Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
Moderators: MoneyTalks41890, HartfordWhalers, Texas Chuck, BullyKing, Andre Roberstan, loserX, Trader_Joe, Mamba4Goat, pacers33granger
Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,139
- And1: 4,263
- Joined: Apr 05, 2012
-
Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
I've seen tweets or mentions on podcasts of Paul George potentially going to the 76ers this summer as some sort of "worst kept secret in the NBA"
I started thinking of scenarios where if this is going to happen, how can the Clippers recoup some of the loss of George and a 3-team idea with Chicago came to mind.
To Philly: Paul George and LAC 2031 1st (lottery protected)
To Clippers: DeMar DeRozan (sign and trade) and Nikola Vucevic
To Chicago: PHI 2024 1st (trade would have to be made after the player is selected)
Philly gets their guy in Paul George
Clippers add two vets in DeRozan and Vucevic to keep things going with Kawhi and Harden. DeRozan is also an LA native.
Bulls do right by two veteran players giving them an opportunity to play on a potential contender. They add a first round pick and tons of cap space for whatever is next for them. Gives Chicago picks 11 and 15 in this year's draft.
Wasn't sure if this would technically be possible due to various sign and trade rules that seem to always be changing.
I started thinking of scenarios where if this is going to happen, how can the Clippers recoup some of the loss of George and a 3-team idea with Chicago came to mind.
To Philly: Paul George and LAC 2031 1st (lottery protected)
To Clippers: DeMar DeRozan (sign and trade) and Nikola Vucevic
To Chicago: PHI 2024 1st (trade would have to be made after the player is selected)
Philly gets their guy in Paul George
Clippers add two vets in DeRozan and Vucevic to keep things going with Kawhi and Harden. DeRozan is also an LA native.
Bulls do right by two veteran players giving them an opportunity to play on a potential contender. They add a first round pick and tons of cap space for whatever is next for them. Gives Chicago picks 11 and 15 in this year's draft.
Wasn't sure if this would technically be possible due to various sign and trade rules that seem to always be changing.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 34,243
- And1: 21,854
- Joined: Feb 13, 2013
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
No chance a 1st from this draft is included with not one but 2 S+T players.
The complications are far too numerous.
The complications are far too numerous.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,837
- And1: 5,904
- Joined: Feb 12, 2016
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
Have you done the math here? Clippers have to stay below the apron to receive a snt ddr, which is near impossible unless Harden comes back cheap. Vuc would need to be dropped here to start to make the money work. No reason to use a 2024 pick here and Philly is likely getting some small asset here to allow this to become a SNT when they don’t need it.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,609
- And1: 5,665
- Joined: Nov 30, 2008
- Contact:
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
Yeah, CBA prevents this from happen, and even if it didn't, why would the Clippers add a first? Taking back a huge TPE and the rights to the Philly pick would be much preferred
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 28,777
- And1: 9,691
- Joined: Jun 12, 2005
- Location: Philadelphia(ish)
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
ejftw wrote:Yeah, CBA prevents this from happen, and even if it didn't, why would the Clippers add a first? Taking back a huge TPE and the rights to the Philly pick would be much preferred
Why would Philly give up a pick in a s&t for a guy they could sign outright?
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- Senior Mod - 76ers and NBA TnT Forum
- Posts: 47,322
- And1: 20,917
- Joined: Apr 07, 2010
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
I have Philly losing value in this, with the '24 pick worth more than a lotto protected pick in '31.
So, Philly should just pick not to lose value to help a team that Philly also owns a pick of already, making that pick worse.
So, Philly should just pick not to lose value to help a team that Philly also owns a pick of already, making that pick worse.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,449
- And1: 7,181
- Joined: Mar 30, 2006
- Location: Whereever you go - there you are
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
Yeah, there's no incentive for Philly to do this.
If PG wants to sign with Philly then he'll just sign with Philly. Maybe they get a future 2nd and send a fake 2nd back to make it a S&T (for the Clippers benefit). Though as Philly already has a Clippers pick they may not want to help them at all.
If PG wants to sign with Philly then he'll just sign with Philly. Maybe they get a future 2nd and send a fake 2nd back to make it a S&T (for the Clippers benefit). Though as Philly already has a Clippers pick they may not want to help them at all.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,139
- And1: 4,263
- Joined: Apr 05, 2012
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
for all the - "if PG wants to sign with Philly he can just sign with Philly" comments - technically true, but for whatever reason it seems like these routinely get handled via sign and trades.
I think making it a three team deal is probably too complicated. But if PG goes to Philly via a S&T maybe they have a Trade Exception that can be used in a DeRozan deal?
I'm personally a big DeRozan fan and would welcome him back to Chicago with open arms. I also just know he's older and his priorities might be to play somewhere with a better shot at contending + an opportunity to play in his hometown could also be appealing.
I think making it a three team deal is probably too complicated. But if PG goes to Philly via a S&T maybe they have a Trade Exception that can be used in a DeRozan deal?
I'm personally a big DeRozan fan and would welcome him back to Chicago with open arms. I also just know he's older and his priorities might be to play somewhere with a better shot at contending + an opportunity to play in his hometown could also be appealing.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
- Texas Chuck
- Senior Mod - NBA TnT Forum
- Posts: 92,468
- And1: 98,445
- Joined: May 19, 2012
- Location: Purgatory
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
I don't have Vuc moved into space worth a 1st and so Chicago is just stealing value.
Of course the real issue is the Clippers basically can't legally do this barring a loss of Harden which makes doing this a bad idea. And the whole tampering issue of including a 24 pick.
But Chicago is sucking out value. DD sign and trade doesn't allow you to dump Vuc and gain a first.
Of course the real issue is the Clippers basically can't legally do this barring a loss of Harden which makes doing this a bad idea. And the whole tampering issue of including a 24 pick.
But Chicago is sucking out value. DD sign and trade doesn't allow you to dump Vuc and gain a first.
ThunderBolt wrote:I’m going to let some of you in on a little secret I learned on realgm. If you don’t like a thread, not only do you not have to comment but you don’t even have to open it and read it. You’re welcome.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 28,777
- And1: 9,691
- Joined: Jun 12, 2005
- Location: Philadelphia(ish)
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
drosestruts wrote:for all the - "if PG wants to sign with Philly he can just sign with Philly" comments - technically true, but for whatever reason it seems like these routinely get handled via sign and trades.
I think making it a three team deal is probably too complicated. But if PG goes to Philly via a S&T maybe they have a Trade Exception that can be used in a DeRozan deal?
I'm personally a big DeRozan fan and would welcome him back to Chicago with open arms. I also just know he's older and his priorities might be to play somewhere with a better shot at contending + an opportunity to play in his hometown could also be appealing.
Sure, but you've got compensation going the wrong way (unless you believe that lotto protected Clippers pick is worth more than this year's Sixers pick).
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,139
- And1: 4,263
- Joined: Apr 05, 2012
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
yeah - as probably a bigger DeRozan fan than most I was hoping to get something of value even if we sign and traded him as a good will gesture for him - but:
1. Getting off Vuc would be value enough
2. It's not even legal for the Clippers to take in both DeRozan and Vuc
1. Getting off Vuc would be value enough
2. It's not even legal for the Clippers to take in both DeRozan and Vuc
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,609
- And1: 5,665
- Joined: Nov 30, 2008
- Contact:
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
youngcrev wrote:ejftw wrote:Yeah, CBA prevents this from happen, and even if it didn't, why would the Clippers add a first? Taking back a huge TPE and the rights to the Philly pick would be much preferred
Why would Philly give up a pick in a s&t for a guy they could sign outright?
Didn't mention whether Philly should or would, just as the OP has it, Clippers wouldn't involve Chicago.
As far as signing him outright, if Philly wants to gut down to
essentially Maxey/PG/Embiid with minimum guys, well, that should be interesting.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 7,993
- And1: 2,372
- Joined: Jul 02, 2014
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
even if the original trade isn't legal
Without the pick in the 15 range, the Bulls are just supposed to give up 2 starters for nothing in return? that's internet GM mastermind at work. At least make it look like the Bulls have a plan, even a weak kneed one
But what are the Clippers thinking? Two Chicago Bulls players who haven't gotten through a round of the playoffs in 3 1/2 seasons are supposed to be the key to the Clips getting to the Finals where future HoF Paul George couldn't?
Without the pick in the 15 range, the Bulls are just supposed to give up 2 starters for nothing in return? that's internet GM mastermind at work. At least make it look like the Bulls have a plan, even a weak kneed one
But what are the Clippers thinking? Two Chicago Bulls players who haven't gotten through a round of the playoffs in 3 1/2 seasons are supposed to be the key to the Clips getting to the Finals where future HoF Paul George couldn't?
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- King of the Trade Board
- Posts: 20,922
- And1: 7,865
- Joined: Aug 05, 2012
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
Think I agree with most that Philly just signs PG here.
I don’t think Philly minds helping LAC sign DDR or create a TPE, etc. Not that they would add value to do it, just wouldn’t refuse to do so.. Don’t think Philly cares how LAC retool around Leonard. They would probably be better off with LAC being stuck over the cap with Demar versus trying to be active in 2025 or 2026 free agency.
I don’t think Philly minds helping LAC sign DDR or create a TPE, etc. Not that they would add value to do it, just wouldn’t refuse to do so.. Don’t think Philly cares how LAC retool around Leonard. They would probably be better off with LAC being stuck over the cap with Demar versus trying to be active in 2025 or 2026 free agency.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,837
- And1: 5,904
- Joined: Feb 12, 2016
-
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
jayjaysee wrote:Think I agree with most that Philly just signs PG here.
I don’t think Philly minds helping LAC sign DDR or create a TPE, etc. Not that they would add value to do it, just wouldn’t refuse to do so.. Don’t think Philly cares how LAC retool around Leonard. They would probably be better off with LAC being stuck over the cap with Demar versus trying to be active in 2025 or 2026 free agency.
I think ideally Philly would be trying to rope in a SNT Harris and other salary(Reed) to make this some kind of 3/4 way deal allowing them to stay above the cap to bring back their desired FAs and have access to the MLE. That is a scenario where I could see Philly willing to pay assets to make this a SNT. Morey will get George to agree to sign there outright 1st and shop around to convince all teams evolved to make into a SNT. I would be mildly surprised if George lands in Philly as not part of a SNT, just not the OP version which does nothing for Philly.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 29,176
- And1: 10,344
- Joined: May 01, 2010
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
psman2 wrote:jayjaysee wrote:Think I agree with most that Philly just signs PG here.
I don’t think Philly minds helping LAC sign DDR or create a TPE, etc. Not that they would add value to do it, just wouldn’t refuse to do so.. Don’t think Philly cares how LAC retool around Leonard. They would probably be better off with LAC being stuck over the cap with Demar versus trying to be active in 2025 or 2026 free agency.
I think ideally Philly would be trying to rope in a SNT Harris and other salary(Reed) to make this some kind of 3/4 way deal allowing them to stay above the cap to bring back their desired FAs and have access to the MLE. That is a scenario where I could see Philly willing to pay assets to make this a SNT. Morey will get George to agree to sign there outright 1st and shop around to convince all teams evolved to make into a SNT. I would be mildly surprised if George lands in Philly as not part of a SNT, just not the OP version which does nothing for Philly.
Yep. I could see Tobias S&T and Reed to DET, PG S&T to PHI, and a protected future 2nd from DET to LAC.
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
-
- King of the Trade Board
- Posts: 20,922
- And1: 7,865
- Joined: Aug 05, 2012
Re: Half-Baked Idea: CHI - PHI - LAC
the_process wrote:psman2 wrote:jayjaysee wrote:Think I agree with most that Philly just signs PG here.
I don’t think Philly minds helping LAC sign DDR or create a TPE, etc. Not that they would add value to do it, just wouldn’t refuse to do so.. Don’t think Philly cares how LAC retool around Leonard. They would probably be better off with LAC being stuck over the cap with Demar versus trying to be active in 2025 or 2026 free agency.
I think ideally Philly would be trying to rope in a SNT Harris and other salary(Reed) to make this some kind of 3/4 way deal allowing them to stay above the cap to bring back their desired FAs and have access to the MLE. That is a scenario where I could see Philly willing to pay assets to make this a SNT. Morey will get George to agree to sign there outright 1st and shop around to convince all teams evolved to make into a SNT. I would be mildly surprised if George lands in Philly as not part of a SNT, just not the OP version which does nothing for Philly.
Yep. I could see Tobias S&T and Reed to DET, PG S&T to PHI, and a protected future 2nd from DET to LAC.
Yeah, I like that more for sure. With Joel/PG/Maxey, Philly would still be able to keep Melton and maybe even use tax MLE before filling bench with near vet mins and staying under the apron?
But I just think Philly would let LAC create a TPE very cheaply (or build a deal similar to the OP) if the Sixers were signing George.. they don’t own LAC’s 2025 first. They own the 2028 first. thats a long time in NBA years. They want LAC to push in with Leonard/Harden and not worry about 2028 until Leonard expires after the 2027 season..
Return to Trades and Transactions