YogurtProducer wrote:Harry Palmer wrote:To me, and I realize I’m tilting at windmills here, but I have never liked the term ‘tanking’ which to me borders on involving the players. You never want players to not want to win. You should be doing what you can to maximize your lottery balls as an organization, but never the players, they should be judged on their fight just as much as anyone. Otherwise it can become a cancer. Coaches can prioritize development, but never overtly teaching players to give anything but their all excepting medical concerns. So I prefer ‘rebuilding’ or ‘building through the draft’ or w/e. But I know I lost this fight a long time ago.
I think most people agree with that.
I don't think I have seen any pro-tankers say they want the players to not try.
Personally, I can see the pro-tank arguments but whenever I watch a game I still cheer for the team to play well and for us to win. To me, if you cant win with the guys you got then you have a lot bigger problems. Anyone who thinks winning is a bad thing is out to lunch IMO.
For a long time I had that dichotomy, wanting us to lose except when the game was on. And in a way it’s a kind of no-lose place, you’re experientially happy if we win but strategically happy if we lose. But for me over time…and remember BC was still in charge when I was last regularly posting…it began to feel like an investment in perpetual mediocrity, and therefore harder to feel enthused about. I think one way of kind of side-stepping the overall process is concentrating on the player or players who will really matter. Like right now I basically just watch Scottie. Over time with BC even that became difficult, but like I had no problem with most of his later draft picks, they were often who I’d have picked in the same situation, but feeling constantly out of the potential franchise player pool eventually just wore me down and I was just not enjoying it enough anymore.
Massai getting hired rekindled some but my life was also changing a lot and I just didn’t have the same time or energy, and when he backed out of his avowed rebuild position I was kinda like ok, maybe later. The Kawai rumours were both encouraging and discouraging, the former because we were finally stopping all this ‘you don’t need superstars, Remember The Pistons’ stuff, but otoh he was the most rock solid free agent destination guy I have ever seen, like to the point where his agents probably wanted to put a lid on it, so it was imo obviously a one shot deal and then what? I’d be lying if I said I thought a championship was likely even in that one season, but I at least knew we’d be in the real conversation. And oddly despite missing the best years I am less certain Massai has to go than others who were here for it. I feel he has demonstrated skills that might come back into play. But I admit without his prior work, if he was just being evaluated on the years since the chip there have been a lot more head scratching decisions than good ones, so I get the frustration and am not at all convinced I know whether or not we should want him here. I just haven’t heard a proposed replacement that does anything for me either.