Roger Murdock wrote:Yeah if you disregard everyone elses injuries. Sexton was a starter and 24ppg player and he missed the entire season. The Cavs fell apart because they needed bodies who could play and nobody else could score except Garland. Hell yes him missing games mattered.
Sexton is just not good my man, I don't view him as a positive contributor at all and that's not a fringe opinion, so we'll just have to agree to disagree on that. I think him being absent made the Cavs much better by unlocking Garland.
Roger Murdock wrote:Harden/Simmons missing 3/4 of the season matters, because next year, they are going to get a hell of a lot more games out of that salary spot.
I agree it matters but it has nothing to do with injury luck. Simmons didn't miss all of his games in Philly because of bad luck due to injuries. Your whole argument is that the Raptors had better injury luck than most other teams, so Philly really isn't relevant to the conversation.
Roger Murdock wrote:Your 'corrections' include completely removing teams that were gashed from injuries in an effort to normalize their luck to the Raptors. See the chart that Aussie Celtic posted. Only teams with better injury luck than the Raptors were the Celtics (who I did *not* include in this comparison, because like the Raptors they were lucky) and Utah, who is clearly going to fall off.
I just don't weigh that chart super highly because it includes a bunch of roleplayers who missed time, which matters much less than a team's top 3-4 players missing time. I don't see the numbers behind the VORP bubbles, maybe you can list them? Because just eyeballing it the VORP that the Raps lost due to injury looks pretty equal with CLE, is slightly more than PHI and MIL, is slightly less than CHI, and is much less than MIA (which I have already conceded had much worse injury luck than most other teams).
So what I read from that chart is that the Raptors lost about the same value from injuries as those other teams (except Miami) but had a fewer 'total games lost to injury' because that chart is counting all the scrub roleplayers that missed time on those teams who weren't significant contributors to overall win rate.
You're unlucky if your top players miss significantly more time than other teams' top players. The Raptors top players missed roughly the equivalent of or more time than the teams you listed, with the exception of Miami. That part isn't disputable, so your whole argument is that the Raptors were lucky to be a playoff team because they didn't have significant injuries to guys like... Yuta Watanabe and Chris Boucher? Okay, man.