rmfc wrote:Piston Pete wrote:chrbal wrote:
If Smith can keep up his Pacer pace. Sure. Money being even I think it’s a toss up.
Smith is a better shooter
Smith is a better rebounder
Smith is a better shot-blocker
Smith is a better defender
Smith is younger
Bagley is decent, I don’t hate the guy. But if I get to chose one to be a Detroit Piston PF/C hybrid, I’m choosing Smith.
Jalen Smith is also a better fit with the team's current needs. I'd easily pick Jalen Smith over Marvin Bagley.
More than anything else, Bagley's defense is just horrendous. Bagley can score in a more variety of ways compared to Jalen but this team needs better defense (and ability to stretch the floor) from the front court than scoring versatility.
Which is all probably true. My issue with Smith is largely the fact that he did really well when the Pacers season was over. The suns giving him for nothing, a cheap owner taking on more money to get rid of him.
But honestly, I’m indifferent between the two of them. Considering they most likely will wind up being career backups, I’d rather go with Bagley whose pretty much shown what he is vs the player that’s largely an unknown commodity in Smith.
If I’m wrong so be it