payitforward wrote:dckingsfan wrote:payitforward wrote:My premise is that the Wiz, being a really awful team year upon year, simply need to rebuild. Expiring veterans in/out just don't matter, whether it's KCP or Barton. To me, IOW, the trade simply amounts to Ish for Morris: the other two guys are noise not signal.
For that reason, I loved the trade. Plus, I would likely have let Ish's option lapse, so to me it looks like we acquired Monte Morris for nothing!
From that perspective I have to agree with you. This keeps us treading water without throwing off assets.
From my perspective, we are signing Beal to pair with Monte Morris for the next two years. To me, that is a disaster - well, I guess trying for the play-in isn't really a disaster but... you get where I am going with this.
If that was your "best" move. You don't sign Beal. You do a S&T. Because three seasons from now Beal is 31...
If you look at this trade - fine, I will give you it isn't horrible. When you look at it in context... not so pretty.
Why does it have to be "your 'best' move?" It's A move. & a substantial upgrade as well -- from Ish to Morris. At no cost. Plus, the "context" doesn't change the move! No matter what, Monte Morris is a zillion times better than Ish Smith. & Ish is 36. Presumably this is his last year. Instead of going away for nothing, in other words, he got us Morris.
& it'll be hard to think of or do anything at all to make re-signing Brad for $45m/year anything but an utterly disastrous mistake.
I look at the trade with the Brad resigning in the same lens (I could see disagreeing with this, that they should be looked at as independent events).
I see the two as individual tactics without a strategy - and agreed - tactical and a strategic disaster.
And name that tune:
"Tactics without strategy is the noise before defeat".
Sun Tzu