Doctor MJ wrote:dhsilv2 wrote:Doctor MJ wrote:
I think that will change quickly if the mainstream becomes convinced that Shai is an MVP-level layer leading a possible dynasty.
I think Shai's got 2 things really working against him:
1. Understated personality - which won't necessarily be an issue if he has enough success and looks cool (we should remember that in the classic Nike adds, Jordan wasn't the one doing the talking).
2. Delayed start to stardom. When a guy gets hyped as a superstar right out the gate and has quick success, he becomes popular. When he doesn't really hit until after people have gotten excited about a new set of younger guys, his popularity is often a slow burn growth even after his emergence.
Speaking as a guy who collects basketball cards, I'd say Luka Doncic is still a bigger deal in the hobby than Nikola Jokic because people going nuts hyping Luka as the next great one and so even after Jokic ended up being the guy winning the MVPs, people were still invested in the idea of the prodigy becoming the best player.
The thing with SGA is that he's close enough to American. Lets be real, if you don't have an accent people really move on fast. He's the right size..not giant, not super small. And he's athletic. He really checks the boxes to do well.
Now I get with Jokic he'll never be Lebron. But I mean that in a good and bad way. He'll never have the level of hype but he's also not a guy people dislike. If I wanted a guy to push my mass made product...man he's the obvious choice. But if I've got some edgy new thing...yeah, I'll look elsewhere.
I'll just piggy back on this and say:
After Jordan, the expectation is that you should look like a male supermodel, and nobody in the NBA looks less like a model than Jokic.
Luka adopting a personality at a young clearly inspired by NBA stars helps him relative to Jokic, but still, Fat Luka & Gru-Face are just not going to get the same kind of mainstream acclaim as someone who actually looks sexy.
I think this is a thing that basketball is really going to have to deal with: Basketball became for men's sports what tennis is for women's sport, the sport with the hot athletes. That's all well and good so long as there's reason to expect a correlation between sport ability and attractiveness, which worked so long as a fast-twitch body was indeed the way to be an MVP player.
What we're seeing now though is that while physical talent is nice, an outlier basketball brain trumps all, and that really can't be expected to resonate the same way with people who know nothing about the sport.
Interesting, I'd actually never thought about that. Though to be fair...I still don't really understand what is considered attractive in a man. Beyond I've figured out don't be fat and be tall...but I guess not Jokic tall. But I suppose I can see some of that.