Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
Moderators: HerSports85, NoLayupRule, GONYK, Jeff Van Gully, dakomish23, Deeeez Knicks, mpharris36, j4remi
Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
Hi Knick fans !
The votes have been tallied, the off-season been graded, the season been predicted now let’s play some ball !
Mod willing , I’d like to start a series of polls to determine who we think should be the starting lineup for the 22-23 Knicks . This can be very interesting who knows what we come with ?!
Each poll will last 1 day to keep the process moving in a timely fashion.
We will start with the backcourt:
Then we go to move on to the FC going C to Sf.
So 1st roster decision my Friends: Pointguard.
Next roster decision : Shooting guard
Next roster decision : Center
Current lineup:
1. pointguard | Jalen Brunson (82% of votes)
2. shooting guard | Quentin Grimes (59% votes)
———————
Bottom of Page 1 for backups.
For backups the minute allocation for a backup can be complicated or semantical .
So I think the simplest way would be to make the best 5 man squad to spar our starters : starting with pointguard.
Next position SG.
Next position C
Same time frame as other polls. 1 day. If we get activity we’ll continue the series or see if dies on the vine .
Current backups :
Pointguard | Derrick Rose (75% of votes)
Shooting guard | Immanuel Quickley (44% of votes)
The votes have been tallied, the off-season been graded, the season been predicted now let’s play some ball !
Mod willing , I’d like to start a series of polls to determine who we think should be the starting lineup for the 22-23 Knicks . This can be very interesting who knows what we come with ?!
Each poll will last 1 day to keep the process moving in a timely fashion.
We will start with the backcourt:
Then we go to move on to the FC going C to Sf.
So 1st roster decision my Friends: Pointguard.
Next roster decision : Shooting guard
Next roster decision : Center
Current lineup:
1. pointguard | Jalen Brunson (82% of votes)
2. shooting guard | Quentin Grimes (59% votes)
———————
Bottom of Page 1 for backups.
For backups the minute allocation for a backup can be complicated or semantical .
So I think the simplest way would be to make the best 5 man squad to spar our starters : starting with pointguard.
Next position SG.
Next position C
Same time frame as other polls. 1 day. If we get activity we’ll continue the series or see if dies on the vine .
Current backups :
Pointguard | Derrick Rose (75% of votes)
Shooting guard | Immanuel Quickley (44% of votes)
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
Went Hartenstein .
Was only person who voted for Obi so went with more realistic option .
Mitch would probably be my last choice on the list to start .
Was only person who voted for Obi so went with more realistic option .
Mitch would probably be my last choice on the list to start .
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
For some reason
more than the others feels like it’s Mitch vs the field . And it’s fair.
more than the others feels like it’s Mitch vs the field . And it’s fair.

Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,438
- And1: 5,683
- Joined: Jun 04, 2005
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
Hartenstein
Mitch is a 10pts/8reb/2blk guy regardless if he starts or comes off the bench
Hartenstein's outside shooting and passing opens up the floor (especially the paint) for everyone else. He's also not terrible defensively, so not a whole lot is lost from moving Mitch to the bench.
Mitch is a 10pts/8reb/2blk guy regardless if he starts or comes off the bench
Hartenstein's outside shooting and passing opens up the floor (especially the paint) for everyone else. He's also not terrible defensively, so not a whole lot is lost from moving Mitch to the bench.
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
- HarthorneWingo
- RealGM
- Posts: 97,170
- And1: 62,279
- Joined: May 16, 2005
- Location: In Your Head, USA
-
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
Can we be real, for once? lol
Mitch is starting. (eye roll gif)
Mitch is starting. (eye roll gif)
Free Palestine
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
- HarthorneWingo
- RealGM
- Posts: 97,170
- And1: 62,279
- Joined: May 16, 2005
- Location: In Your Head, USA
-
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
ctorres wrote:Hartenstein
Mitch is a 10pts/8reb/2blk guy regardless if he starts or comes off the bench
Hartenstein's outside shooting and passing opens up the floor (especially the paint) for everyone else. He's also not terrible defensively, so not a whole lot is lost from moving Mitch to the bench.
He'll get a lot more usage with the second unit and can still end up playing most of the 4th quarter (if that's what the game dictates). I want to see him playing with Obi ... and whoever is left on the second unit.

Free Palestine
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
Team Hartenstein I see you .
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,868
- And1: 5,173
- Joined: Jun 15, 2002
- Location: NYC Queens
-
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
Mitch will start but there will always be plenty of minutes for the others. He's only averaged 23 minutes for his career and 25 minutes last year. Not much will change imo
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,396
- And1: 6,331
- Joined: May 18, 2017
-
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
bearadonisdna wrote:Went Hartenstein .
Was only person who voted for Obi so went with more realistic option .
Mitch would probably be my last choice on the list to start .
Hartenstein also. Thought I'd be alone, but giving Mitch a run for his money...
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
After this poll Mitch better not get in my face.
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
- KnixtapeH20
- RealGM
- Posts: 10,769
- And1: 16,568
- Joined: Feb 08, 2021
-
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
8 ppl need to be banned. Mods I need names. I can guess some lol
U can't say the r word so 8 ppl have extra chromosomes
Buzz prolly voted the last 1 well bc he's buzz lmao
U can't say the r word so 8 ppl have extra chromosomes

Buzz prolly voted the last 1 well bc he's buzz lmao
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,532
- And1: 5,695
- Joined: Mar 01, 2005
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
Since tanking has long been off the table:
Brunson
Mitchell
RJ
Bamba
Robinson
Please.
Brunson
Mitchell
RJ
Bamba
Robinson
Please.
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
- PerkinsFor3
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,989
- And1: 2,065
- Joined: Nov 10, 2004
- Contact:
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
Theres 8 people who realistically believe the 16/2 signee will start over 60/4 guy? Okay.
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Starting Lineup! C
PerkinsFor3 wrote:Theres 8 people who realistically believe the 16/2 signee will start over 60/4 guy? Okay.
Lol I totally want to address this but it’s too early today to be ragging on Mitch I don’t want to be that guy. Especially since our board has been under attack by the Utahs.
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
——————————
Welcome to Page 1 for backups.
For backups the minute allocation for a backup can be complicated or semantical .
So I think the simplest way would be to make the best 5 man squad to spar our starters : starting with pointguard.
Next position SG.
Next position C
Same time frame as other polls. 1 day. If we get activity we’ll continue the series or see if dies on the vine .
Current backups :
Pointguard | Derrick Rose (75% of votes)
Shooting guard | Immanuel Quickley (44% of votes)
Welcome to Page 1 for backups.
For backups the minute allocation for a backup can be complicated or semantical .
So I think the simplest way would be to make the best 5 man squad to spar our starters : starting with pointguard.
Next position SG.
Next position C
Same time frame as other polls. 1 day. If we get activity we’ll continue the series or see if dies on the vine .
Current backups :
Pointguard | Derrick Rose (75% of votes)
Shooting guard | Immanuel Quickley (44% of votes)
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
Went Hartenstein for backup
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
We need 4 votes to continue to next position .
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
So we’re gonna wrap up this attempted series of positional data due to lack of activity .
Results for Backup center ,backup Power forward , and backup small forward are inconclusive .
Results for Backup center ,backup Power forward , and backup small forward are inconclusive .
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
- Jalen Bluntson
- RealGM
- Posts: 25,310
- And1: 26,985
- Joined: Nov 07, 2012
-
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
Evan squeezes minutes from IQ/Grimes/Cam. Everyone else is set. Rose will backup Brunson.
IQ/Grimes/Cam fighting for backup minutes behind RJ/Evan.
Cam is in no man's land.
Obi backs up Randle.
Shartenstein backs up Mitch but probably sees more minutes than the other backups.
Until the roster is set. 10 different threads to discuss these positions is ridiculous.
IQ/Grimes/Cam fighting for backup minutes behind RJ/Evan.
Cam is in no man's land.
Obi backs up Randle.
Shartenstein backs up Mitch but probably sees more minutes than the other backups.
Until the roster is set. 10 different threads to discuss these positions is ridiculous.

Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,757
- And1: 5,394
- Joined: Jul 07, 2012
Re: Let’s Make The Knicks Bench Lineup! C page 1
Are We Ther Yet wrote:Evan squeezes minutes from IQ/Grimes/Cam. Everyone else is set. Rose will backup Brunson.
IQ/Grimes/Cam fighting for backup minutes behind RJ/Evan.
Cam is in no man's land.
Obi backs up Randle.
Shartenstein backs up Mitch but probably sees more minutes than the other backups.
Until the roster is set. 10 different threads to discuss these positions is ridiculous.
This is specifically for centers .