Chris Vs. George

[dygaction]

Which team wins? All players at their peaks. Year 85 rule.

Team Chris:
PG: Chris Paul
SG: Chris Mullin
SF: Khris Middleton
PF: Chris Weber
C: Chris Bosh
Bench: Chris Ford/Doug Christie/Chris Morris/Chris Gatling/Chris Kaman/Christian Laettner

Team George:
PG: George Hill
SG: Paul George
SF: George Gervin
PF: George McGinnis
C: George Mikan
Bench: George Thompson/George Carter/George Yardley/George McCloud III/George Johnson

[OhayoKD]

chrises probably

[dygaction]

Curious why Chrises getting more votes. There is a big gap between CP3 and George Hill, but the other four positions are quite arguably all leaning towards Georges. Is players coming from more recent for Chrises a big factor?

[penbeast0]

Which team wins? All players at their peaks. Year 85 rule.

Team Chris:
PG: Chris Paul
SG: Chris Mullin
SF: Khris Middleton
PF: Chris Weber
C: Chris Bosh
Bench: Chris Ford/Doug Christie/Chris Morris/Chris Gatling/Chris Kaman/Christian Laettner

Team George:
PG: George Hill
SG: Paul George
SF: George Gervin
PF: George McGinnis
C: George Mikan
Bench: George Thompson/George Carter/George Yardley/George McCloud III/George Johnson

85 rules AND COACHING, time machine format, it's close. 85 rules allowing modern playstyles and coaching, Team Chris wins easily. Era dominance translated to 1985, team George wins easily.

[dygaction]

Which team wins? All players at their peaks. Year 85 rule.

Team Chris:
PG: Chris Paul
SG: Chris Mullin
SF: Khris Middleton
PF: Chris Weber
C: Chris Bosh
Bench: Chris Ford/Doug Christie/Chris Morris/Chris Gatling/Chris Kaman/Christian Laettner

Team George:
PG: George Hill
SG: Paul George
SF: George Gervin
PF: George McGinnis
C: George Mikan
Bench: George Thompson/George Carter/George Yardley/George McCloud III/George Johnson

85 rules AND COACHING, time machine format, it's close. 85 rules allowing modern playstyles and coaching, Team Chris wins easily. Era dominance translated to 1985, team George wins easily.

Definitely not era dominance translation, that would be unfair...
By 85 rules allowing modern playstyles, are you mostly concerned with Chris teams spamming 3s?

[penbeast0]

Time machine, I don't think Mikan's game with the primitive hook shots and the like translates; Gervin is lesser too and they are the peak players on that team.

Era dominance, Mikan is an easy #1, Gervin and Paul compete for #2. McGinnis not a good fit on his team, Hill probably the weakest player out there.

I just don't see a way to make a reasonable comp; too much variance for "all born around 1960" to work and their games wouldn't work the same way. At least with either era dominance or time machine you can make some sort of an educated guess how it would go but either way, it quits being a close comp.

[durantbird]

Kevins