Lo Wang wrote:dhsilv2 wrote:Lo Wang wrote:
How am I stupid for saying Shaq and Kobe can win 8 rings if healthy and intact?
It's a speculation bro. I'm not talking in matter of fact terms.
If you disagree, state your position and speculate. Stop relying on stats. I understand nobody wants to look stupid, but I'm not learning anything from you guys except a few great posters in here who speculate and come up with the better idea.
If all you do is stats this and that, I'm sorry, you're not teaching me anything.
Healthy and intact for 8 years is already impossible...so yeah. It's a stupid statement. That doesn't even get into the wear and tear of going to the finals for multiple seasons. There's a reason teams just can't keep doing it and breakdown.
That's the criteria. The speculation is based on the criteria.
At the time, when Shaq/Kobe were in their primes, they still had 15 years left.
You're telling me they can't win 8 rings if they were completely healthy and remained as a team?
If you want a real debate, we can break down the metrics and go at it.
When shaq won his first ring with kobe, he was 27..they didnt have 15 years left to play with each other.
So they would have to win 8 straight until shaq is 35...or win it all with a 36 or older shaq. Neither seems plausible when you consider that they lost in 04 and how well shaq was playing when he got older.