JMAC3 wrote:Colbinii wrote:JMAC3 wrote:
I have been in on Castle for a few weeks now, I still have him in Tier 2 but I have been saying I keep wanting to place him in my top 5. He reminds me of Marcus Smart.
I think De'Anthony Melton is more similar than Smart.
Smart was much more electric in college, pooping off the chart on both ends with his high energy. He was also better at getting to the free throw line and a better slasher/driver.
Castle seems more in control and shows a real willingness to play in control.
I am more so talking about his build, play strength on both ends and defensive upside. Castle has great balance and he plays with such a strong base that sometimes defense looks effortless for him. His shooting is the concern, but it was for Smart too who was a career 30% guy in college and even early in his NBA career.
Despite that Smart had such good intangibles that he still was a guy you couldn't keep off the floor and that is how Castle is IMO. He is playing in a backcourt with 2 5th year seniors, 2 other starters who are back from a title team last year. The fact he is playing in a smaller role is a bit more expected from my viewpoint that he didn't come in and immediately become the center of the offense like Smart was playing for just a very average OK St team.
I also like that he has SG size, SF wingspan type of build so not only does he bring versatility to guard multiple positions but should be easier to play him in lineups that have shooting to where he isn't as big of a liability early in his career. Big fan.
You're literally describing De'Anthony Melton. Castle hasn't shown to have a 99 Percentile Motor like Marcus Smart.
De'Anthony Melton is exactly like Castle.
De'Anthony Melton joined a loaded Big 5 Conference School as a Freshman.
De'Anthony Melton took on a lesser role in college to co-exist on a talented team (USC then went deep in the tournament).
De'Anthony Melton is a solid secondary playmaker who defends at a high level.
Castle Freshman Stats: 25.1 PP100, 30% 3P, 75% FT%, 2.2 STL%, 2.1 BLK%, 19.4 AST%, 3.0 APG, 40% FTR
Melton Freshman Stats: 17.6 PP100, 28% 3P, 71% FT%, 4.0 STL%, 3.9 BLK%, 22.5 AST%, 3.5 APG, 47% FTR
Castle has some higher-end offensive outcomes which Melton doesn't possess.
Smart on the other hand was a wrecking ball as a prospect--negative AST/TO ratio, incredible FTR of 58%, Higher Usage as a college player at 27% with an incredible 5% STL%.
Castle is more along the lines of the Melton pedigree where he is much more in control as a lead/secondary creator, understand an offense and utilizes his IQ/Feel of the game to compliment his athleticism. Marcus Smart was a "Lay it all on the court" and had one of the best Motors we have ever seen. Castle hasn't shown that Motor on a consistent basis.