couple year all ready. He doesn't really do that much off the ball, so this rule really doesn't affect his game.

Watch him adjust.
Hugi Mancura
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,936
And1: 1,174
Joined: Dec 05, 2017

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#196 » by Hugi Mancura » Wed Oct 10, 2018 2:57 pm

michaelm wrote:
Hugi Mancura wrote:
johanliebert wrote:It’s to counteract moving screens which we all know won’t be addressed.

Another rule in favour of offense. So now defenders can’t grab and got to do deal with moving screens all game to free up shooters.


This does favour the offense, but holding has never been a counteract on moving screen. Teams use moving screens on pick & roll situations as well and in those situations you can't hold the ball handler. You will get called a foul. So teams playing lot pick & rolls have had the benefit of moving screens and other team unable to hold your stars as much they want.

Would I like to see refs start calling moving screens? Yes, I would, but every team does moving screens, so it has never given any team any advantage. But situation where you can't touch the ball handler, but can hold as much you want off the ball players have given clear advantage to teams that play lot of ISO and P&R. So in the end this just moves team oriented offenses on the same starting line where ISO or p&r offenses all ready were.

I do understand why people hate that this rule is removed, because it does help team offense to become better, so team playing without ball movement does lose their ground against team oriented offense. This means players like Harden, Westbrook and Lebron loses little bit their ground against GSW, but maybe GSW biggest opponents will be Utah or Boston, who both have ball movement more. **start of sarkasm** And maybe they add this rule because Lebron's Lakers start to play with ball movement and Lebron wanted to make his life easier and thus asked NBA to add this rule. **end of sarkasm**

Kerr could have run a fairly unstoppable Durant/Curry pick and roll every play but seemed to consider same ideologically unsound.


Maybe he could have, but is that really what fans want? That rules would force all teams to play pick & rolls and nothing else? Would you be happy, if you go to shop and only beer you could buy is Bud light? This chance gives teams more options how they
could build their offense, so everyone should be happy. More options does enrich the game and more options does enrich your life in beer section because you can buy different beers.
michaelm
RealGM
Posts: 12,169
And1: 5,219
Joined: Apr 06, 2010
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#197 » by michaelm » Wed Oct 10, 2018 3:38 pm

Hugi Mancura wrote:
michaelm wrote:
Hugi Mancura wrote:
This does favour the offense, but holding has never been a counteract on moving screen. Teams use moving screens on pick & roll situations as well and in those situations you can't hold the ball handler. You will get called a foul. So teams playing lot pick & rolls have had the benefit of moving screens and other team unable to hold your stars as much they want.

Would I like to see refs start calling moving screens? Yes, I would, but every team does moving screens, so it has never given any team any advantage. But situation where you can't touch the ball handler, but can hold as much you want off the ball players have given clear advantage to teams that play lot of ISO and P&R. So in the end this just moves team oriented offenses on the same starting line where ISO or p&r offenses all ready were.

I do understand why people hate that this rule is removed, because it does help team offense to become better, so team playing without ball movement does lose their ground against team oriented offense. This means players like Harden, Westbrook and Lebron loses little bit their ground against GSW, but maybe GSW biggest opponents will be Utah or Boston, who both have ball movement more. **start of sarkasm** And maybe they add this rule because Lebron's Lakers start to play with ball movement and Lebron wanted to make his life easier and thus asked NBA to add this rule. **end of sarkasm**

Kerr could have run a fairly unstoppable Durant/Curry pick and roll every play but seemed to consider same ideologically unsound.


Maybe he could have, but is that really what fans want? That rules would force all teams to play pick & rolls and nothing else? Would you be happy, if you go to shop and only beer you could buy is Bud light? This chance gives teams more options how they
could build their offense, so everyone should be happy. More options does enrich the game and more options does enrich your life in beer section because you can buy different beers.

That was rather my point. I think Kerr has deliberately chosen what he considers to be a better way, certainly for team harmony and whole team involvement but probably also because he believes that basketball is better played that way.
User avatar
TMU
Forum Mod - Rockets
Forum Mod - Rockets
Posts: 30,188
And1: 10,413
Joined: Jan 02, 2005
Location: O.R.
       

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#198 » by TMU » Wed Oct 10, 2018 3:43 pm

The NBA also needs to do something about illegal screens. Someone needs to say that again and again. :wizard:
Hugi Mancura
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,936
And1: 1,174
Joined: Dec 05, 2017

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#199 » by Hugi Mancura » Wed Oct 10, 2018 3:54 pm

michaelm wrote:
Hugi Mancura wrote:
michaelm wrote:
Kerr could have run a fairly unstoppable Durant/Curry pick and roll every play but seemed to consider same ideologically unsound.


Maybe he could have, but is that really what fans want? That rules would force all teams to play pick & rolls and nothing else? Would you be happy, if you go to shop and only beer you could buy is Bud light? This chance gives teams more options how they
could build their offense, so everyone should be happy. More options does enrich the game and more options does enrich your life in beer section because you can buy different beers.

That was rather my point. I think Kerr has deliberately chosen what he considers to be a better way, certainly for team harmony and whole team involvement but probably also because he believes that basketball is better played that way.


I misunderstood your message.
User avatar
Johnny Bball
RealGM
Posts: 54,681
And1: 59,018
Joined: Feb 01, 2015
 

Re: Refs new "freedom of movement" rule bans defenders from grabbing off ball cutters like Curry and Klay!!! 

Post#200 » by Johnny Bball » Wed Oct 10, 2018 3:57 pm

Luigi wrote:
TreymondGreen wrote:Damn those warriors for playing unselfish, fundamental basketball!

How dare they move off the ball and not be allowed to run without being held!

NBA sucks and is rigged!!!


Lol, nobody has said anything close to that. Who are you responding to?


He's practicing. It's been a whole summer without whining about the unfairness of it all and without the bragging, so it's time for GSW warrior fans to get in regular season form.

Return to The General Board