Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
Moderators: Jeff Van Gully, HerSports85, Capn'O, dakomish23, j4remi, Deeeez Knicks, NoLayupRule, mpharris36, GONYK
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- Buttah304
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,438
- And1: 6,016
- Joined: Feb 09, 2011
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
I don’t like the idea of Brunson Randle and DD all trying to work the mid range. Floor would get clogged.
Maybe in some alternate universe where he was willing to come off the bench while staggering at times could in theory work.
But let’s be real - he averaged 38min per game this past year and played 42min per game in their play ins.
I still love the upgrade of DDV to Spider. D Mitch was just as good if not better on defense, still can rack up some deflections and steals like Donte. His ability to create off the dribble though is from another universe in comparison. If you do it correctly - Brunson and DM could share the floor for 22-24min and separate them in other units to keep applying offensive pressure.
Maybe in some alternate universe where he was willing to come off the bench while staggering at times could in theory work.
But let’s be real - he averaged 38min per game this past year and played 42min per game in their play ins.
I still love the upgrade of DDV to Spider. D Mitch was just as good if not better on defense, still can rack up some deflections and steals like Donte. His ability to create off the dribble though is from another universe in comparison. If you do it correctly - Brunson and DM could share the floor for 22-24min and separate them in other units to keep applying offensive pressure.
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- moocow007
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 98,091
- And1: 25,553
- Joined: Jan 07, 2002
- Location: In front of the computer, where else?
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
WaltFrazier wrote:moocow007 wrote:
Should have got him this past winter.
Yeah at least Bogs is looking better lately but Derozan alone instead of Bogs and Burks, DD would have been killing it all this time. A better replacement for Randle's scoring
Yep exactly. And then they would have his Bird Rights so wouldn't have had to figure out some way to finagle a sign and trade.
Subscribe to NBNF!: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCWW9GUVpNULS97PyptXXU4w
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- moocow007
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 98,091
- And1: 25,553
- Joined: Jan 07, 2002
- Location: In front of the computer, where else?
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
nykballa2k4 wrote:moocow007 wrote:
Should have got him this past winter.
Eh, we are just fine I think
That's what we thought heading into the playoffs in 2020-2021, heading into the playoffs in 2022-2023 and...anyone remember John Starks as the Robin going 2 for 11 against the Rockets or Ewing never having a real Robin? Or Carmelo and Brokeback Stat or JR McNugget as his 2nd option? This team is better than the Randle and Carmelo teams but that doesn't mean they are fine. Randle being injured last year and then going down completely this year are significant. Derozan would have made up for Randle.
Subscribe to NBNF!: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCWW9GUVpNULS97PyptXXU4w
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 29,408
- And1: 6,432
- Joined: Jul 26, 2004
- Location: Kurt Rhombus is managing the defense...
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
moocow007 wrote:nykballa2k4 wrote:moocow007 wrote:
Should have got him this past winter.
Eh, we are just fine I think
That's what we thought heading into the playoffs in 2020-2021, heading into the playoffs in 2022-2023 and...anyone remember John Starks as the Robin going 2 for 11 against the Rockets or Ewing never having a real Robin? Or Carmelo and Brokeback Stat or JR McNugget as his 2nd option? This team is better than the Randle and Carmelo teams but that doesn't mean they are fine. Randle being injured last year and then going down completely this year are significant. Derozan would have made up for Randle.
Couple of things.
Right now is DeRozan a better fit for this team THIS POSTSEASON compared to Bojan? Most likely yes, but we do have a crippling need for shooters, particularly at the 4. So if we were under the belief that Randle was out for the year at the deadline and we were skiddish on OG being back, then getting a spread 4 might have been the bigger priority.
The price... I am pissed we lost Grimes, but he seems to have been damaged goods this year anyhow so in the narrow scope that is THIS POST SEASON, it seems his loss is not significant. either way he wasn't wearing a jersey. DDR would have cost more. Grimes + picks (probably at least 2, and probably better ones).
Long term consequence. In addition to being down draft assets to rent-a-rozan, we also would be down a big tradable contract. The belief is we are going big game hunting this summer again with one last shot with the war chest. Bojan is a 24ish mil EC that can be clumped with another piece for our target.
Lastly - what if Randle wasn't done. Brunson, DDR, Randle all operate in the same space. Add to that our center rotation and there would be a significant spacing issue.
DDR would be a nice piece to have right now for free. That's not what it would have cost us. Best-case would have been that we dealt something like Burks, Hartenstein(or Mitch) and 3 picks for Drummond (who Embiid eats like Zion does beignets) and DDR. I don't think that makes us a better team now OR later.
Numbers don't lie, people who use them do
Stand up to all hate
Stand up to Jewish hate
Stand up to all hate
Stand up to Jewish hate
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- Wildcat
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,305
- And1: 2,351
- Joined: Aug 07, 2002
- Location: Astoria, NY
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
DDR only makes sense if he's accepting a bench role and greatly reduced minutes. I don't think he's at a place in his career where that's an option. If you're bringing in the same core with a healthy Randle, where does DeMar fit in? Mitch, Josh, Deuce, and him? That seems a bit off to me.
Same issue with the Lowry. He -- like DeMar -- is going to want sufficient minutes.
Same issue with the Lowry. He -- like DeMar -- is going to want sufficient minutes.
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,660
- And1: 2,142
- Joined: Jul 27, 2013
- Location: In the Spirit
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
nykballa2k4 wrote:moocow007 wrote:nykballa2k4 wrote:Eh, we are just fine I think
That's what we thought heading into the playoffs in 2020-2021, heading into the playoffs in 2022-2023 and...anyone remember John Starks as the Robin going 2 for 11 against the Rockets or Ewing never having a real Robin? Or Carmelo and Brokeback Stat or JR McNugget as his 2nd option? This team is better than the Randle and Carmelo teams but that doesn't mean they are fine. Randle being injured last year and then going down completely this year are significant. Derozan would have made up for Randle.
Couple of things.
Right now is DeRozan a better fit for this team THIS POSTSEASON compared to Bojan? Most likely yes, but we do have a crippling need for shooters, particularly at the 4. So if we were under the belief that Randle was out for the year at the deadline and we were skiddish on OG being back, then getting a spread 4 might have been the bigger priority.
The price... I am pissed we lost Grimes, but he seems to have been damaged goods this year anyhow so in the narrow scope that is THIS POST SEASON, it seems his loss is not significant. either way he wasn't wearing a jersey. DDR would have cost more. Grimes + picks (probably at least 2, and probably better ones).
Long term consequence. In addition to being down draft assets to rent-a-rozan, we also would be down a big tradable contract. The belief is we are going big game hunting this summer again with one last shot with the war chest. Bojan is a 24ish mil EC that can be clumped with another piece for our target.
Lastly - what if Randle wasn't done. Brunson, DDR, Randle all operate in the same space. Add to that our center rotation and there would be a significant spacing issue.
DDR would be a nice piece to have right now for free. That's not what it would have cost us. Best-case would have been that we dealt something like Burks, Hartenstein(or Mitch) and 3 picks for Drummond (who Embiid eats like Zion does beignets) and DDR. I don't think that makes us a better team now OR later.
Spidah, Booker (if available) or a stretch 5 like KAT are better fits.
For God, who said, “Let light shine out of darkness,” has shone in our hearts to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ. 2nd Corinthians 4:6
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- Wildcat
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,305
- And1: 2,351
- Joined: Aug 07, 2002
- Location: Astoria, NY
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
KnixinSix wrote:nykballa2k4 wrote:moocow007 wrote:
That's what we thought heading into the playoffs in 2020-2021, heading into the playoffs in 2022-2023 and...anyone remember John Starks as the Robin going 2 for 11 against the Rockets or Ewing never having a real Robin? Or Carmelo and Brokeback Stat or JR McNugget as his 2nd option? This team is better than the Randle and Carmelo teams but that doesn't mean they are fine. Randle being injured last year and then going down completely this year are significant. Derozan would have made up for Randle.
Couple of things.
Right now is DeRozan a better fit for this team THIS POSTSEASON compared to Bojan? Most likely yes, but we do have a crippling need for shooters, particularly at the 4. So if we were under the belief that Randle was out for the year at the deadline and we were skiddish on OG being back, then getting a spread 4 might have been the bigger priority.
The price... I am pissed we lost Grimes, but he seems to have been damaged goods this year anyhow so in the narrow scope that is THIS POST SEASON, it seems his loss is not significant. either way he wasn't wearing a jersey. DDR would have cost more. Grimes + picks (probably at least 2, and probably better ones).
Long term consequence. In addition to being down draft assets to rent-a-rozan, we also would be down a big tradable contract. The belief is we are going big game hunting this summer again with one last shot with the war chest. Bojan is a 24ish mil EC that can be clumped with another piece for our target.
Lastly - what if Randle wasn't done. Brunson, DDR, Randle all operate in the same space. Add to that our center rotation and there would be a significant spacing issue.
DDR would be a nice piece to have right now for free. That's not what it would have cost us. Best-case would have been that we dealt something like Burks, Hartenstein(or Mitch) and 3 picks for Drummond (who Embiid eats like Zion does beignets) and DDR. I don't think that makes us a better team now OR later.
Spidah, Booker (if available) or a stretch 5 like KAT are better fits.
Heh, on cue.
Hot take: I think Booker will melt under pressure in NY.
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- robillionaire
- RealGM
- Posts: 36,237
- And1: 50,842
- Joined: Jul 12, 2015
- Location: Asheville
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
Wildcat wrote:KnixinSix wrote:nykballa2k4 wrote:
Couple of things.
Right now is DeRozan a better fit for this team THIS POSTSEASON compared to Bojan? Most likely yes, but we do have a crippling need for shooters, particularly at the 4. So if we were under the belief that Randle was out for the year at the deadline and we were skiddish on OG being back, then getting a spread 4 might have been the bigger priority.
The price... I am pissed we lost Grimes, but he seems to have been damaged goods this year anyhow so in the narrow scope that is THIS POST SEASON, it seems his loss is not significant. either way he wasn't wearing a jersey. DDR would have cost more. Grimes + picks (probably at least 2, and probably better ones).
Long term consequence. In addition to being down draft assets to rent-a-rozan, we also would be down a big tradable contract. The belief is we are going big game hunting this summer again with one last shot with the war chest. Bojan is a 24ish mil EC that can be clumped with another piece for our target.
Lastly - what if Randle wasn't done. Brunson, DDR, Randle all operate in the same space. Add to that our center rotation and there would be a significant spacing issue.
DDR would be a nice piece to have right now for free. That's not what it would have cost us. Best-case would have been that we dealt something like Burks, Hartenstein(or Mitch) and 3 picks for Drummond (who Embiid eats like Zion does beignets) and DDR. I don't think that makes us a better team now OR later.
Spidah, Booker (if available) or a stretch 5 like KAT are better fits.
Heh, on cue.
Hot take: I think Booker will melt under pressure in NY.
He hit a game winning 3 against us at the garden earlier this year I think he can handle it
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- Wildcat
- RealGM
- Posts: 12,305
- And1: 2,351
- Joined: Aug 07, 2002
- Location: Astoria, NY
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
robillionaire wrote:Wildcat wrote:KnixinSix wrote:
Spidah, Booker (if available) or a stretch 5 like KAT are better fits.
Heh, on cue.
Hot take: I think Booker will melt under pressure in NY.
He hit a game winning 3 against us at the garden earlier this year I think he can handle it
I have no data to back up what I said. Just a gut feeling.
Actually, let me walk that back. I just saw his stat line in elimination games. Very choky.
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- sol537
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,851
- And1: 6,169
- Joined: Nov 07, 2001
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
Spida gives us more offense, but less defense than Mikal.
How about a blockbuster trade sending Randle, Mitch, and pick(s) to New Orleans for Zion and Tre Murphy? I doubt they'd entertain that, but I love Tre Murphy's game that much... and Zion seems to need a change of scenery... badly.
How about a blockbuster trade sending Randle, Mitch, and pick(s) to New Orleans for Zion and Tre Murphy? I doubt they'd entertain that, but I love Tre Murphy's game that much... and Zion seems to need a change of scenery... badly.
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,991
- And1: 1,131
- Joined: Dec 29, 2009
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
Bridges or Bust. Bridges and OG playing D together would be a nightmare for opposing teams.
Plus
Hes a Nova guy
Tight with our players
Would fit in with our culture
and unselfish.
I think a Bridges overpay is the move
Plus
Hes a Nova guy
Tight with our players
Would fit in with our culture
and unselfish.
I think a Bridges overpay is the move
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,991
- And1: 1,131
- Joined: Dec 29, 2009
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
I am also worried about certain stars and our culture. We might have the best culture in the NBA. I have been a big anti-Thibs guy but he is proving me wrong. The team has found players who want to play in his system and his way. I would be scared a Mitchell, Giannias, Luka etc would complain about systems schemes practices etc. Bridges would fit right in.
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,660
- And1: 2,142
- Joined: Jul 27, 2013
- Location: In the Spirit
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
Buttah304 wrote:I don’t like the idea of Brunson Randle and DD all trying to work the mid range. Floor would get clogged.
Maybe in some alternate universe where he was willing to come off the bench while staggering at times could in theory work.
But let’s be real - he averaged 38min per game this past year and played 42min per game in their play ins.
I still love the upgrade of DDV to Spider. D Mitch was just as good if not better on defense, still can rack up some deflections and steals like Donte. His ability to create off the dribble though is from another universe in comparison. If you do it correctly - Brunson and DM could share the floor for 22-24min and separate them in other units to keep applying offensive pressure.
I think we can upgrade from Randle but lets be honest here. Brunson is getting blitzed and doubled at a much higher rate without Randle on the floor. Much higher rate.
The 10 or so games with OG Randle and Brunson on the floor were less clawing and scratching to win and flat out more dominant.
Does this mean Randle shouldn't be upgraded? No. If he was a better playoff performer sure. But I think it is pretty clear an elite scorer to take pressure off Brunson is sorely needed.
OG is not an elite scorer and lets not pretend he is going to turn into one either.
For God, who said, “Let light shine out of darkness,” has shone in our hearts to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ. 2nd Corinthians 4:6
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,660
- And1: 2,142
- Joined: Jul 27, 2013
- Location: In the Spirit
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
bleedblue3303 wrote:I am also worried about certain stars and our culture. We might have the best culture in the NBA. I have been a big anti-Thibs guy but he is proving me wrong. The team has found players who want to play in his system and his way. I would be scared a Mitchell, Giannias, Luka etc would complain about systems schemes practices etc. Bridges would fit right in.
Bridges isn't the ideal or elite guy offensively but with his intangibles and two way game he might be a pretty close to ideal fit in Thibs system.
Wouldn't complain if we pulled Bridges off but the two most available guys this offseason seem like they will be (for now):
KAT due to that monstrous contract Minny can't afford under the new CBA and Donovan Mitchell who made it pretty clear he isn't resigning with Cleveland
For God, who said, “Let light shine out of darkness,” has shone in our hearts to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ. 2nd Corinthians 4:6
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 10,728
- And1: 4,244
- Joined: Mar 01, 2005
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
Buttah304 wrote:I don’t like the idea of Brunson Randle and DD all trying to work the mid range. Floor would get clogged.
Maybe in some alternate universe where he was willing to come off the bench while staggering at times could in theory work.
But let’s be real - he averaged 38min per game this past year and played 42min per game in their play ins.
I still love the upgrade of DDV to Spider. D Mitch was just as good if not better on defense, still can rack up some deflections and steals like Donte. His ability to create off the dribble though is from another universe in comparison. If you do it correctly - Brunson and DM could share the floor for 22-24min and separate them in other units to keep applying offensive pressure.
Brunson, DDV, DeRozan, OG, KAT (+ Hartenstein to be able to move everyone else down a position) >>>>
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 10,728
- And1: 4,244
- Joined: Mar 01, 2005
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
KnixinSix wrote:bleedblue3303 wrote:I am also worried about certain stars and our culture. We might have the best culture in the NBA. I have been a big anti-Thibs guy but he is proving me wrong. The team has found players who want to play in his system and his way. I would be scared a Mitchell, Giannias, Luka etc would complain about systems schemes practices etc. Bridges would fit right in.
Bridges isn't the ideal or elite guy offensively but with his intangibles and two way game he might be a pretty close to ideal fit in Thibs system.
Wouldn't complain if we pulled Bridges off but the two most available guys this offseason seem like they will be (for now):
KAT due to that monstrous contract Minny can't afford under the new CBA and Donovan Mitchell who made it pretty clear he isn't resigning with Cleveland
Best bets for us:
1. Bridges
2. DeRozan
3. KAT
4. Mitchell
in that order imo. Doncic tops that list of everything goes south for Dallas though.
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- KnicksGadfly
- RealGM
- Posts: 15,848
- And1: 15,888
- Joined: Jul 29, 2007
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
Bulls aren’t letting DeRozan go that easily. They’ve given him a $80/2 offer already and DeRozan is negotiating for more.
Those guys haven’t even made an in-season trade in forever…hell, they’re now stuck with Lavine cause they refused to move him at this peak value
Those guys haven’t even made an in-season trade in forever…hell, they’re now stuck with Lavine cause they refused to move him at this peak value
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- thebuzzardman
- RealGM
- Posts: 75,616
- And1: 85,004
- Joined: Jun 24, 2006
- Location: Villanovknicks
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
Booker please, after Suns get swept in the first round
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- BigShot Bojan
- RealGM
- Posts: 10,288
- And1: 8,874
- Joined: Nov 28, 2011
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
I hope this dispels anyone’s yearning for us to trade for Embiid….i take Zion everytime heck id take Ingram over him
Formerly Knicks85
Capn'O wrote:I wonder what Paul Reed's feelings are about metal bats.
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
- BigShot Bojan
- RealGM
- Posts: 10,288
- And1: 8,874
- Joined: Nov 28, 2011
Re: Trades and Transactions Ideas Thread
agreed…if I could get Brandon Ingram for same price I wouldWildcat wrote:KnixinSix wrote:nykballa2k4 wrote:
Couple of things.
Right now is DeRozan a better fit for this team THIS POSTSEASON compared to Bojan? Most likely yes, but we do have a crippling need for shooters, particularly at the 4. So if we were under the belief that Randle was out for the year at the deadline and we were skiddish on OG being back, then getting a spread 4 might have been the bigger priority.
The price... I am pissed we lost Grimes, but he seems to have been damaged goods this year anyhow so in the narrow scope that is THIS POST SEASON, it seems his loss is not significant. either way he wasn't wearing a jersey. DDR would have cost more. Grimes + picks (probably at least 2, and probably better ones).
Long term consequence. In addition to being down draft assets to rent-a-rozan, we also would be down a big tradable contract. The belief is we are going big game hunting this summer again with one last shot with the war chest. Bojan is a 24ish mil EC that can be clumped with another piece for our target.
Lastly - what if Randle wasn't done. Brunson, DDR, Randle all operate in the same space. Add to that our center rotation and there would be a significant spacing issue.
DDR would be a nice piece to have right now for free. That's not what it would have cost us. Best-case would have been that we dealt something like Burks, Hartenstein(or Mitch) and 3 picks for Drummond (who Embiid eats like Zion does beignets) and DDR. I don't think that makes us a better team now OR later.
Spidah, Booker (if available) or a stretch 5 like KAT are better fits.
Heh, on cue.
Hot take: I think Booker will melt under pressure in NY.
Formerly Knicks85
Capn'O wrote:I wonder what Paul Reed's feelings are about metal bats.