thebuzzardman wrote:NoDopeOnSundays wrote:
Mitch is less problematic than Randle in an offense, you could run spain PnR with Mitch and Obi, those sets the Hawks killed us with where Collins & Capella were setting screens at the same time? We could do that with them if they have Mitchell/Brunson as primary ball handlers.
Randle isn't a good enough finisher at the rim for that kind of thing, you can only do it with 2 skywalkers.
Good point. I'm torn on Randle, even after being really pissed at him last year.
Same for Obi, different reasons.
I suppose how I feel is a loose summary of the overall take on both
Obi is getting better and needs an expanded role - this amount of which depends on where you are on the Obi spectrum.
There are defensive concerns for Obi; generally Randle is better except last year when he mailed it in
Have some concerns for Obi in the halfcourt offense, particularly when teams zone up and he's asked to create his own offense more. 3 point shot concerns add to this.
Randle can more reliably create offense in the half court, he can certainly pass well for a big, but there's a concern Randle's passing comes with dominating the ball.
Counter argument is Randle got put in a role one level too high and can do well if asked to do less
Counter counter argument is Randle really doesn't have the inclination to play that way and is less effective in that role
Also, with Brunson and Donovan M, Knicks would have two guys who can score when "the play breaks down", so it's better to have willing cutters, stay in their lane shooters and finisher types.
I mean, Utah thrived with Uber P&R Gobert, Mitchell, with Conley, and Boj B providing spacing (not all but this is long enough) with Ingles the willing do it all glue guy and Clarkson to keep the shooting/scoring going off the bench.
Meaning, teams can do well and don't know the 3rd option to be as skilled as Randle, especially if he's not going to stay in his lane.
I'd probably sacrifice Grimes on the alter of getting DMitch and saving a future pick, probably shed Cam too, and Rose (who I like) and keep Fournier and IQ for bench shooting, Randle to see if he can embrace an uber role player mindset, and if not, that's 25 million to deal.
Yes, I know that's giving up defense, height, that Utah might say f*ck off, and the risk Randle acts like a d*ckbag.
Brunson/IQ
DMitchell/Fournier
RJ/ Feron Hunt (bootleg Cam Reddish) or mle vet
Randle/Obi
Big Mitch/Hartenstein
Various pieces (McBride traded)