parapooper wrote:Rust_Cohle wrote:Jordan had a double three peat, better peak, I do agree that lebron had better longevity but MJ was a better defender and scorer and better PER, #1 all time for playoffs which more GOAT like than lebron
double three peat
team achievement,
LeBron would have 4-peated by age 22 if the Cavs hadnt drafted him because he would have been on the 2004 to 2007 Pistons - so what
better peak
Jordan 91: RSPSaverage: PER 31.8, BPM 13.3
Lebron 09: RSPSaverage: PER 34.5, BPM 15.3
Before the the mentally challenged "riiiing" response:
LeBrons Gamescore in ECF: 29.3 against 101.9 DRtg - lost putting up 39-8-8 against the nr.1 defense
Jordans Gamescore in ECF: 26.3 against 104.6 DRtg - played worse against a worse defense but swept opponent with 12 point win margin
Defense:
playoff Jordan averaged 7.7 DRB+STl+BLK while LeBron averaged 10.2 over 1.5x as many minutes
playoff Jordan had a DBPM of 2.3 vs 2.5 for Lebron over 1.5x as many minutes
using DBPM before the formula was retroactively changed to make Jordan look better and Lebron worse:
playoff Jordan had a DBPM of 1.8 vs 3.5 for Lebron
Scoring:
playoff Jordan scored 33.4 pts/game while playoff LeBron 2009 to 2020 (1300 more minutes than Jordans playoff career) scored 29.2 pts/game on 4.2 less FGA and 1 less FTA - so Jordan additional scoring came at a TS% below 46% = counterproductive
Over his entire career Jordan scored 9000 points less than Lebron at lower efficiency.
Playoff PER:
Jordan 28.6 over 7474 minutes
Lebron 29.5 over 8762 minutes from 09 to 2020
-> more minutes than MJ at a higher PER + 5 additional playoffs at young or old age where LeBron's PER was around Kobe-level and Jordan's PER was non-existent
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1uWyzC3JZZFPMkyJGpsbOwZ0LsOdyO2OmlqkvnYk4Xm8/edit?pli=1#gid=0
From age 21 - 28, they're both pretty much equally dominant and almost first in everything.
For the period age 29-34, Jordan maintained a significantly higher ranking in each metric almost across the board.
In 97-98 season, Jordan had easily one of the biggest offensive carry jobs ever. Still the highest percentage of a championship team's total points scored by a single player in the playoffs. Greatest playoff PER ever too.
He also won MVP was First Team All Defense, and led the Bulls to a 62-20 record with an older beaten down team. Scottie only played 44 games and was not the same after that surgery.
Nobody on that roster was close to as good as AD was in 2020 and Jordan in that Playoff run contributed more to his teams total points than almost anyone has and went up against the #1 seed Jazz with Stockton and Malone in the Finals. He scored 45 points in the close out Game 6. The rest of his team scored 44 and Scottie played that entire series with a hurt back.
2 more rings in 3,561 less minutes is impressive.
And this absolutely nails why Jordan comes out ahead:
https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/michael-jordan-faced-better-competition-than-lebron-james/














