What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
Moderators: dVs33, Cowology, theBigLip, Snakebites
What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Sophomore
- Posts: 107
- And1: 62
- Joined: Jan 22, 2024
-
What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
I'm coming from the Kings forum in peace to inquire about what you guys think we would need to offer in order to get Isaiah Stewart. We're in a rough situation ourselves as we recover from our own horrible mismanagement and time in the NBA basement, and while we don't have many assets, we need to find a way to get ourselves a long, defensive 4 who can at least somewhat shoot the ball.
For one, what do Pistons fans, who are more familiar with his game, think about the fit? Also, what would it take in addition to Kevin Huerter to make the deal happen? He's not really in a position to start for us, and he's enough of a rhythm shooter that we just don't have the minutes to give him in order to take advantage of his skills.
For one, what do Pistons fans, who are more familiar with his game, think about the fit? Also, what would it take in addition to Kevin Huerter to make the deal happen? He's not really in a position to start for us, and he's enough of a rhythm shooter that we just don't have the minutes to give him in order to take advantage of his skills.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,949
- And1: 5,080
- Joined: Feb 26, 2005
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
Huerter is redundant in Detroit as well with Beasley and THJ here, so his contract would not be appealing to the Pistons. That means, he'd probably have to go to a 3rd team or Sac would have to incentivize the Pistons to take him in addition to what they would offer for Stewart in terms of assets.
You might get a mix of opinions on Stewart here, but I think the Pistons need his ability to stretch the floor and defend from the center position, so it would take an overpay from my perspective (no idea what Langdon thinks).
Because of that, It's hard to see a deal. The only guys I really have an interest in are Keon Ellis and Devin Carter. Of course, draft picks are also interesting.
You might get a mix of opinions on Stewart here, but I think the Pistons need his ability to stretch the floor and defend from the center position, so it would take an overpay from my perspective (no idea what Langdon thinks).
Because of that, It's hard to see a deal. The only guys I really have an interest in are Keon Ellis and Devin Carter. Of course, draft picks are also interesting.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
- VicVinegar
- Sophomore
- Posts: 243
- And1: 221
- Joined: Jul 01, 2024
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
Contract/age wise, Huerter for Stew seems reasonable, but Pistons are weak when it comes to big man depth, so I don't see anything there.
I think most view Stew around here as a good role player with a less than ideal contract and a low ceiling. Quite frankly, he's just not a starter, but I think he definitely provides some 3 and D value getting 20 -25 minutes a night.
Honestly if a team wanted to acquire him, it shouldn't cost much of anything. It just makes zero sense right now as he's more valuable to the pistons than whatever they'd get back. Most likely scenario is they'd move him in the offseason to create cap space, and then could draft or sign a replacement. But right now with little center depth and no free agent targets left, it just doesn't make sense for the Pistons.
I think most view Stew around here as a good role player with a less than ideal contract and a low ceiling. Quite frankly, he's just not a starter, but I think he definitely provides some 3 and D value getting 20 -25 minutes a night.
Honestly if a team wanted to acquire him, it shouldn't cost much of anything. It just makes zero sense right now as he's more valuable to the pistons than whatever they'd get back. Most likely scenario is they'd move him in the offseason to create cap space, and then could draft or sign a replacement. But right now with little center depth and no free agent targets left, it just doesn't make sense for the Pistons.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 21,528
- And1: 1,976
- Joined: Mar 02, 2001
- Contact:
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
We can trade you Paul Reed sometime in late November. I can’t see Stewart being available. Not saying he’s amazing, but he’s among the guys that got screwed by Monty’s lack of interest in last season
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Forum Mod - Pistons
- Posts: 16,832
- And1: 3,421
- Joined: May 22, 2001
- Location: Santa Cruz, CA
-
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
VicVinegar wrote:Contract/age wise, Huerter for Stew seems reasonable, but Pistons are weak when it comes to big man depth, so I don't see anything there.
I think most view Stew around here as a good role player with a less than ideal contract and a low ceiling. Quite frankly, he's just not a starter, but I think he definitely provides some 3 and D value getting 20 -25 minutes a night.
Honestly if a team wanted to acquire him, it shouldn't cost much of anything. It just makes zero sense right now as he's more valuable to the pistons than whatever they'd get back. Most likely scenario is they'd move him in the offseason to create cap space, and then could draft or sign a replacement. But right now with little center depth and no free agent targets left, it just doesn't make sense for the Pistons.
Agree on the Pistons need for big man depth but disagree another team wouldn’t need much to acquire him. He’s a solid rotation player on a playoff team. His 4 year deal is around the MLE for each year (probably year 4 he will be paid beneath it).
So you need to give us something to just take Huerter’s remaining two years and another something to get Stewart. So give us two out of three of (a good) FRP or Ellis or Carter.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Senior
- Posts: 563
- And1: 233
- Joined: Jan 15, 2024
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
theBigLip wrote:He’s a solid rotation player on a playoff team. His 4 year deal is around the MLE for each year (probably year 4 he will be paid beneath it).
Is there any proof that he’s a solid player on a playoff team?
And in year four of his four year contract, he’s a value!

Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,949
- And1: 5,080
- Joined: Feb 26, 2005
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
JennetteMcCurdy wrote:theBigLip wrote:He’s a solid rotation player on a playoff team. His 4 year deal is around the MLE for each year (probably year 4 he will be paid beneath it).
Is there any proof that he’s a solid player on a playoff team?
And in year four of his four year contract, he’s a value!
Players that hustle, defend, and shoot at above average rates ALWAYS find a spot in a playoff rotation. There's a reason that his biggest suitors in the trade market the last couple of years have ALL been top-end teams (Boston, Dallas, and OKC). Every great team needs a few of these guys.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Senior
- Posts: 563
- And1: 233
- Joined: Jan 15, 2024
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
BDM22 wrote:JennetteMcCurdy wrote:theBigLip wrote:He’s a solid rotation player on a playoff team. His 4 year deal is around the MLE for each year (probably year 4 he will be paid beneath it).
Is there any proof that he’s a solid player on a playoff team?
And in year four of his four year contract, he’s a value!
Players that hustle, defend, and shoot at above average rates ALWAYS find a spot in a playoff rotation. There's a reason that his biggest suitors in the trade market the last couple of years have ALL been top-end teams (Boston, Dallas, and OKC). Every great team needs a few of these guys.
Yea but have there been any specific offers for Stewart that you can quote?
If not, it’s null and void
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,949
- And1: 5,080
- Joined: Feb 26, 2005
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
JennetteMcCurdy wrote:BDM22 wrote:JennetteMcCurdy wrote:
Is there any proof that he’s a solid player on a playoff team?
And in year four of his four year contract, he’s a value!
Players that hustle, defend, and shoot at above average rates ALWAYS find a spot in a playoff rotation. There's a reason that his biggest suitors in the trade market the last couple of years have ALL been top-end teams (Boston, Dallas, and OKC). Every great team needs a few of these guys.
Yea but have there been any specific offers for Stewart that you can quote?
If not, it’s null and void
Of course we don't know specific offers. We just know that the teams that want him are some of the top teams in the league. Good teams aren't looking to bring in Stewart's $15M/year to not play him in their rotation!
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Senior
- Posts: 563
- And1: 233
- Joined: Jan 15, 2024
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
BDM22 wrote:JennetteMcCurdy wrote:BDM22 wrote:Players that hustle, defend, and shoot at above average rates ALWAYS find a spot in a playoff rotation. There's a reason that his biggest suitors in the trade market the last couple of years have ALL been top-end teams (Boston, Dallas, and OKC). Every great team needs a few of these guys.
Yea but have there been any specific offers for Stewart that you can quote?
If not, it’s null and void
Of course we don't know specific offers. We just know that the teams that want him are some of the top teams in the league. Good teams aren't looking to bring in Stewart's $15M/year to not play him in their rotation!
So as it stands, no one really wants Stewart for the price. Glad we all agree on that!
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,949
- And1: 5,080
- Joined: Feb 26, 2005
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
JennetteMcCurdy wrote:BDM22 wrote:JennetteMcCurdy wrote:
Yea but have there been any specific offers for Stewart that you can quote?
If not, it’s null and void
Of course we don't know specific offers. We just know that the teams that want him are some of the top teams in the league. Good teams aren't looking to bring in Stewart's $15M/year to not play him in their rotation!
So as it stands, no one really wants Stewart for the price. Glad we all agree on that!
What? lol
Teams apparently didn't want him for the price Weaver (and so far Langdon) have for him. That's all we know. We DO know that Boston, OKC, and Dallas wanted him AFTER the contract extension was signed. Any talk on the value returned would be conjecture.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
- Piston Pete
- RealGM
- Posts: 19,070
- And1: 1,352
- Joined: Feb 07, 2002
- Location: Way out in left field
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
Pretty sure the Kings don’t have the assets enough to warrant trading them Stew. The players we’d want, they’d want to keep. The players they’d make available, we wouldn’t/shouldn’t want.
Moving on
Moving on
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Forum Mod - Pistons
- Posts: 16,832
- And1: 3,421
- Joined: May 22, 2001
- Location: Santa Cruz, CA
-
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
BDM22 wrote:JennetteMcCurdy wrote:BDM22 wrote:
Of course we don't know specific offers. We just know that the teams that want him are some of the top teams in the league. Good teams aren't looking to bring in Stewart's $15M/year to not play him in their rotation!
So as it stands, no one really wants Stewart for the price. Glad we all agree on that!
What? lol
Teams apparently didn't want him for the price Weaver (and so far Langdon) have for him. That's all we know. We DO know that Boston, OKC, and Dallas wanted him AFTER the contract extension was signed. Any talk on the value returned would be conjecture.
Totally agree w BDM. I don’t understand Jeanette’s logic on this one.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 4,322
- And1: 2,289
- Joined: Nov 23, 2018
-
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
To answer the OP's other question that hasn't really been answered: I'm not sure he's really a fit. He's much more suited to being a back up 5 than a starting 4.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Sixth Man
- Posts: 1,811
- And1: 361
- Joined: Jul 31, 2004
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
Piston Pete wrote:Pretty sure the Kings don’t have the assets enough to warrant trading them Stew. The players we’d want, they’d want to keep. The players they’d make available, we wouldn’t/shouldn’t want.
Moving on
They have the assets, they just might not want to give them.
I'd do, Huerter/Carter for Stewart/Sasser for example.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Forum Mod - Pistons
- Posts: 16,832
- And1: 3,421
- Joined: May 22, 2001
- Location: Santa Cruz, CA
-
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
Drwho17 wrote:Piston Pete wrote:Pretty sure the Kings don’t have the assets enough to warrant trading them Stew. The players we’d want, they’d want to keep. The players they’d make available, we wouldn’t/shouldn’t want.
Moving on
They have the assets, they just might not want to give them.
I'd do, Huerter/Carter for Stewart/Sasser for example.
I like Carter but I think he’s compensation for taking on Huerter. They need to add something else to get Stewart, like a draft pick.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Forum Mod - Pistons
- Posts: 41,153
- And1: 4,625
- Joined: Sep 05, 2004
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
Stew is needed. Not to say he's unavailable, but it would take an unlikely over pay to pry him free because we'd immediately need to find another big who can both defend & shoot. Makes this largely a non-starter.
Stew makes more sense as part of a package that would secure an upgrade. He's not the guy we want to move for picks/prospects.
Stew makes more sense as part of a package that would secure an upgrade. He's not the guy we want to move for picks/prospects.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Junior
- Posts: 279
- And1: 173
- Joined: May 16, 2009
- Location: Expect the unexpected.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
Stewart is on a great contract - every Pistons fan would say the same. Earlier this summer, I advocated for pairing him with one or more of our young core (Ivey, Sasser) and trying to trade for an impact player at the SG or PF positions. Since then, we've spent a high draft pick on a SF/PF (Holland) and spent a lot of money on another one (Harris).
I'm not sure I would have drafted Holland - I liked Clingan - or signed Harris had I been in charge. But without a strong option behind Duren, I think we need to ride it out with Stewart. It's not the best option, in my opinion, but I'm telling myself to let TL cook.
Stewart has been in the league for four years and won 74 total games (18.5/year average). Brutal.
I'm not sure I would have drafted Holland - I liked Clingan - or signed Harris had I been in charge. But without a strong option behind Duren, I think we need to ride it out with Stewart. It's not the best option, in my opinion, but I'm telling myself to let TL cook.
Stewart has been in the league for four years and won 74 total games (18.5/year average). Brutal.
"A moment later, the two of us were millions of miles up in outer space ..."
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,207
- And1: 3,339
- Joined: Sep 06, 2013
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
I don't think the team is interested in moving him for a 1-1 type deal. His name has been in some of the rumored packages for a bigger name player, but I think that's because he 1) has value and 2) has a substantial but fairly reasonable contract for salary matching.
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
- Snakebites
- Forum Mod - Pistons
- Posts: 50,826
- And1: 17,966
- Joined: Jul 14, 2002
- Location: Looking not-so-happily deranged
-
Re: What would the Pistons' return in a Beef Stew trade look like?
Cowology wrote:Stew is needed. Not to say he's unavailable, but it would take an unlikely over pay to pry him free because we'd immediately need to find another big who can both defend & shoot. Makes this largely a non-starter.
Stew makes more sense as part of a package that would secure an upgrade. He's not the guy we want to move for picks/prospects.
What do you think Stew’s ceiling as a shooter is?
As of now I don’t think his shooting brings much value given he isn’t actually spreading the floor with it- teams are still able to lay off of him without consequence. To me unless you think it’s an aspect of his game that can expand it’s of smaller importance.