Dirk wrote:Important point made.
While I we may read a few niche opinions about FIBA>NBA (aesthetically) and that's fine, since it's just about "taste" and subjectivity, it's still very outlandish.
If FIBA style basketball was indeed better on the eye or a better brand of the sport, it would draw more viewers. It appears that basketball in Europe makes huge losses (Real, Barcelona lose tens of millions of euros) and I see that clubs in Greece, Turkey, Russia... likely are just banked by the owners.
That highly suggests that there isn't a market there for it (paying fans, tv money)... there isn't an audience to match the spending of the big clubs.
As you said, it's about personal preference. It's 100% subjective. Therefore, I don't think that it's something that can really be judged. People like what they like for whatever reasons they like it.
Dirk wrote:I guess you can even point out this whole "let's give citizenship to foreign guy to play for our team"... which points to countries not having enough talent (people playing) to draw from.
The reason why some countries do not have enough talent to draw from isn't necessarily because people don't play the sport in that country. It can just as easily be that the country itself is too small. Slovenia's population barely exceeds 2 million, for example, while North Macedonia's (mentioned here because Bo McCalebb's naturalization and consequent success definitely helped popularize the concept even more) population is actually below 2 million.
When your population is so small then, yes, your talent pool is going to be significantly restricted, regardless of how popular the sport is in the country.
Now, granted, there are definitely countries that have a limited talent pool to choose from because basketball just isn't very popular there. But there are also those that love the sport but have a restricted talent pool (either due to the size of the country or for some other reason) which forces them to seek out naturalized players to fill these gaps.
Dirk wrote:Imagine you had someone who never watched basketball and landed here from Mars. You showed them Euroleague basketball. And NBA basketball. More likely than not... they'd prefer the latter. The reasons are obvious... athleticism and skill. It doesn't even feel like the same sport at times.
I mean, you can't really say that. Since the person in your example is an alien being who landed here from Mars, we really have no idea to know what their criteria are going to be. Heck, we don't even know if they process sensory information the same way we do.
If you were talking about a human being then, sure, you could make this claim but I don't think that you can (or need) to use an alien being for this hypothetical
Dirk wrote:I think some may just get caught up in the moment as they're watching an international tournament, where it's tense and it's one and done... and then they draw comparisons to NBA where we have 82 games in a regular season and then 7 game series. I guess to sum up my point... if anyone genuinely thinks FIBA>NBA, they probably should be aware of how much of a niche opinion that is.
Sure. Same thing happens with March Madness.
Dirk wrote:I say to those who love FIBA: Just enjoy it. You don't have to compare the two brands of the sport and provoke reactions and leave folks like me dumbfounded.
Here's the thing, though. The vast majority of the posts you're talking about do not come from international fans. These posts usually come from American fans who are disappointed by the NBA for a number of different reasons. And, heck, some times these reasons don't even have to do with basketball itself. Most of the time these posts aren't about people actually preferring FIBA basketball over NBA basketball, it's about preferring a single rule or two. Or, sometimes, they're just meant to piss at the NBA because they're mad at the league for whatever reason (it can even be a political reason, depending on what's trending in the media).
In short, most of these comments have absolutely nothing to do with the majority of the posters in this thread. They're made from a different subset of posters for wildly varying reasons. We have nothing to do with them
