What are your top 7 peaks of players you don't have as top 25 all time?

[Colbinii]

That's almost impossible. All people that have a top7 all-time peak are good enough for a top25 spot. But for me it's KD, everyone else is in top25.

You misread the question.

"Consider all players outside of your Top 25, who are the best peaks among them? List 7"

I understood the question perfectly. Only Kd.

Nah, you misunderstood. I even re-phrased the OP to make it more clear for you.


"Who are your Top 10 peaks of players who never made an all-star game?"

All my Top 10 peaks made an all-star game.

-Medbrat, 2023

[Medbrat]

You misread the question.

"Consider all players outside of your Top 25, who are the best peaks among them? List 7"

I understood the question perfectly. Only Kd.

Nah, you misunderstood. I even re-phrased the OP to make it more clear for you.


"Who are your Top 10 peaks of players who never made an all-star game?"

All my Top 10 peaks made an all-star game.

-Medbrat, 2023

Jesus chriwst dude, how can you be so dumb...

Personal attack, derailing. Warned. trex

[Colbinii]

I understood the question perfectly. Only Kd.

Nah, you misunderstood. I even re-phrased the OP to make it more clear for you.


"Who are your Top 10 peaks of players who never made an all-star game?"

All my Top 10 peaks made an all-star game.

-Medbrat, 2023

Jesus chriwst dude, how can you be so dumb...

How am I dumb? What are you not understanding?

[trex_8063]

How am I dumb? What are you not understanding?

Drop it, please. We shouldn't give this line any more oxygen, it's just derailing the thread. Thanks....

[Narigo]

Tracy McGrady
James Harden
Bob Pettit
Nikola Jokic
Giannis
Anthony Davis
Bill Walton

[Chronz]

Tmac stands alone

[Ben AN]

Jokic TMac Embiid Dwight Luka PG Russ

[Colbinii]

Jokic TMac Embiid Dwight Luka PG Russ

Which of these guys peaked higher than Kawhi?

[Ben AN]

Jokic TMac Embiid Dwight Luka PG Russ

Which of these guys peaked higher than Kawhi?

I got Kawhi in my top 25, my criteria is career value + role in postseason success. I'd rank his peak 2nd behind current Jokic.

[rk2023]

Leonard, T-Mac, Harden, Giannis, Jokic, Yao, Hill

Just curious for the rationale of taking Yao over the likes of big men such as: Davis, Walton, Ewing, Alonzo, etc?

[Cavsfansince84]

Jokic TMac Embiid Dwight Luka PG Russ

Which of these guys peaked higher than Kawhi?

I got Kawhi in my top 25, my criteria is career value + role in postseason success. I'd rank his peak 2nd behind current Jokic.

Would you be using the 2019 or 2017 version here? Because I think the 2017 version was better myself(as do others) but obviously the 2019 version had a much more complete playoff run.

[Ben AN]

Would you be using the 2019 or 2017 version here? Because I think the 2017 version was better myself(as do others) but obviously the 2019 version had a much more complete playoff run.

Probably 2019, I'd also take 2021>2017. He took a leap in playmaking that season and was playing the best ball of his career in the postseason before going down.

[Jaivl]

Jokic
Mikan
Walton
Giannis
Davis
Leonard
T-Mac or Harden

Usual suspect Wade is barely in my top 25.

[PistolPeteJR]

Jokic TMac Embiid Dwight Luka PG Russ

Which of these guys peaked higher than Kawhi?

By the end of the season, I'd comfortably say Jokic. I don't see a discussion for Russ, PG.