Ben wrote:Jailblazers7 wrote:What discipline would the NBA enact on Harden if he did this in the US? I don’t get that talking point, is the NBA gonna fine him because he was mean to his GM?
I misread the NBA memo that I posted earlier. I thought it was stating that players and agents couldn't say that they wouldn't fulfill their contracts, period, not that they wouldn't fulfill their contracts if traded (to certain teams). So I guess that what Harden said doesn't violate the terms of that memo. I can't for the life of me understand why it's more acceptable to say publicly that you won't perform for your own team rather than that you won't perform for a new team, but it seems as if the memo allows for that.
[youtube]
[/youtube]
Well, more specifically, the memo was based off the collective bargaining agreement which states that players and agents cannot publicly express a desire to go to another team. Players or their agents cannot indicate privately or publicly that they would not fully perform services called for under their contract. Finally, players can be fined for off-court behavior that is not in the best interest of the association or basketball.
I believe the Lillard memo was just a warning as for the most part organizations did not report Goodwin making the reported threat.
James, as far as I can tell, has not publicly asked for a trade. He only said he wouldn’t play for an organization that Morey is part of. And he is well within his rights to step away from the game and not play professional basketball or not report and deal with the fines. Ultimately, saying that he won’t work for the Sixers is his right, but that leaves him with few options moving forward.
And fining him under the conduct detrimental to the league clause is left solely to Adam Silver. When the offense involves guns, drugs, or domestic violence, Adam Silver provides his evidence findings to the player’s association, and those findings are subject to grievance procedures. I find Harden’s conduct very detrimental to the league. It’s an embarrassment. However, the NBA likely has a large team of lawyers and PR people who assess if it is worthy of a fine, if the fine will withstand a grievance, and if fining Harden will be popular or unpopular with fans.
However, teams also fine players for conduct detrimental to the team. Detrimental conduct is considered any activity that can be viewed as a distraction or nuisance for an organization. Ben Simmons was fined multiple times for conduct detrimental to the team for refusing to cooperate with team doctors, for instance, or disrupting practice. Looking at it from this lens, I would be a little surprised, but I wouldn’t be shocked if Harden were subject to discipline. This seems like something that would come from the league though.