RGM GOAT Debate Thread

Moderators: cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285, Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid

Who Is officially the all time goat!? Only have 10 slots Poll. 2024/5 season

Jordan
369
63%
Lebron
123
21%
B. Russell
21
4%
Kobe
10
2%
Kareem
16
3%
Magic
3
1%
Jokic
13
2%
Curry
9
2%
Duncan
8
1%
Other Insert comment goat debate
14
2%
 
Total votes: 586

MavsDirk41
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,828
And1: 4,514
Joined: Dec 07, 2022
     

Re: Did any players make their teammates better as much as MJ did? (Via practice, accountability, etc) 

Post#401 » by MavsDirk41 » Wed Jul 31, 2024 7:53 pm

Homer38 wrote:
MavsDirk41 wrote:
SlimShady83 wrote:
lol yep and It's not even close to being the actual NBA season yet :lol:



Nfl season kicks off in 5 weeks….something to look forward to until the end of October


I always look forward at how bad the cowboys will choke in january!



Kind of like 2011 nba finals James choke lol?
Homer38
RealGM
Posts: 12,178
And1: 13,711
Joined: Dec 04, 2013

Re: Did any players make their teammates better as much as MJ did? (Via practice, accountability, etc) 

Post#402 » by Homer38 » Wed Jul 31, 2024 7:54 pm

MavsDirk41 wrote:
Homer38 wrote:
MavsDirk41 wrote:

Nfl season kicks off in 5 weeks….something to look forward to until the end of October


I always look forward at how bad the cowboys will choke in january!



Kind of like 2011 nba finals James choke lol?


yeah but it happens every year for the cowboys!
SlimShady83
RealGM
Posts: 15,676
And1: 4,977
Joined: Jun 19, 2012

Re: Official RGM GOAT Debate Thread 

Post#403 » by SlimShady83 » Wed Jul 31, 2024 8:11 pm

NO PLEASE DON'T START TALKING ABOUT OTHER SPORTS, this is basketball only
My Go Team
Magic, Jordan, Bird, Duncan, Shaq

My Counter
Stockton, Kobe, Pippen, Rodman, Dirk

Today's Team
Luka, SGA, Tatum, Giannis, Wemby
ScrantonBulls
Veteran
Posts: 2,554
And1: 3,516
Joined: Nov 18, 2023
     

Re: Official RGM GOAT Debate Thread 

Post#404 » by ScrantonBulls » Thu Aug 1, 2024 2:45 am

SlimShady83 wrote:NO PLEASE DON'T START TALKING ABOUT OTHER SPORTS, this is basketball only

Who made you boss? This moderator sanctioned GOAT thread sucks ass. OP is drunk again too.
bledredwine wrote:There were 3 times Jordan won and was considered the underdog

1989 Eastern Conference Finals against the Detroit Pistons, the 1991 NBA Finals against the Magic Johnson-led Los Angeles Lakers, and the 1995 Eastern Conference Finals against the NY Knicks
SlimShady83
RealGM
Posts: 15,676
And1: 4,977
Joined: Jun 19, 2012

Re: Official RGM GOAT Debate Thread 

Post#405 » by SlimShady83 » Thu Aug 1, 2024 5:41 am

ScrantonBulls wrote:
SlimShady83 wrote:NO PLEASE DON'T START TALKING ABOUT OTHER SPORTS, this is basketball only

Who made you boss? This moderator sanctioned GOAT thread sucks ass. OP is drunk again too.

No one, but I helped come up idea of the sticky thread and nope not drunk, only drink on Friday's :lol:
My Go Team
Magic, Jordan, Bird, Duncan, Shaq

My Counter
Stockton, Kobe, Pippen, Rodman, Dirk

Today's Team
Luka, SGA, Tatum, Giannis, Wemby
bledredwine
RealGM
Posts: 14,654
And1: 5,788
Joined: Sep 17, 2010
   

Re: Official RGM GOAT Debate Thread 

Post#406 » by bledredwine » Thu Aug 1, 2024 4:31 pm

SlimShady83 wrote:This guy Is actually good with his videos.



This guy has some excellent points.

Jordan stuck with the team when they were way outmatched and took the mentality of making the team tougher over all of those years of being way understaffed (Pippen stated that Jordan had him guard him in practices as well). Lebron teamed up whenever outmatched and the Heatles were immediately the most talented team in the league… and then 2011.

Jordan also didn’t play for stats, he was going to shoot and take over simply for the win. Players actually did say you didn’t look him in the eye because he’d take it as a challenge, and the further he went regular season - playoffs - finals,

the stronger he got. I remember seeing a stat where both Lebron and Kobe’s 50 point games were 75% against losing teams (both players were right around that mark), and 73 percent of Jordan’s were against winning teams, plenty who were strong. Think 63 against the Celtics in the playoffs or 69 against the Cavs, a defensively strong team with light out shooting.
:o LeBron is 0-7 in game winning/tying FGs in the finals. And is 20/116 or 17% in game winning/tying FGs in the 4th/OT for his career. That's historically bad :o
bledredwine
RealGM
Posts: 14,654
And1: 5,788
Joined: Sep 17, 2010
   

Re: Did any players make their teammates better as much as MJ did? (Via practice, accountability, etc) 

Post#407 » by bledredwine » Thu Aug 1, 2024 4:33 pm

Lalouie wrote:
ScrantonBulls wrote:I'm not talking about making their teammates better by giving them assist like Magic or anything. See the thought provoking post below about what I mean - specifically the bolded.

bledredwine wrote:

That's a really unusual take. Jordan impacted both ends of the floor as much as anyone.

And more than Hakeem, Lebron, or anyone you mentioned, Jordan held the teammates accountable,
holding them to a very high standard and turning practices into wars, which made games easy-
this has been said by multiple players, from Scottie to BJ, Grant etc.


To say he didn't have a multitude of impact is wild. And when he played point for the Bulls? He averaged near a 32 point triple double during the season while only playing PG for a portion of it. In 1991? He averaged 32.5, 11.4 (3rd highest finals assists of all time behind Russell and Magic) with awesome defense.

There was not much else if anything he could have done to be impactful.

This is why Jordan and Scottie 3-peated twice with two different supporting casts, and Pippen himself stated that Jordan's push made him the player he became (Jordan used to have Pippen guard him during practice when he was young in the league)

The only players that holds others accountable like that whom you mentioned is probably Duncan or Hakeem to an extent, but nearly the same extent as Jordan.

Either way, I appreciate you acknowledging that. Lebron's are impressive as well.

It's been said that no player had the off court impact on his teammates like MJ did.

- He had.twammates accountable like you wouldn't believe. Nobody held teammates more accountable than MJ did.
- He made practices ALL OUT WAR. Per bledredwine's post, this games simple. Games were a walk in the park after to into battle with MJ during practice. Those must have been intense practices.

More than any other player, you hear? How much Pippen benefited from practicing against Jordan. How do you think he became a GOAT wing defender? Practicing against Jordan. He may not have become the all-star player he was without Jordan to play against.

The question is simple. Did any players have the off court impact on teammates that MJ had?



"making teammates better" is in and of itself a specious assertion, but when you stretch it by adding what you parenthesized, it becomes even more difficult.

as in how are you going to back this up.


How about literally most of the Bulls players stating that Jordan made practices harder than games, and then the obvious evidence that Jordan got on a guy’s case any time there was an error on the court.

It’s pretty obvious and if you followed Jordan, you’d know this as a given by now.
:o LeBron is 0-7 in game winning/tying FGs in the finals. And is 20/116 or 17% in game winning/tying FGs in the 4th/OT for his career. That's historically bad :o
JRoy
RealGM
Posts: 16,931
And1: 14,270
Joined: Feb 27, 2019
 

Re: Official RGM GOAT Debate Thread 

Post#408 » by JRoy » Thu Aug 1, 2024 9:52 pm

How is Wilt not on the list?
Edrees wrote:
JRoy wrote:Monta Ellis have it all


I was hoping and expecting this to be one of the first replies. You did not disappoint. Jroy have it all.
Rishkar
Junior
Posts: 474
And1: 340
Joined: Feb 19, 2022
     

Re: Official RGM GOAT Debate Thread 

Post#409 » by Rishkar » Thu Aug 1, 2024 9:59 pm

Candidates
Russell
LeBron
Jordan
Kareem

The Dark Horse Candidates
Tim Duncan
Wilt

The "I Really Want to be Different" Candidates
Jokic
Mikan
Magic
KG
Hakeem
Curry
Shaq
Bird
Oscar
Kobe

Listed in order of reasonableness
nikster
RealGM
Posts: 14,524
And1: 13,008
Joined: Sep 08, 2013

Re: Official RGM GOAT Debate Thread 

Post#410 » by nikster » Thu Aug 1, 2024 10:11 pm

bledredwine wrote:
SlimShady83 wrote:This guy Is actually good with his videos.



This guy has some excellent points.

Jordan stuck with the team when they were way outmatched and took the mentality of making the team tougher over all of those years of being way understaffed (Pippen stated that Jordan had him guard him in practices as well). Lebron teamed up whenever outmatched and the Heatles were immediately the most talented team in the league… and then 2011.

Jordan also didn’t play for stats, he was going to shoot and take over simply for the win. Players actually did say you didn’t look him in the eye because he’d take it as a challenge, and the further he went regular season - playoffs - finals,

the stronger he got. I remember seeing a stat where both Lebron and Kobe’s 50 point games were 75% against losing teams (both players were right around that mark), and 73 percent of Jordan’s were against winning teams, plenty who were strong. Think 63 against the Celtics in the playoffs or 69 against the Cavs, a defensively strong team with light out shooting.

The initial outmatched team Jordan had around him he didn't make tougher, they were entirely replaced by a competent GM.
nikster
RealGM
Posts: 14,524
And1: 13,008
Joined: Sep 08, 2013

Re: Did any players make their teammates better as much as MJ did? (Via practice, accountability, etc) 

Post#411 » by nikster » Thu Aug 1, 2024 10:12 pm

bledredwine wrote:
Lalouie wrote:
ScrantonBulls wrote:I'm not talking about making their teammates better by giving them assist like Magic or anything. See the thought provoking post below about what I mean - specifically the bolded.


It's been said that no player had the off court impact on his teammates like MJ did.

- He had.twammates accountable like you wouldn't believe. Nobody held teammates more accountable than MJ did.
- He made practices ALL OUT WAR. Per bledredwine's post, this games simple. Games were a walk in the park after to into battle with MJ during practice. Those must have been intense practices.

More than any other player, you hear? How much Pippen benefited from practicing against Jordan. How do you think he became a GOAT wing defender? Practicing against Jordan. He may not have become the all-star player he was without Jordan to play against.

The question is simple. Did any players have the off court impact on teammates that MJ had?



"making teammates better" is in and of itself a specious assertion, but when you stretch it by adding what you parenthesized, it becomes even more difficult.

as in how are you going to back this up.


How about literally most of the Bulls players stating that Jordan made practices harder than games, and then the obvious evidence that Jordan got on a guy’s case any time there was an error on the court.

It’s pretty obvious and if you followed Jordan, you’d know this as a given by now.

Bolded doesn't mean he's making his teammates better
The4thHorseman
General Manager
Posts: 9,098
And1: 5,675
Joined: Jun 18, 2011

Re: Did any players make their teammates better as much as MJ did? (Via practice, accountability, etc) 

Post#412 » by The4thHorseman » Thu Aug 1, 2024 11:01 pm

MavsDirk41 wrote:
Homer38 wrote:
MavsDirk41 wrote:

Nfl season kicks off in 5 weeks….something to look forward to until the end of October


I always look forward at how bad the cowboys will choke in january!



Kind of like 2011 nba finals James choke lol?

And like how Dirk choked in the first round in 2007 against the 8th seeded Warriors.
MavsDirk41 wrote:

Utah was a dynasty in the 90s
Blazers had a mini dynasty late 80s early 90s
bledredwine
RealGM
Posts: 14,654
And1: 5,788
Joined: Sep 17, 2010
   

Re: Official RGM GOAT Debate Thread 

Post#413 » by bledredwine » Fri Aug 2, 2024 4:38 am

nikster wrote:
bledredwine wrote:
SlimShady83 wrote:This guy Is actually good with his videos.



This guy has some excellent points.

Jordan stuck with the team when they were way outmatched and took the mentality of making the team tougher over all of those years of being way understaffed (Pippen stated that Jordan had him guard him in practices as well). Lebron teamed up whenever outmatched and the Heatles were immediately the most talented team in the league… and then 2011.

Jordan also didn’t play for stats, he was going to shoot and take over simply for the win. Players actually did say you didn’t look him in the eye because he’d take it as a challenge, and the further he went regular season - playoffs - finals,

the stronger he got. I remember seeing a stat where both Lebron and Kobe’s 50 point games were 75% against losing teams (both players were right around that mark), and 73 percent of Jordan’s were against winning teams, plenty who were strong. Think 63 against the Celtics in the playoffs or 69 against the Cavs, a defensively strong team with light out shooting.

The initial outmatched team Jordan had around him he didn't make tougher, they were entirely replaced by a competent GM.


That’s not true. The 90 team was made stronger and they’ve attested to this in interviews.

We also know how intense Jordan got about practices and that Pippen credited part of his development toJordan pushing him and having him guard him in practice.

Then there’s the on court accountability, where he’s second to none.
:o LeBron is 0-7 in game winning/tying FGs in the finals. And is 20/116 or 17% in game winning/tying FGs in the 4th/OT for his career. That's historically bad :o
Lo Wang
Rookie
Posts: 1,155
And1: 620
Joined: Jan 07, 2024

Who is the greatest all around player of all time? 

Post#414 » by Lo Wang » Fri Aug 2, 2024 10:56 am

Let's ignore records, rings, awards, etc. Who is the best and most impactful all around player in their prime? He doesn't have to be a great scorer or passer; he can just do the little things that help his team win. I am going to omit Lebron just because he is more of a scorer most of his career than an all around player.
SlimShady83
RealGM
Posts: 15,676
And1: 4,977
Joined: Jun 19, 2012

Re: Who is the greatest all around players of all time? 

Post#415 » by SlimShady83 » Fri Aug 2, 2024 10:59 am

Bird On the poll

But for the little things
Dennis Rodman, gets little credit for all the things he did. Heart, hustle and energy and comes away with 5 chips - rarely gets enough credit.

p.s It's Friday all, y'all know what that means :)
My Go Team
Magic, Jordan, Bird, Duncan, Shaq

My Counter
Stockton, Kobe, Pippen, Rodman, Dirk

Today's Team
Luka, SGA, Tatum, Giannis, Wemby
Tim Lehrbach
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 26,111
And1: 4,379
Joined: Jul 29, 2001
   

Re: Who is the greatest all around player of all time? 

Post#416 » by Tim Lehrbach » Fri Aug 2, 2024 11:36 am

LeBron.
Clipsz 4 Life
January 20, 2002-May 17, 2006
Saxon
February 20, 2001-August 9, 2007
Kiss of Death
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,463
And1: 1,663
Joined: Jun 24, 2022
 

Re: Who is the greatest all around player of all time? 

Post#417 » by Kiss of Death » Fri Aug 2, 2024 11:43 am

Olajuwon.
Movics
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,631
And1: 1,726
Joined: Jul 16, 2015
       

Re: Who is the greatest all around player of all time? 

Post#418 » by Movics » Fri Aug 2, 2024 11:47 am

How is the player whose only weakness is FT shooting omitted from the list? Scorer with over 11k assists…
Run n point that .32 make em sicker than magic
foreigngrammar
Pro Prospect
Posts: 871
And1: 537
Joined: Jun 28, 2014

Re: Who is the greatest all around player of all time? 

Post#419 » by foreigngrammar » Fri Aug 2, 2024 11:53 am

You dared to not include LeBron at all? :lol:
Lo Wang
Rookie
Posts: 1,155
And1: 620
Joined: Jan 07, 2024

Re: Who is the greatest all around player of all time? 

Post#420 » by Lo Wang » Fri Aug 2, 2024 11:57 am

foreigngrammar wrote:You dared to not include LeBron at all? :lol:


By all around, I mean triple double threat: a guy who does a bit of everything. Lebron has been more of a prolific scorer than an all around player; it's hard to classify, but I just don't see him as an all around player like Kidd, Magic, Doncic, etc.

I'm open to a debate on this subject matter because I admit I could be wrong.

Return to The General Board