Would you trade Maxey for Lillard? (Poll)

ProcessDoctor · Post #1 » by **ProcessDoctor** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 2:54 am

I feel like this deserves its own thread and I'm curious how the majority of the fanbase leans.

Discuss.

Post #2 » by **sixers hoops** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 3:00 am

I have to think about it. For me, it’s not a no-brainer either way.

phifans · Post #3 » by **phifans** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 3:13 am

I just wonder what do u guys expect we can achieve with Lillard and Embiid if we pull this trigger ?

TheBallsDeeper · Post #4 » by **TheBallsDeeper** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 3:56 am

No - because I don't rate Lillard. Way past his best.

However I do want to trade Maxey - just not for Dame. I think he is seriously overrated and Sixers should cash in before he gets found out.

Sixteen · Post #5 » by **Sixteen** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 4:09 am

TheBallsDeeper wrote:No - because I don't rate Lillard. Way past his best.

However I do want to trade Maxey - just not for Dame. I think he is seriously overrated and Sixers should cash in before he gets found out.

what's to find out ? he's one of the fastest players in the league that shoots 43% percentage with more than enough volume. He has improved almost considerably every season he's been in the league. 4th year guards tend to make big jumps. is it that far fetched to expect an all-star season out of him?

TheBallsDeeper · Post #6 » by **TheBallsDeeper** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 4:11 am

Phila Tough wrote:
TheBallsDeeper wrote:No - because I don't rate Lillard. Way past his best.

However I do want to trade Maxey - just not for Dame. I think he is seriously overrated and Sixers should cash in before he gets found out.

what's to find out ? he's one of the fastest players in the league that shoots 43% percentage with more than enough volume. He has improved almost considerably every season he's been in the league. 4th year guards tend to make big jumps. is it that far fetched to expect an all-star season out of him?

Tiny shooting guard, very little playmaking and a liability on defense. Has had the luxury of being the 4th option on the team. He will get found out when Harden leaves. Trade now why people over estimate him.

Sixteen · Post #7 » by **Sixteen** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 4:12 am

now if this was a 28 year old Lillard, heck maybe even a 30 year old Lillard I would do that trade. But not for a 33 year old Lillard that doesn't even want to be here.

Sixteen · Post #8 » by **Sixteen** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 4:15 am

TheBallsDeeper wrote:
Phila Tough wrote:
TheBallsDeeper wrote:No - because I don't rate Lillard. Way past his best.

However I do want to trade Maxey - just not for Dame. I think he is seriously overrated and Sixers should cash in before he gets found out.

what's to find out ? he's one of the fastest players in the league that shoots 43% percentage with more than enough volume. He has improved almost considerably every season he's been in the league. 4th year guards tend to make big jumps. is it that far fetched to expect an all-star season out of him?

Tiny shooting guard, very little playmaking and a liability on defense. Has had the luxury of being the 4th option on the team. He will get found out when Harden leaves. Trade now why people over estimate him.

I keep seeing this argument. Maxey seemed fine without Harden when Ben Simmons was sitting out before the trade.

Embiid P · Post #9 » by **Embiid P** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 4:18 am

Straight up? Sure.

Maxey along with additional players and assets which is what it would take? Nope.

76ciology · Post #10 » by **76ciology** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 4:57 am

Yes, but no picks. And only if Morey can be sure that we can have some depth to build around Dame and Biid.

76ciology · Post #11 » by **76ciology** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 4:59 am

Reality of how Dame and Embiid would look like

Watch on YouTube

Maxey = CJ Mccullom

the_process · Post #12 » by **the_process** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 5:05 am

Just make the deal already. The Sixers are on course to detonation in two or three years. Once that happens, Maxey will be on his way out of town anyway.

Lillard can be talked into playing here I think. We know he’s thought about it. Embiid will just have to agree to let Dame be the alpha. That should be enough.

brannigan73 · Post #13 » by **brannigan73** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 5:25 am

Lets live in the world of reality and understand that how the Sixers would look with Lillard would be a team weaker then the team that lost to the Celtics in the second round. It would be Harden and Maxey out and Lillard and maybe some marginal roleplayer. Considering Harden was a top 20 player during the regular season and Maxey a 20PPG scorer on excellent percentages and Lillard's age why exactly would you do that? So no.

Jhawk03 · Post #14 » by **Jhawk03** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 5:40 am

Put me down for maybe, I mean the timing of it finally being possible couldn't be worse, but I do lean yes (selfish reasons) only because I want to be proven right or wrong about the pairing of him with Embiid being elite. (Yes a tier far above Embiid and Harden)

TheBallsDeeper · Post #15 » by **TheBallsDeeper** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 5:55 am

Phila Tough wrote:
TheBallsDeeper wrote:
Phila Tough wrote:
what's to find out ? he's one of the fastest players in the league that shoots 43% percentage with more than enough volume. He has improved almost considerably every season he's been in the league. 4th year guards tend to make big jumps. is it that far fetched to expect an all-star season out of him?

Tiny shooting guard, very little playmaking and a liability on defense. Has had the luxury of being the 4th option on the team. He will get found out when Harden leaves. Trade now why people over estimate him.

I keep seeing this argument. Maxey seemed fine without Harden when Ben Simmons was sitting out before the trade.

One off games when the other team hasn't really gameplanned for him. Wait until the pressure comes.

Was prime Lou Williams the man to build a team around? Because that's where I think Maxeys ceiling is, and that is the best comparison to him.
His best spot would be a regular 6th man of the league candidate, never going to lead a team anywhere. If Hinkey was still at the Sixers Maxey would be gone like MCW.

76thBearCub · Post #16 » by **76thBearCub** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 8:44 am

There's a good argument both ways

sixers4real · Post #17 » by **sixers4real** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 9:04 am

2023-24 Maxey << Lillard
2024-25 Maxey = Lillard
2025-26 Maxey > Lillard
2026-27 Maxey >>>> Lillard
2027-28 Maxey >>>>>>> Lillard

No, I would not trade Maxey for Lillard straight up.

sixers4real · Post #18 » by **sixers4real** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 9:18 am

TheBallsDeeper wrote:
Phila Tough wrote:
TheBallsDeeper wrote:Tiny shooting guard, very little playmaking and a liability on defense. Has had the luxury of being the 4th option on the team. He will get found out when Harden leaves. Trade now why people over estimate him.

I keep seeing this argument. Maxey seemed fine without Harden when Ben Simmons was sitting out before the trade.

One off games when the other team hasn't really gameplanned for him. Wait until the pressure comes.

Was prime Lou Williams the man to build a team around? Because that's where I think Maxeys ceiling is, and that is the best comparison to him.
His best spot would be a regular 6th man of the league candidate, never going to lead a team anywhere. If Hinkey was still at the Sixers Maxey would be gone like MCW.

To me, prime Lue Williams was never as good as Maxey is right now.
I’m trying be objective about Maxey.
The thing I love about him is his work ethic. He always surprise me with his improvements.

Sixteen · Post #19 » by **Sixteen** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 9:27 am

Lou Williams started off as a terrible long range shooter as a guard and while he was quick, he was not as quick as Maxey. Maxeys quickness & shooting range is a deadly combination.. Smart money says Maxey improves his iso/playmaking game.

Jay555 · Post #20 » by **Jay555** » Tue Jul 4, 2023 9:47 am

Dame’s contract looks meh down the road. He can be good for a couple of years but him and Embiid are not getting past Boston or Mil or Miami.

People are missing the point. The KEY is for Embiid to change his playing style. If he still operates from the elbow, Jordan can’t save him.