Who says no? Detroit/Atlanta

[JennetteMcCurdy]

Let’s assume the Pistons pick third in the draft….. could be anywhere 1-5…..

The trade is:

Trae Young

For

Isaiah Stewart
Jaden Ivey
Pistons 2024 first round pick

Who says no?

[jayjaysee]

Atlanta has to say no here IMO. Even if you have Ivey and Stewart worth a first each, more is needed IMO.

And Detroit shouldn’t be making a win now trade. They don’t have a young core (or a core in general) to build around. It’s fine to sign Demar and try and end the bleeding. But it doesn’t really make sense to pay in a trade to do it IMO.

[oldncreaky]

On value, maybe it's fair, or even favouring Detroit -- I'm not here to praise Ivey

But I don't get it direction-wise for either team. Is Atlanta trying to get younger, or just trying to recoup something (anything?) for Trae? This surely isn't a win-now move for an expensive team that's below .500

This OP would leave Detroit with 2 major talents (Trae and Cade) who both need the ball and neither plays D at an NBA level, some youngsters who are 2-4 years from finding their level, and not much else. 30 win team, with no clear path to making even the play-in. Maybe it makes sense if we are able to nab OG as a FA, and trade Cade for value, but that's a stretch

[jayu70]

Atlanta

[SkyHook]

Let’s assume the Pistons pick third in the draft….. could be anywhere 1-5…..

The trade is:

Trae Young

For

Isaiah Stewart
Jaden Ivey
Pistons 2024 first round pick

Who says no?

I really like it for the Hawks, not so much for the Pistons. What exactly are they hoping to accomplish by picking up Young?

[zeebneeb]

I want exactly zero part of a tiny, horrific defensively, chucker.

Hard pass.

[Ball4life32]

Atlanta says no. Two negative players and one high pick in a meh draft isn’t close.

[Billl]

Both say no. Atlanta likely isn't going this direction and we've already see how Trae looks next to another guard who needs to ball to be effective.

[Snakebites]

I won’t speak for Atlanta.

But for Detroit Trae/Cade is a very poor fit on both sides of the ball.

[vege]

Atlanta would likely ask for Pick + Ivey + Ausar + Duren for Trae + Capela.

Detroit shouldn't touch Trae. He plays 0 defense and need the ball on his hand, we alread have one of those in Cade like oldncreaky said.

[Moses ShamMoses]

Hmm both teams think its a bad trade for their team, that must mean its a good trade and could happen. Don't two wrongs make a right?

[JennetteMcCurdy]

Atlanta says no. Two negative players and one high pick in a meh draft isn’t close.

To me this is the best reply - I’m trying to figure out what the Piston players are valued at these days. Apparently our starting power forward, starting shooting guard and a top five pick isn’t worth an All Star. Good times in Detroit.

[louc1970]

What does Ivey give that Bufkin and Griffin don't?