KOA wrote:ScienceOfLosing wrote:
I agreed with what @mcpharris36 asked you (and you never answered) about your statement the page before on Nabors.
Nabors is one of the best and most explosive receivers to come out in 10 years.
And now you post stg w him questioning who our QB might be (which I agree with LOL).
But you come across as not the sharpest tool in the shed here. Nabors would be the #1 receiver in most drafts.
Rough day?
Do you think Nabers is a as good as Ja’Marr Chase or Jaylen Waddle who were taken #5 and #6 overall?
Is he a pro bowl type talent?
Is he a legit #1 receiver?
Is he a red zone target where PFF ranked him as the 20th best receiver in the red zone with only a 47% catch rate?
https://www.pff.com/news/draft-2024-nfl-draft-highest-graded-red-zone-receivers-past-two-seasonsFor me, the answer is no to all of these questions. He is not worthy of being picked #6 overall in a draft.
The Giants have no size at receiver whatsoever. They were second to last in the red zone last year and Nabers does nothing for that.
He’s the product of a good QB with a good OL who rarely got pressured and had plenty of time in the pocket to get some deep balls.
If it weren’t for Chase and Jefferson coming out with huge success, he would not be drafted this high.
Taking age into consideration I think Nabers (20) can be bit better than those two. I think Ja’Marr Chase or Jaylen Waddle were 21 and 22 years old when drafted. Regardless of age, YES, Nabors is at that level but none of us know if he will achieve what those guys have. Athletically Chase ran a 4.38 40 and Nabers 4.35 but Nabers might be more explosive
Pro Bowl Talent – Well, I’d say he can be a top 10, maybe 5 receiver. He still has so much upside from here as he is really young so a part of talking about him is unknown/forecasting. He can be like a more muscular Hill, yeah, said it. Let this kid fill out and with his acceleration and athleticism (and hands), scary. He has a great chance to be special.
Legit #1 – Come on, of course he is, as was the receiver taken before him and probably the one taken just after. This class is deep as we all know. Many have MHJ ranked just behind Nabers. At least both are in the discussion as being #1 this year in a DEEP draft..
You seem to be sbout the only one here that is down on him. And when I search online, the reviews and opinions of him are like 99% positive. The guy can be like OBJ and then some. Not being sarcastic, but what do you possess that is better than all the experts out there saying he can be GREAT?
My only worry about Nabors is that he doesn’t become too Diva’ish, which is often a problem with star receivers.
Fair evaluation of upside and downside, not saying pro bowl or like
Who would you have rather the pick been?