JMAC3 wrote:reanimator wrote:JMAC3 wrote:
Great, we have established both players have gone through struggles at some point this year.
Who has the better overall shooting numbers?
Who has had the best peak games?
Miller is obviously the better shooter. Hands down and his shot distribution is better even if I expect Scoot to be a much better finisher than Miller at the pro level.
but Miller is also playing against inferior competition.
There are no Missouris, Georgias, Ole Miss in the G league. Don't get me started on the non-conference portion of these college player's schedules. I'll easily take Scoot's peak performances with Ignite.
His peak performances playing on an 8-11 team where he has hit no game winners and struggling to score 20 ppg in a fast-paced scoring league that stats are easy to come by.
Vs Miller playing on a 25-6 team and being the #1 overall seed in the tourney, with multiple clutch moments of game altering shots and 4 30+ point performances.
You do you I suppose.
Scoot playing in front of 200 fans vs Miller playing in front of thousands of crazy fans heckling him. Scoot could go 1/15 tonight and they lose by 20 and nobody would talk about it tomorrow.
What does who is in the audience have to do with anything?
I'm supposed to give Miller the nod because he plays with elite guards, elite rim protectors, stretch bigs and his team holistically is above most of the field? 75% of those 25 wins are against subpar defense even for NCAA standards. If anything, Scoot playing on a talent poor team against grown men makes his peak performance even more incredible.
The thing with me is I have not 1 issue criticizing bad performance or any flaw I perceive when I watch Scoot.
If he sucks, I will adjust my eval and drop him but for now I see mostly reaches beyond concerns with his shot distribution.