bucknut wrote:greg4012 wrote:bucknut wrote:
Pj, rui, jerami Grant any classic strech....let's use Reid as he is someone Holmes gets compared to. Do we think Holmes has the ability to attack closeouts and slash of Naz ? Can he even attack like towns ?
Holmes looks rather awkward and lacks explosion. He is most comfortable in a crab position with his back to basket. His shot is a very slow setup and release too. I think shooting a contested close out 3 on the swing will be trouble for him and the pickup to drive in afraid he is too deliberate and slow
His post game I feels kind of gets nullified vs real competition.
He's a unique player ....it feels like something is there but
I don't see any deficiency in his attacking closeouts tbh. He looks damn good at it for a player that didn't get tasked with playing from the perimeter until this past season. It's actually shocking that, considering the fact he didn't really play from the perimeter until year 3, he has better playmaking numbers than most starting PFs in the NBA did in their last year before college (I specifically looked at the multi-year college guys, as freshman bigs rarely have plus playmaking numbers).
For someone that lacks explosion, how do you explain Holmes being top 6 in the NCAA each of the past 3 seasons in dunks? Holmes is one of 5 players 6'10 or under to have 89 dunks in a college season since 2008. The other 4 are AD, Bam, Obi Toppin, and Montrezl Harrell.
I don't see post up as a big part of his pro game. That should be reserved mostly as a matchup beater off the switch. His offensive game should be rim runner off the PnR, C&S 3s, and attack off the closeout.
He's been one of the best rim runners in college since his FR year when that's all he did on offense. Dude just stacks more skills onto his foundational strengths.
His shot is a little slow, so we'll see if he continues to develop there.
Holmes is high-waisted and has a funky build. He does look a little awkward out there. But, I think it may be deceiving when weighed against how/if it limits him
5640 and 5735 he gets blocked trying to drive to the hoop. He is long and lengthy athletic yes....but doesn't explode and he takes time to gather after the dribble. His successful drives were against out of shape college 5s but most of his points came via assists on dunks from teammates or iso plays with back to basket on a team that force fed him the ball. He has a great iso spin that allowed him to get away from the d for dunks.
He won't have that luxury of having the whole offense run through him with his crawl dribble unless he's in Denver. He's a slow player and prefers the offensive system to be that way. Would not be a good player for a Celtics style system.....doesn't react well in quick reaction environment imo
Yes he's been blocked before over the course of his 3 season career. I think you're way overstating any lack of explosion. Let me ask you this: How does someone that needs to function out of a back to the basket "crab position" end up being one of the most prolific college dunkers of the past decade?
He's a methodical player that succeeded in differing and expanded roles each season:
(1) Freshman - exclusively as a rim runner/finisher (a part of his game that is most translatable to the NBA, but you seem to completely ignore). Here are his contemporaries in terms of FRESHMAN numbers (dataset begins in 2008):

(2) Sophomore - Became a post up player and the foundation of his team's entire offense. In this higher usage role, he was #2 in the entire NCAA in total dunks on the season (89);
(3) Junior: Built off of his total game and added a heavier dose of perimeter play, including creating more of his own offense from the perimeter and hitting nearly 39% of his 3s (2.5 per game). Here's a total list of players who have ever shown as much of a 2-way inside-outside game in college as Daron (dataset begins in 2008):

He's the next version of the increasingly valuable hybrid BIG that can fit on a lot of teams as either a Center or PF depending on teammates' skillsets. There are a lot of teams where he can very effectively fit alongside star centers or PFs. I see his ideal early role being a team's 3rd big (think Naz Reid, Bobby Portis)
For being touted as such a good passer it's weird he only averaged 2.5 a game
Who is touting him as some next level passer? He showed clear progress over his 3 seasons with court vision, passing and playmaking for others. That's an important skillset for his succeeding in a perimeter role at the next level. Fun fact, Holmes' JR season Assist Volume and A/TO ratio was higher than each of the following starting PFs in the NBA in college (all of which at least played thru their Soph year of college):
Dorian Finney-Smith
Pascal Siakam
PJ Washington
Rui Hachimura
Jerami Grant
Keegan Murray
Kyle Kuzma
There are at least 10 more starting NBA PFs that Holmes clears in terms of college playmaking production, but most were 1 and done players (or international), so I don't think that's as apt of a comparison. I will note that Holmes playmaking production in college also clears that of Naz Reid, Bobby Portis, and Al Horford (3 guys who fit a similar hybrid BIG role that Holmes projects to).
IMO the fact that he won't have the "luxury" to have the whole offense run through him mostly means that he'll face a lot less double teams and defensive focus.
I think one of my favorite things about Holmes as a prospect is the fact that his aesthetics are leading to such a big divergence in his draft stock. Should be fun to see how it unfolds.