ImageImageImage

Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0)

Moderators: bisme37, Darthlukey, Shak_Celts, Parliament10, shackles10, snowman, Froob, canman1971

Who smokes the big cigar?

Tatum
45
34%
Brown
2
2%
Smart
2
2%
White
66
50%
Horford
1
1%
Brogdon
9
7%
Rob
4
3%
Hauser
0
No votes
Other/Coach/Team
4
3%
 
Total votes: 133

exculpatory
RealGM
Posts: 15,203
And1: 11,396
Joined: Nov 10, 2008

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#101 » by exculpatory » Wed Apr 19, 2023 10:02 pm

Feed Your Head wrote:
exculpatory wrote:
keevsnick1 wrote:Derrick White going from almost unplayable on offense to a legit third option level offense generator with +++defensive value is the biggest development of the season.

In addition, both HEALTHY GAME CHANGING Rob and Smart THE DISTRIBUTOR & DEFENDER are looking closer to what they were last year. If these three things hold, (AND WE CONSISTENTLY HOLD LEADS BETTER), Celtics are the clear favorites.


…And the 6MOTY who could start for most NBA teams.

…And JT #4 in MVP VOTING.

…And, to be fair, #7 often playing to his elite offensive strengths (when he isn’t trying to set a TOV RECORD).

…And BIG AL defying his age.

I LOVE DERRICK!


Everyone, get your camera’s ready.

Of the top 20 players in usage rate, these are the only ones who had a lower turnover rate than Jaylen.

SGA: 10.1%
Mitchell: 10.3%
Tatum: 10.4%
Booker: 10.6%
Fox: 10.6%
Jaylen: 11.4

Then the rest of the top 20 had a worse turnover rate.

B. The issue with Jaylen is he doesn’t really make up for it with playmaking, or even the threat of playmaking.

A. But he really doesn’t turn the ball over much, he just has memorable turnovers.



A. Thanks for the stats. Defies the eye test perhaps because they are ‘memorable’, often seem to occur in bunches, & often seem to occur at bad times.

B. That matters a **** lot. Excellent point.
SamIam 2010: Truth's ability to play so incredibly efficiently is so UNDERAPPRECIATED. Bballcool 2012: Amazing how great Pierce has been for so long. Continues to defy age! KG 2013: P is original Celtic. Wherever he goes, we go. This is The Truth's house.
exculpatory
RealGM
Posts: 15,203
And1: 11,396
Joined: Nov 10, 2008

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#102 » by exculpatory » Wed Apr 19, 2023 10:04 pm

BK_2020 wrote:
Feed Your Head wrote:
exculpatory wrote:
…And the 6MOTY who could start for most NBA teams.
.
…And JT #4 in MVP VOTING.

…And, to be fair, #7 often playing to his elite offensive strengths (when he isn’t trying to set a TOV RECORD).

…And BIG AL defying his age.

I LOVE DERRICK!


Everyone, get your camera’s ready.

Of the top 20 players in usage rate, these are the only ones who had a lower turnover rate than Jaylen.

SGA: 10.1%
Mitchell: 10.3%
Tatum: 10.4%
Booker: 10.6%
Fox: 10.6%
Jaylen: 11.4

Then the rest of the top 20 had a worse turnover rate. The issue with Jaylen is he doesn’t really make up for it with playmaking, or even the threat of playmaking. But he really doesn’t turn the ball over much, he just has memorable turnovers.


The other issue with Jaylen is that he doesn't score on good efficiency despite being a secondary scorer and his scoring often comes at the expense of ball movement and team offense.

SGA: .626
Mitchell: .614
Tatum: .607
Booker: .601
Fox: .599
Jaylen: .581

Then some fun comps like

KD: .697

Jaylen is a good but not elite scorer who wants the volume of an elite scorer, often at the expense of team success.


Yup.
SamIam 2010: Truth's ability to play so incredibly efficiently is so UNDERAPPRECIATED. Bballcool 2012: Amazing how great Pierce has been for so long. Continues to defy age! KG 2013: P is original Celtic. Wherever he goes, we go. This is The Truth's house.
User avatar
ballup
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,965
And1: 3,527
Joined: Dec 08, 2013
 

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#103 » by ballup » Thu Apr 20, 2023 12:57 am

BK_2020 wrote:
Feed Your Head wrote:
exculpatory wrote:
…And the 6MOTY who could start for most NBA teams.
.
…And JT #4 in MVP VOTING.

…And, to be fair, #7 often playing to his elite offensive strengths (when he isn’t trying to set a TOV RECORD).

…And BIG AL defying his age.

I LOVE DERRICK!


Everyone, get your camera’s ready.

Of the top 20 players in usage rate, these are the only ones who had a lower turnover rate than Jaylen.

SGA: 10.1%
Mitchell: 10.3%
Tatum: 10.4%
Booker: 10.6%
Fox: 10.6%
Jaylen: 11.4

Then the rest of the top 20 had a worse turnover rate. The issue with Jaylen is he doesn’t really make up for it with playmaking, or even the threat of playmaking. But he really doesn’t turn the ball over much, he just has memorable turnovers.


The other issue with Jaylen is that he doesn't score on good efficiency despite being a secondary scorer and his scoring often comes at the expense of ball movement and team offense.

SGA: .626
Mitchell: .614
Tatum: .607
Booker: .601
Fox: .599
Jaylen: .581

Then some fun comps like

KD: .697

Jaylen is a good but not elite scorer who wants the volume of an elite scorer, often at the expense of team success.

Well it issue is because people like you don't know how to use TS% properly. Applying TS% across the board uniformly instead of comparing players of similar shot charts/play styles is one example of why advanced stats get pushback.
BK_2020
RealGM
Posts: 17,088
And1: 15,821
Joined: Sep 08, 2020
 

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#104 » by BK_2020 » Thu Apr 20, 2023 1:51 am

ballup wrote:
BK_2020 wrote:
Feed Your Head wrote:
Everyone, get your camera’s ready.

Of the top 20 players in usage rate, these are the only ones who had a lower turnover rate than Jaylen.

SGA: 10.1%
Mitchell: 10.3%
Tatum: 10.4%
Booker: 10.6%
Fox: 10.6%
Jaylen: 11.4

Then the rest of the top 20 had a worse turnover rate. The issue with Jaylen is he doesn’t really make up for it with playmaking, or even the threat of playmaking. But he really doesn’t turn the ball over much, he just has memorable turnovers.


The other issue with Jaylen is that he doesn't score on good efficiency despite being a secondary scorer and his scoring often comes at the expense of ball movement and team offense.

SGA: .626
Mitchell: .614
Tatum: .607
Booker: .601
Fox: .599
Jaylen: .581

Then some fun comps like

KD: .697

Jaylen is a good but not elite scorer who wants the volume of an elite scorer, often at the expense of team success.

Well it issue is because people like you don't know how to use TS% properly. Applying TS% across the board uniformly instead of comparing players of similar shot charts/play styles is one example of why advanced stats get pushback.

People like you need to learn to read the entire thread because it takes maybe someone of 12 - 15 IQ to figure out why my list includes those names in the order they are in. I can trust you to meet the minimum?
User avatar
tlee324
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 20,009
And1: 8,571
Joined: Jun 29, 2003
Location: Celtic Nation
       

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#105 » by tlee324 » Thu Apr 20, 2023 3:47 am

White and Tatum deserve their votes; wanted to also throw out there how effective Rob was when we were down early in the 1st quarter and his efforts started to turn it around for the team by the end of the quarter.
Image
User avatar
zoyathedestroya
RealGM
Posts: 41,125
And1: 98,277
Joined: Nov 05, 2017

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#106 » by zoyathedestroya » Thu Apr 20, 2023 11:17 am

Only 8 instances of 25p-10r-5a by a Celtics player in a playoff game since 2010. Tatum registered all eight.
Homerclease
RealGM
Posts: 30,682
And1: 32,715
Joined: Dec 09, 2015

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#107 » by Homerclease » Thu Apr 20, 2023 1:24 pm

Read on Twitter
?s=46&t=2r3K1qCL2UmIu9zb8OVdDw

Who’s gonna stop John Collins guys
User avatar
ballup
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,965
And1: 3,527
Joined: Dec 08, 2013
 

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#108 » by ballup » Thu Apr 20, 2023 1:52 pm

BK_2020 wrote:
ballup wrote:
BK_2020 wrote:
The other issue with Jaylen is that he doesn't score on good efficiency despite being a secondary scorer and his scoring often comes at the expense of ball movement and team offense.

SGA: .626
Mitchell: .614
Tatum: .607
Booker: .601
Fox: .599
Jaylen: .581

Then some fun comps like

KD: .697

Jaylen is a good but not elite scorer who wants the volume of an elite scorer, often at the expense of team success.

Well it issue is because people like you don't know how to use TS% properly. Applying TS% across the board uniformly instead of comparing players of similar shot charts/play styles is one example of why advanced stats get pushback.

People like you need to learn to read the entire thread because it takes maybe someone of 12 - 15 IQ to figure out why my list includes those names in the order they are in. I can trust you to meet the minimum?


BK_2020 wrote:
ballup wrote:
BK_2020 wrote:
The other issue with Jaylen is that he doesn't score on good efficiency despite being a secondary scorer and his scoring often comes at the expense of ball movement and team offense.

SGA: .626
Mitchell: .614
Tatum: .607
Booker: .601
Fox: .599
Jaylen: .581

Then some fun comps like

KD: .697

Jaylen is a good but not elite scorer who wants the volume of an elite scorer, often at the expense of team success.

Well it issue is because people like you don't know how to use TS% properly. Applying TS% across the board uniformly instead of comparing players of similar shot charts/play styles is one example of why advanced stats get pushback.

People like you need to learn to read the entire thread because it takes maybe someone of 12 - 15 IQ to figure out why my list includes those names in the order they are in. I can trust you to meet the minimum?


My statement still applies.

The equation for TS% is Points/(FGA+.44FTA). There are multiple ways to increase one's percentage for this formula. It's not just make more shots. It can unintentionally be gamified if the player shoots a high volume of 3s and FTs while limiting mid rangers. Why go on this long tangent? Because Jaylen's playstyle isn't to force defenders to foul him like a Butler. He plays a hybrid style of Kyrie/Kawhi/DeRozan where he slashes and avoids contact by hanging in the air, shooting on the descend. If Jaylen played more of the conventional perimeter star where he emphasizes fouls drawn, his FGA would go down and FTA would go up. Mathematically, that lowers the denominator, increasing TS%.

Compare that to his contemporaries. Tatum is now muscling through defenders and their outstretched arms. Fox/Mitchell/SGA are speed demons and defenders are more likely to foul because they can't keep up. KD is the rarified uber efficient scorer who is the anomaly.

Now Booker is the one case similar to Jaylen. Similar FGA, but Booker goes to the line more and shoots less 3s. Booker has the ball more in his hands. Granted, he is one of the leagues better secondary ballhandlers. It's valid to criticize Jaylen on not making his 3s this season. It's his lowest rate of his career. Also valid to call out his average FT shooting. Saying that he is not an elite scorer is a terrible opinion and quite hypocritical of you. You know who scored 27 PPG on 58 TS% recently?Tatum last season. The one player you stan and never criticize.

Sent from my Pixel 3a using Tapatalk
Homerclease
RealGM
Posts: 30,682
And1: 32,715
Joined: Dec 09, 2015

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#109 » by Homerclease » Thu Apr 20, 2023 2:09 pm

BK_2020 wrote:
Feed Your Head wrote:
exculpatory wrote:
…And the 6MOTY who could start for most NBA teams.
.
…And JT #4 in MVP VOTING.

…And, to be fair, #7 often playing to his elite offensive strengths (when he isn’t trying to set a TOV RECORD).

…And BIG AL defying his age.

I LOVE DERRICK!


Everyone, get your camera’s ready.

Of the top 20 players in usage rate, these are the only ones who had a lower turnover rate than Jaylen.

SGA: 10.1%
Mitchell: 10.3%
Tatum: 10.4%
Booker: 10.6%
Fox: 10.6%
Jaylen: 11.4

Then the rest of the top 20 had a worse turnover rate. The issue with Jaylen is he doesn’t really make up for it with playmaking, or even the threat of playmaking. But he really doesn’t turn the ball over much, he just has memorable turnovers.


The other issue with Jaylen is that he doesn't score on good efficiency despite being a secondary scorer and his scoring often comes at the expense of ball movement and team offense.

SGA: .626
Mitchell: .614
Tatum: .607
Booker: .601
Fox: .599
Jaylen: .581

Then some fun comps like

KD: .697

Jaylen is a good but not elite scorer who wants the volume of an elite scorer, often at the expense of team success.

When has he ever stated anything to this effect?
BK_2020
RealGM
Posts: 17,088
And1: 15,821
Joined: Sep 08, 2020
 

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#110 » by BK_2020 » Thu Apr 20, 2023 5:16 pm

Homerclease wrote:
BK_2020 wrote:
Feed Your Head wrote:
Everyone, get your camera’s ready.

Of the top 20 players in usage rate, these are the only ones who had a lower turnover rate than Jaylen.

SGA: 10.1%
Mitchell: 10.3%
Tatum: 10.4%
Booker: 10.6%
Fox: 10.6%
Jaylen: 11.4

Then the rest of the top 20 had a worse turnover rate. The issue with Jaylen is he doesn’t really make up for it with playmaking, or even the threat of playmaking. But he really doesn’t turn the ball over much, he just has memorable turnovers.


The other issue with Jaylen is that he doesn't score on good efficiency despite being a secondary scorer and his scoring often comes at the expense of ball movement and team offense.

SGA: .626
Mitchell: .614
Tatum: .607
Booker: .601
Fox: .599
Jaylen: .581

Then some fun comps like

KD: .697

Jaylen is a good but not elite scorer who wants the volume of an elite scorer, often at the expense of team success.

When has he ever stated anything to this effect?

I mean, Jaylen isn't an idiot, he's not gonna literally say "I don't care about the team." That doesn't mean you are automatically a team player.
Homerclease
RealGM
Posts: 30,682
And1: 32,715
Joined: Dec 09, 2015

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#111 » by Homerclease » Thu Apr 20, 2023 5:18 pm

BK_2020 wrote:
Homerclease wrote:
BK_2020 wrote:
The other issue with Jaylen is that he doesn't score on good efficiency despite being a secondary scorer and his scoring often comes at the expense of ball movement and team offense.

SGA: .626
Mitchell: .614
Tatum: .607
Booker: .601
Fox: .599
Jaylen: .581

Then some fun comps like

KD: .697

Jaylen is a good but not elite scorer who wants the volume of an elite scorer, often at the expense of team success.

When has he ever stated anything to this effect?

I mean, Jaylen isn't an idiot, he's not gonna literally say "I don't care about the team." That doesn't mean you are automatically a team player.

You said “he wants the volume of an elite scorer”. Is that just your opinion or is there some quote by Brown somewhere that supports this claim?
Hal14
RealGM
Posts: 22,455
And1: 21,383
Joined: Apr 05, 2019

Re: Hawks Squawk, Celtics Rock! Playoff Victory Cigar vs ATL 4/18 (BOS lead 2-0) 

Post#112 » by Hal14 » Thu Apr 20, 2023 5:24 pm

Good grief. Didn't BK post those exact same stats in the JB thread? Why does that guy have to turn every thread into a JB bashing thread? Those stats have nothing to do with game 2 from the other night vs the Hawks :banghead:
Nothing wrong with having a different opinion - as long as it's done respectfully. It'd be lame if we all agreed on everything :)

Return to Boston Celtics