JujitsuFlip wrote:https://www.fearthesword.com/2024/8/26/24228197/grading-every-cavs-move-since-the-donovan-mitchell-trade
If you all have a chance, give this article a read.
Never heard of the author but i really agree with the overall narrative of the piece.
I don't think the individual grades for each move matter so much but the conclusion i fully agree with.
Flickinger is on The Junkyard Pod with Tony Pesta a lot.
I fundamentally disagree because there is a complete lack of expectation setting for certain moves and consideration of the alternatives.
Love was a disaster in hindsight because Dean Wade never got healthy, but he didn't shoot well in Miami either-- was he going to be the difference between beating New York or not? Was he leaving in free agency anyway? We thought, at the time, that Wade and Stevens could handle the 4 when we released him. Turns out Wade never got healthy and Stevens can't rebound when playing the 4.
Danny Green was a flop, but a flop with your 15th roster spot isn't a disaster, it's how it goes in the NBA. Would we have rather promoted Diakite to the playoff roster?
Damian Jones was a flop, but a flop with your third-string C when your fourth-string C actually plays well isn't a disaster, it's how it goes in the NBA. Signing both Jones AND Tristan Thompson, and batting roughly 50% on the results? Great outcome when you sum both moves.
If signing LeVert to a reasonable deal that expires when we need cap space is a C, I don't know what kind of curve is going on here. He's a little expensive for a 6th man but not egregiously so. He says LeVert doesn't fit while linking to an article saying that LeVert is versatile enough to fill a variety of roles on the team-- the most fitty fit there is. LeVert is on the team because he's happy to be a Cav, being born and raised in Ohio.
Actually finding useful guys in roster spots 10-15 like Merrill and CPJ and TT is the valuable part of being a GM. Most guys in those roster spots aren't playable playoff players on the majority of rosters around the league. Damian Jones didn't work out? Doesn't matter when TT did. Emoni Bates still on a two-way? Par for the course drafting a young guy in the back half of the second round. Is $8m for a guy who played every game for us in the regular season an F-worthy deal? Nah, not when guys who are often not even in rotations like Luke Kennard is signing for slightly more.
His more pronounced "mistakes" are his lack of moves rather than the moves he's made. Would firing JBB last summer instead of this summer and getting a better coach helped the team more? Maybe. Should he have made a deal at either of the past two trade deadlines? Probably. Should he do something besides low-ball Okoro this offseason? Probably.