DayofMourning wrote:greg4012 wrote:DayofMourning wrote:
Generalizing every other teams decisions as poor wont get far.
Tbh, I disliked JB coming out. He still cant dribble however many years later, but hes a dawg.
Why won't it get far?
There are bad decisions and late round draft gems in every draft.
I would want Miami to trust their own evaluation process and not be swayed by public perception and the echo chamber it can create.
Because its such a generalization. Miami good. Others dumb.
Maybe Holland is falling because hes not good at bball despite his obvious athletic gifts.
And yes, everyone misses, even on obvious choices. They also miss on unheralded talent.
However, when a guy is hyped at the start of the process and does nothing to validate that hype, then does private workouts and is suddenly "falling"...well, what does that mean? That hes going to be Jaylen Brown? The guy who didnt fall and is now literally pushing his team to a chip? Thats a lot to ask.
Ok let's get beyond hypothetical. It's about trusting your own process and not having it be informed by the public chatter that is often just strawmen.
If he's not good at bball, how did he lead his GLI team in scoring as the youngest player on the roster? How did he put up better stats as an 18 year old than virtually every player that has gone from G League to 1st round pick in the past few years?
I can't subscribe to the idea that the highest level of professional basketball operators should base their decisions off of the decisions of others. They should base their decisions off of their own due diligence process.
If you don't like the Jaylen Brown reference because it seems like a 1% outcome, then let's look at the 18 year old stats of other top wings (check out freshman year stats):
Jimmy Butler -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/jimmy-butler-1.htmlKawhi Leonard -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/kawhi-leonard-1.htmlPaul George -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/paul-george-1.htmlJayson Tatum -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/jayson-tatum-1.htmlMikal Bridges -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/mikal-bridges-1.htmlDemar Derozan -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/demar-derozan-1.htmlKhris Middelton -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/khris-middleton-1.htmlFranz Wagner -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/franz-wagner-1.htmlAndrew Wiggins -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/andrew-wiggins-1.htmlOG Anunoby -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/og-anunoby-1.htmlJalen Williams -
https://www.sports-reference.com/cbb/players/jalen-williams-13.htmlCommon features in basically all of them--a bad A/TO ratio. The only one with a positive A/TO ratio was super low usage as a Fresman (Jalen Williams). Other common features with most is bad 3-pt shooting. Many with worse FT shooting than Holland, as well.
I like to operate off of available info. Virtually no uber athletic wing prospects with clear scoring talent and defensive ability are also sharpshooting playmakers at 18 years old.
Maybe his shot is more broken than all of the above. I love that the Heat are working him out to find out. If he works out well for the Heat, I could not care less what the hysteria built on hysteria dictates.
Just look at last draft, I bet Cam Whitmore will be a better NBA player than 2/3 of the players drafted before him.