ronnymac2 wrote:Owly wrote:ronnymac2 wrote:This guy led the league in total turnovers in 1984 and didn't even average four assists per game. This is almost Shawn Kemp-levels of sloppy turnover economy relative to creative ability/load. It's terrible and shows a very low basketball iq.
Depends on other stuff and how many turnover you might think are a given but you raise assists and turnovers here ... just by the conventional A:T ratio his number is sub 1, but it's not a Duckworthian circa 0.5; Seikaly-eque 0.45 (there are worse but can't find the post I had).
It's a very high turnover number but I'd guess at a glance it's the worst a:t year of his meaningful career, and certainly the turnovers are very high and a:t is just one (simple) tool but I'd say the assists, from center, are a slight mitigation.
Whilst I don't love high turnovers I'd dispute that it necessarily show "a very low basketball iq" that would depend on the causes/circumstances (is it [mis]reading D, or is it setting picks, or is it catching passes, or is it grabbing rebounds ...).
Are there worse offenders (in terms of Assists/Turnover ratio) who had similar volume (raw average)*** of assists and turnovers as Ruland? Shoutout to Penbeast's McGinnis mention as that is the only one off the top of my head that is comparable.
Fair point about what the high turnovers by themselves reveal about Ruland's Bball IQ. In all fairness, I'm not super familiar with Ruland's game on tape/eye-test observation.
***Equal or greater than 3.8 assists per game and equal or greater than 3.8 turnovers per game over a 200-game sample
In terms of awful A:T ratios in noteworthy players, I'm not sure anyone is more eye-popping [not in good way] than Moses Malone: career avg of 0.45 Ast:TO. In his consensus peak season ['83], it's actually worse: 0.38.
But I think Ast:TO ratio is of limited value in evaluating all-around turnover economy (as is TOV%).
I've made my own metric that I use (called Modified TOV% [mTOV%]). To be sure: Moses does look pretty bad by mTOV%, too; but his Ast:TO ratio makes him look like the worst ever.