payitforward wrote:tontoz wrote:9 and 20 wrote:Saw the discussion on the trade board about a Kuz/Giddey swap.
Is this getting us to 30 wins - Giddey/Poole/Kispert/Deni/Clingan, plus Bilal on the bench? Could tank the end of the season to get us below 30 and in high lottery range.
Not interested in Giddey. He's been in the league 3 years and still can't shoot. Not very athletic either.
??
He's as good a shooter as Kuz
This is an absolutely ridiculous statement that reveals a total absence of experience watching Giddey. Giddey is a terrible shooter and only shoots WIDE OPEN shots that opposing defenses intentionally yield because they would rather have Giddey shoot wide open than anyone else shoot a contested shot.
Giddey's rebounding is also inflated because he plays the power forward position by default since OKC plays small. It also matters that their center is about 195 pounds and can't rebound very well, allowing more rebounds to fall to Giddey.
Giddey is an exceptional passer, but that's really all he is good at. He is a terrible shooter and a bad defender. He doesn't get to the free throw line and he can't break his man down off the dribble His passing skills are nice in a "connector" role, but that's just not enough to be worth enduring his negative impact on spacing and defense. Basically, he needs the ball in his hands to be effective, but he is not effective enough with the ball in his hands to be better than other options. There's a reason he is being played off the floor in the playoffs.
Kuzma is unquestionably a better and more useful player than Giddey. Any trade for Giddey is a bet that he'll get better in the future. He is still very young. But ultimately, I don't think his upside is very high. If he can improve his 3-point shot enough that defenses need to guard him, it may open a pathway for him to be a secondary-attack threat against an off-balance defense, but that's still not that great of an outcome. He would be a below-average defender and an average at best offensive player.