Top 10 all-time if only playoffs count?

[70sFan]

Eh, Duncan had quite a few underperformances.

The biggest underperformance I can think of Duncan's prime are 2004 and 2008. These are not some horrible showings and other than that, he was remarkably consistent in over a decade of his best years.

If we're talking playoffs, you're basically putting both TD and Hakeem that high based on 03 & 94,

Not at all, I put them that high based on their remarkable consistency in the playoffs. As I said, ot's tough to find them play badly and they often increased their level of production and impact.

because the others below were better throughout their careers in the post-season.

How? Who? Why?

[Doctor MJ]

Topic.

Unrealistic hypothetical given seeding, etc, but say the playoffs play out exactly as they did in real life. Same performances, same matchups, same rosters, same winners/losers, same injuries, etc.

Who are your top 10 all-time?

Not a lot for me. The changes would be lower down than that.

My POY rankings in any year would certainly change in some years. Gobert in ‘20-21 is an example. I have him at #3 based on considering the entirety of the season, but he wouldn’t be in my Top 5 playoff performers.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk