CptCrunch wrote:Duke4life831 wrote:clyde21 wrote:
which 5 PGs starting in the NBA are better athletes than Scoot today?
only two you can make an argument for are Ja and Fox, and even then I can make a pretty solid pro Scoot argument in that convo. no one else is close now. Russ a few years ago obviously but not anymore.
Scoot he is a top 3 athlete at the PG position in the NBA on day one. and im talking true lead guards, Jalen Greens don't qualify.
Yup. Here is a quick link where you can see all the starting PGs from last year
http://www.espn.com/nba/depthJa and Fox are the only two I see with an argument over him, especially when you factor in Scoot will be significantly stronger than both of those guys on day 1. I mean even when you include the starting SGs on the list, still hard to push him out of the top 5.
Ja
Fox
Ant
Green
...
Ivey beats him in straight line speed, but Scoot is stronger and moves better laterally. Mitchell is explosive but not as agile. Sharpe is a fantastic leaper but I dont see the same on ball burst as Scoot. No way I see him as 5-10 at best when it comes to the starting PGs.
Maybe the number is lower than 5, but the only thing that matter is functional atheleticism here. Don't see Scoot driving his way to the basket like prime Rose with first step/explosiveness or prime Harden in craft. I do not think that his athleticism will define the way he plays ball; he is solidly in the category of young guards who are not held back by their lack of atheletic abilities from day 1.
Probably better - Morant, Fox, Porter Jr
Probably same tier - Ivey, Ben Simmons, Lavine, Fultz, Hayes, maybe the skeleton of Westbrook
My thing with Scoot is, his athleticism is functional. We arent talking Harrison Barnes or MPJ kind of empty gym athletes here. Scoot is strong, explosive, quick and moves well laterally.
Going off the guys you mentioned
Porter Jr (assuming Kevin): Kevin has very good wiggle. Not sure I have him over Scoot on anything else.
Ivey: elite straight line speed. I think Scoot is better laterally, has better wiggle, more explosive of a leaper and stronger
Simmons: Hard to compare a 6'10 guy
LaVine: LaVine has the hops but Im not sure what else after the surgeries. Dont think he's quicker.
Fultz: This ones not close. Fultz looks straight up slow compared to Scoot.
Hayes: Not sure I take Hayes in any athletic category over Scoot
Westrbook: Scoot is the better athlete than current Westbrook easily.
This is my point where I think we are at the point where we're just over scouting guys now, especially the guys we arent too fond of. Not saying this is just you, this is something everyone does.