ImageImageImageImage

Poll: best of "three bold trades"

Moderators: ChosenSavior, UCF, Knightro, UCFJayBird, Def Swami, Howard Mass

consider the trade not the player per se:

1) Donovan Mitchell trade
8
36%
2) Simmons trade
4
18%
3) Herro trade
10
45%
 
Total votes: 22

User avatar
drsd
RealGM
Posts: 39,052
And1: 8,904
Joined: Mar 16, 2003
     

Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#1 » by drsd » Mon Aug 8, 2022 9:50 pm

3 Bold Magic Trades To Find Paolo Banchero Co-Star


LINK

Which is your favourite?

1) Utah Jazz Star Donovan Mitchell

Utah Jazz Receive: G Markelle Fultz, F/C Jonathan Isaac, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2027 First-Round Pick (ORL)

Orlando Magic Receive: G Donovan Mitchell

.....

2) Brooklyn Nets Star Ben Simmons

Brooklyn Nets Receive: G/F Jaylen Brown, F/C Jonathan Isaac, G Markelle Fultz, G Derrick White, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (BOS), 2027 First-Round Pick (BOS), 2029 First-Round Pick (Swap – BOS)

Boston Celtics Receive: F Kevin Durant

Orlando Magic Receive: G/F Ben Simmons

(For Orlando, this is Isaac, Fultz, 2023 FRP for Simmons)
.......


3) Miami Heat Star Tyler Herro

Miami Heat Receive: G/F Gary Harris, F Chuma Okeke, G Devin Cannady, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (ORL)

Orlando Magic Receive: G/F Duncan Robinson, G Tyler Herro
anothermagicfan
Pro Prospect
Posts: 826
And1: 344
Joined: Dec 28, 2016
       

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#2 » by anothermagicfan » Mon Aug 8, 2022 10:33 pm

I find all 3 trade options to be terribly horrific trades for orlando
Skybox
RealGM
Posts: 18,364
And1: 8,424
Joined: Jan 21, 2017
 

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#3 » by Skybox » Tue Aug 9, 2022 2:37 am

Bad. How about protections on the picks?- that might make them ‘maybes’
zaymon
Head Coach
Posts: 6,068
And1: 3,405
Joined: Jul 01, 2015
   

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#4 » by zaymon » Tue Aug 9, 2022 4:10 am

I dont like Mitchell but #1 is interesting. We dont give up Suggs which is crucial becouse someone needs to guard perimeter. Picks hurt but we still would have Bulls and Nuggets and we could actually be better than Bulls next year. Fit is great.

Simmons is not an option since we have Banchero. His attitude is big problem, he is a loser.

Herro trade is the worst. Two picks for Heat bench players ? Tyler is very similar to Fournier, not a star and will cost a lot. Herro is expiring, we got 2 seconds for Evan and while Tyler is better he is not worth two firsts, and in reality 3 becouse Robinson is bad contract and Harris solid rotation player on great contract. Ridicilous.
My money is on Banchero going number 1 !
cedric76
RealGM
Posts: 16,216
And1: 3,715
Joined: May 28, 2005

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#5 » by cedric76 » Tue Aug 9, 2022 5:14 am

drsd wrote:
3 Bold Magic Trades To Find Paolo Banchero Co-Star


LINK

Which is your favourite?

1) Utah Jazz Star Donovan Mitchell

Utah Jazz Receive: G Markelle Fultz, F/C Jonathan Isaac, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2027 First-Round Pick (ORL)

Orlando Magic Receive: G Donovan Mitchell

.....

2) Brooklyn Nets Star Ben Simmons

Brooklyn Nets Receive: G/F Jaylen Brown, F/C Jonathan Isaac, G Markelle Fultz, G Derrick White, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (BOS), 2027 First-Round Pick (BOS), 2029 First-Round Pick (Swap – BOS)

Boston Celtics Receive: F Kevin Durant

Orlando Magic Receive: G/F Ben Simmons

(For Orlando, this is Isaac, Fultz, 2023 FRP for Simmons)
.......


3) Miami Heat Star Tyler Herro

Miami Heat Receive: G/F Gary Harris, F Chuma Okeke, G Devin Cannady, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (ORL)

Orlando Magic Receive: G/F Duncan Robinson, G Tyler Herro


Bold or awful?
Suggs, Tyus, Jase
Bane, AB, Jett
Franz, TDS,
P5, JI, Panda
Wcj, Goga, Moe
User avatar
Howard Mass
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 66,386
And1: 16,305
Joined: Feb 20, 2001
Location: Longwood, Florida
Contact:
       

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#6 » by Howard Mass » Tue Aug 9, 2022 9:03 am

Sometimes the best trade is the one you don't make.
R.I.P. Dharam Raghubir (A.K.A. Magnumt)

:beer:
User avatar
Ducklett
General Manager
Posts: 8,039
And1: 5,501
Joined: Jul 17, 2012
 

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#7 » by Ducklett » Tue Aug 9, 2022 9:23 am

Magic cannot trade unprotected 2023 unless the player we get back cements us into the playoffs. None of these players here do that.
User avatar
MoMM
RealGM
Posts: 10,553
And1: 1,766
Joined: Jan 08, 2002
Location: Brazilian in Barcelona
Contact:
       

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#8 » by MoMM » Tue Aug 9, 2022 1:10 pm

If the picks are lottery-protected or something like this I'd consider, but unprotected ones? I won't even care to analyse any further.

BTW, I don't want Ben Simmons anyhow.
User avatar
ChosenSavior
Forum Mod - Magic
Forum Mod - Magic
Posts: 29,326
And1: 13,018
Joined: Sep 09, 2009
Location: San Antonio, TX
Contact:
   

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#9 » by ChosenSavior » Tue Aug 9, 2022 2:24 pm

anothermagicfan wrote:I find all 3 trade options to be terribly horrific trades for orlando
p0peye
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,838
And1: 3,341
Joined: Feb 27, 2006
 

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#10 » by p0peye » Tue Aug 9, 2022 3:16 pm

Fair trades, but picks need protections. I don't like Simmons and giving up 3 picks for Mitchell is bit too much for me even though Jazz will probably get that from someone. I'd go for Herro trade if we add some protections.
jonbob17
Analyst
Posts: 3,481
And1: 1,440
Joined: Jul 01, 2020

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#11 » by jonbob17 » Tue Aug 9, 2022 6:37 pm

I guess I'd lean Mitchell just because the price between him and Herro is a 2027 first, and he is a good deal better than Herro, and even though Herro has better size, i'd say they are similar on the defensive side.

I am probably not making any of these unless the 2023 is top 4 protected.

Simmons is the best value here, but just so much overlap with the Magic. Simmons is a point forward in my eyes, and i just don't see that working with Franz and Paolo. The one interesting thing that could change my mind would be if the Magic committed to small ball, with WCJ as a super sub, and played Simmons as a point-center. Probably not enough shooting, but a front court of Franz/Paolo/Simmons and add tall 3&D shooter. That could be something that works. I like the idea of the Magic going really tall and athletic, akin to the Raptors.
User avatar
tiderulz
RealGM
Posts: 36,918
And1: 14,847
Joined: Jun 16, 2010
Location: Atlanta
 

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#12 » by tiderulz » Tue Aug 9, 2022 9:08 pm

Miami doesnt get to drop DUncan Robinson and his bad contract along with Herro for 2 first round picks, unless at least one of them is lottery protected.
User avatar
drsd
RealGM
Posts: 39,052
And1: 8,904
Joined: Mar 16, 2003
     

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#13 » by drsd » Tue Aug 9, 2022 9:26 pm

tiderulz wrote:Miami doesnt get to drop DUncan Robinson and his bad contract along with Herro for 2 first round picks, unless at least one of them is lottery protected.


Conceptually, Robinson and Herro help the team grow, but Orlando would need a Brink's truck to resign them. I think both have an ego larger than their age and thus have a misguided view of their financial worth.

Look for example at the Heat - Magic idea, but make that applied to Utah. I very much like: Donovan Mitchell for
G/F Gary Harris, F Chuma Okeke, G Devin Cannady, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (ORL). Ross might need to be swapped in for Cannady for salary reasons. But that's the kind of consolidation trade Orlando profits from. (Heck, even swap Isaac for Okeke in the trade idea!)
User avatar
drsd
RealGM
Posts: 39,052
And1: 8,904
Joined: Mar 16, 2003
     

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#14 » by drsd » Tue Aug 9, 2022 9:27 pm

anothermagicfan wrote:I find all 3 trade options to be terribly horrific trades for orlando


I also lean towards, none of the above.


..
User avatar
SOUL
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 58,728
And1: 40,764
Joined: Dec 11, 2006
Location: █████████████
     

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#15 » by SOUL » Tue Aug 9, 2022 10:23 pm

drsd wrote:
tiderulz wrote:Miami doesnt get to drop DUncan Robinson and his bad contract along with Herro for 2 first round picks, unless at least one of them is lottery protected.


Conceptually, Robinson and Herro help the team grow, but Orlando would need a Brink's truck to resign them. I think both have an ego larger than their age and thus have a misguided view of their financial worth.

Look for example at the Heat - Magic idea, but make that applied to Utah. I very much like: Donovan Mitchell for
G/F Gary Harris, F Chuma Okeke, G Devin Cannady, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (ORL). Ross might need to be swapped in for Cannady for salary reasons. But that's the kind of consolidation trade Orlando profits from. (Heck, even swap Isaac for Okeke in the trade idea!)


Utah doesn't do that trade after getting five 1st round picks from Minnesota. They'd either want better younger talent in return or more picks, we can't only give 2 picks and barely any young talent.
www.rareslums.com // please support my writing!
User avatar
drsd
RealGM
Posts: 39,052
And1: 8,904
Joined: Mar 16, 2003
     

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#16 » by drsd » Tue Aug 9, 2022 10:40 pm

SOUL wrote:Utah doesn't do that trade after getting five 1st round picks from Minnesota. They'd either want better younger talent in return or more picks, we can't only give 2 picks and barely any young talent.


Isaac, Anthony, Ross, Harris, Orlando 2023 FRP, Orlando 2025 FRP, Bulls-FRP, Nuggets-FRP.

That's gotta be getting close.


Orlando becomes:
Fultz/Suggs/Cannady
Mitchell/Hampton/vet FA
F-Wagner/vet FA/Houstan
Banchero/Okeke/Bol
Carter/Bamba/M-Wagner



..
jonbob17
Analyst
Posts: 3,481
And1: 1,440
Joined: Jul 01, 2020

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#17 » by jonbob17 » Fri Aug 12, 2022 2:15 pm

drsd wrote:
tiderulz wrote:Miami doesnt get to drop DUncan Robinson and his bad contract along with Herro for 2 first round picks, unless at least one of them is lottery protected.


Conceptually, Robinson and Herro help the team grow, but Orlando would need a Brink's truck to resign them. I think both have an ego larger than their age and thus have a misguided view of their financial worth.

Look for example at the Heat - Magic idea, but make that applied to Utah. I very much like: Donovan Mitchell for
G/F Gary Harris, F Chuma Okeke, G Devin Cannady, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (ORL). Ross might need to be swapped in for Cannady for salary reasons. But that's the kind of consolidation trade Orlando profits from. (Heck, even swap Isaac for Okeke in the trade idea!)


Would they cost a lot to resign? I mean the most Herro is going to get is just about what Ayton got 4/133 (adjusted for new salary cap), 5 years if the team extends him before the deadline.

Personally I'd be a little wary of Herro at a max rookie extension, he may get it, but Iooking at last year's rookie extensions, I'd probably prefer JJJ (4/108) and Bridges (5/90) not even considering money. He will probably get the max based on his scoring, i am just not sure he's better than those guys, and I'd put him a good bit below SGA and a (healthy) MPJ

Duncan is 4+ years away from resigning and a somewhat negative contract at the moment. Honestly he might not be a bad guy to target. We could probably get him and something back for like Gary Harris. He's "only" 3/54 guaranteed, 4/64 total. Robinson still had 57% TS last year (same as Harris, best amongst our non-bigs). We have enough cap room to roll the dice on a guy like this and get some shooting back, and take a bet on him returning as an elite shooter.
User avatar
tiderulz
RealGM
Posts: 36,918
And1: 14,847
Joined: Jun 16, 2010
Location: Atlanta
 

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#18 » by tiderulz » Fri Aug 12, 2022 2:51 pm

jonbob17 wrote:
drsd wrote:
tiderulz wrote:Miami doesnt get to drop DUncan Robinson and his bad contract along with Herro for 2 first round picks, unless at least one of them is lottery protected.


Conceptually, Robinson and Herro help the team grow, but Orlando would need a Brink's truck to resign them. I think both have an ego larger than their age and thus have a misguided view of their financial worth.

Look for example at the Heat - Magic idea, but make that applied to Utah. I very much like: Donovan Mitchell for
G/F Gary Harris, F Chuma Okeke, G Devin Cannady, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (ORL). Ross might need to be swapped in for Cannady for salary reasons. But that's the kind of consolidation trade Orlando profits from. (Heck, even swap Isaac for Okeke in the trade idea!)


Would they cost a lot to resign? I mean the most Herro is going to get is just about what Ayton got 4/133 (adjusted for new salary cap), 5 years if the team extends him before the deadline.

Personally I'd be a little wary of Herro at a max rookie extension, he may get it, but Iooking at last year's rookie extensions, I'd probably prefer JJJ (4/108) and Bridges (5/90) not even considering money. He will probably get the max based on his scoring, i am just not sure he's better than those guys, and I'd put him a good bit below SGA and a (healthy) MPJ

Duncan is 4+ years away from resigning and a somewhat negative contract at the moment. Honestly he might not be a bad guy to target. We could probably get him and something back for like Gary Harris. He's "only" 3/54 guaranteed, 4/64 total. Robinson still had 57% TS last year (same as Harris, best amongst our non-bigs). We have enough cap room to roll the dice on a guy like this and get some shooting back, and take a bet on him returning as an elite shooter.

HArris is a 2 way player. Robinson is a little better shooter but not good on defense. oh, and he is a year older than Harris (not a big deal, just surprised me). I am just way about a 1-way player that is good but not elite in that skill.
pepe1991
RealGM
Posts: 22,971
And1: 18,965
Joined: Jan 10, 2016
   

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#19 » by pepe1991 » Fri Aug 12, 2022 3:28 pm

tiderulz wrote:
jonbob17 wrote:
drsd wrote:
Conceptually, Robinson and Herro help the team grow, but Orlando would need a Brink's truck to resign them. I think both have an ego larger than their age and thus have a misguided view of their financial worth.

Look for example at the Heat - Magic idea, but make that applied to Utah. I very much like: Donovan Mitchell for
G/F Gary Harris, F Chuma Okeke, G Devin Cannady, 2023 First-Round Pick (ORL), 2025 First-Round Pick (ORL). Ross might need to be swapped in for Cannady for salary reasons. But that's the kind of consolidation trade Orlando profits from. (Heck, even swap Isaac for Okeke in the trade idea!)


Would they cost a lot to resign? I mean the most Herro is going to get is just about what Ayton got 4/133 (adjusted for new salary cap), 5 years if the team extends him before the deadline.

Personally I'd be a little wary of Herro at a max rookie extension, he may get it, but Iooking at last year's rookie extensions, I'd probably prefer JJJ (4/108) and Bridges (5/90) not even considering money. He will probably get the max based on his scoring, i am just not sure he's better than those guys, and I'd put him a good bit below SGA and a (healthy) MPJ

Duncan is 4+ years away from resigning and a somewhat negative contract at the moment. Honestly he might not be a bad guy to target. We could probably get him and something back for like Gary Harris. He's "only" 3/54 guaranteed, 4/64 total. Robinson still had 57% TS last year (same as Harris, best amongst our non-bigs). We have enough cap room to roll the dice on a guy like this and get some shooting back, and take a bet on him returning as an elite shooter.

HArris is a 2 way player. Robinson is a little better shooter but not good on defense. oh, and he is a year older than Harris (not a big deal, just surprised me). I am just way about a 1-way player that is good but not elite in that skill.


Harris is much worst shooter.

He is career 36% for 3 witch makes him definition of average nba shooter.
Duncan Robinson is career 40,6% three point shooter.
At first sight that difference doesn't sound like big deal, but 4,6% for 3 is difference for career between Steph Curry and some Evan Fournier or Christian Wood. It's massive one.

Not just that, Duncan Robinson in 4 years made more threes than Gary Harris in 9. So Duncan has ability to make shots at higher clip and at much higher volumen.

IN addition, Harris in his entire career never made more than 6 threes in single game. Duncan Robinson made more than 6 threes three different times in playoffs alone :lol:

In general, Gary Harris was never ment to be "spot up shooter", for career 2 point shots make 57% of all shots Gary Harris took, where Duncan Robinson averages 13,5% of all shots for 2 lol.
Gary Harris is dude who was always viewed as some Bradley Beal arhytype, somebody who can make 3s at high rate, but who's game is more well rounded, but after year 4 his body gave up on him and all driving, long 2s , attacking rim had to be replaced by overhouling his whole game.
During his 3rd year for example, 40% of all shots were inside 3 feet ( layups , dunks) , 20% of shots were mid range, 40% were for 3.

But his injuries forced him to change everything, so now , for example last year, he averaged 15% FGA inside 3 feet, but 55% of all shots for 3.


Neither are playable on contenders for long period of times. Duncan Robinson is just more reliable shooter, better player off ball ( constant movment) and has ability to get super hot.
Gary Harris plays okey defense but won't lock down anybody but that's not issue. Issue is fact that he hasn't been healthy in half of decade and you expect to have him for like 40-60 game a year.
Life is what happens when you're busy making other plans. -John Lennon
User avatar
tiderulz
RealGM
Posts: 36,918
And1: 14,847
Joined: Jun 16, 2010
Location: Atlanta
 

Re: Poll: best of "three bold trades" 

Post#20 » by tiderulz » Fri Aug 12, 2022 4:17 pm

pepe1991 wrote:
tiderulz wrote:
jonbob17 wrote:
Would they cost a lot to resign? I mean the most Herro is going to get is just about what Ayton got 4/133 (adjusted for new salary cap), 5 years if the team extends him before the deadline.

Personally I'd be a little wary of Herro at a max rookie extension, he may get it, but Iooking at last year's rookie extensions, I'd probably prefer JJJ (4/108) and Bridges (5/90) not even considering money. He will probably get the max based on his scoring, i am just not sure he's better than those guys, and I'd put him a good bit below SGA and a (healthy) MPJ

Duncan is 4+ years away from resigning and a somewhat negative contract at the moment. Honestly he might not be a bad guy to target. We could probably get him and something back for like Gary Harris. He's "only" 3/54 guaranteed, 4/64 total. Robinson still had 57% TS last year (same as Harris, best amongst our non-bigs). We have enough cap room to roll the dice on a guy like this and get some shooting back, and take a bet on him returning as an elite shooter.

HArris is a 2 way player. Robinson is a little better shooter but not good on defense. oh, and he is a year older than Harris (not a big deal, just surprised me). I am just way about a 1-way player that is good but not elite in that skill.


Harris is much worst shooter.

He is career 36% for 3 witch makes him definition of average nba shooter.
Duncan Robinson is career 40,6% three point shooter.
At first sight that difference doesn't sound like big deal, but 4,6% for 3 is difference for career between Steph Curry and some Evan Fournier or Christian Wood. It's massive one.

Not just that, Duncan Robinson in 4 years made more threes than Gary Harris in 9. So Duncan has ability to make shots at higher clip and at much higher volumen.

IN addition, Harris in his entire career never made more than 6 threes in single game. Duncan Robinson made more than 6 threes three different times in playoffs alone :lol:

In general, Gary Harris was never ment to be "spot up shooter", for career 2 point shots make 57% of all shots Gary Harris took, where Duncan Robinson averages 13,5% of all shots for 2 lol.
Gary Harris is dude who was always viewed as some Bradley Beal arhytype, somebody who can make 3s at high rate, but who's game is more well rounded, but after year 4 his body gave up on him and all driving, long 2s , attacking rim had to be replaced by overhouling his whole game.
During his 3rd year for example, 40% of all shots were inside 3 feet ( layups , dunks) , 20% of shots were mid range, 40% were for 3.

But his injuries forced him to change everything, so now , for example last year, he averaged 15% FGA inside 3 feet, but 55% of all shots for 3.


Neither are playable on contenders for long period of times. Duncan Robinson is just more reliable shooter, better player off ball ( constant movment) and has ability to get super hot.
Gary Harris plays okey defense but won't lock down anybody but that's not issue. Issue is fact that he hasn't been healthy in half of decade and you expect to have him for like 40-60 game a year.

Harris also had injury which impacted him and dragged that career % down. You can see he can be a good shooter, with years at 42%, 40% and 38%. Harris last year from Dec 1 and on was around 42%. maybe he is finally healthy. and no, i did not call Harris a "bradley beal" or even made any type of comparison about that. and Duncan has more volume at 3% because that is all he can do. if he tries to get closer to the basket he gets blocked, doesnt help being non-athletic in the NBA.

if you are going to quote me and use my statements, then use them, dont make it out like i said things i didnt.

Return to Orlando Magic