Butler to Lakers with Pistons
Moderators: MoneyTalks41890, HartfordWhalers, Texas Chuck, BullyKing, Andre Roberstan, loserX, Trader_Joe, Mamba4Goat, pacers33granger
Butler to Lakers with Pistons
- zimpy27
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 45,467
- And1: 43,615
- Joined: Jul 13, 2014
Butler to Lakers with Pistons
Lakers get Butler, Burks, Reed, Larsson
Lakers give Rui, Vincent, Vando, Christie, Knecht, JHS, LAL28swap
Heat get Knecht, Christie, Rui, Vincent
Heat give Butler, Burks, Larsson
Pistons get Vando, JHS, LAL28swap
Pistons give Reed
Lakers go for a big 3: Reaves, Butler, DFS, LeBron, Davis -- Burks, Larsson, Reddish, Wood, Reed
Heat get Christie+Knecht (combined for $12m in 2026 offseason, which doesn't eat their space much at all). They also get Rui and Vincent that expire in 2026. Importantly the Heat duck the tax entirely this season.
Pistons get Vando who is expected back on the court this month. They also get a look at JHS. But mainly they get the unprotected swap when they should be a strong playoff team and Lakers will probably be without LeBron and Butler.
Lakers give Rui, Vincent, Vando, Christie, Knecht, JHS, LAL28swap
Heat get Knecht, Christie, Rui, Vincent
Heat give Butler, Burks, Larsson
Pistons get Vando, JHS, LAL28swap
Pistons give Reed
Lakers go for a big 3: Reaves, Butler, DFS, LeBron, Davis -- Burks, Larsson, Reddish, Wood, Reed
Heat get Christie+Knecht (combined for $12m in 2026 offseason, which doesn't eat their space much at all). They also get Rui and Vincent that expire in 2026. Importantly the Heat duck the tax entirely this season.
Pistons get Vando who is expected back on the court this month. They also get a look at JHS. But mainly they get the unprotected swap when they should be a strong playoff team and Lakers will probably be without LeBron and Butler.
"Let's play some basketball!" - Fergie
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,709
- And1: 3,618
- Joined: Jul 31, 2009
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
If I were Lakers, I'd add another swap to keep Knecht, or just remove Knecht altogether. Larsson isn't setting the world on fire, and despite hearing for years about Paul Read being some "advances stat/per 48 monster", his ACTUAL stats, and GAMETIME haven't really backed that up, imo... This also leaves the Lakers pretty thin on the guard spots. I'd see what other offers I had to beat before putting this out there as my initial off, from Lakers pov.
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 14,262
- And1: 9,749
- Joined: Feb 04, 2005
- Location: San Francisco, CA
-
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
This is actually tempting to me.
I actually like Vando, so the 3/36 after this year doesn’t bother me a ton. He’s likely a bit overpaid unless he stays fully healthy and improves a bit, but gritty defense is a Detroit staple.
JHS had his options declined and would just be getting a look before seeing if he sticks in the league as a near minimum guy.
That swap is potentially juicy but would def need to be unprotected to take on 14(prorated)/12/12/13 in salary for future years.
I think I’d say yes from Detroit.
I actually like Vando, so the 3/36 after this year doesn’t bother me a ton. He’s likely a bit overpaid unless he stays fully healthy and improves a bit, but gritty defense is a Detroit staple.
JHS had his options declined and would just be getting a look before seeing if he sticks in the league as a near minimum guy.
That swap is potentially juicy but would def need to be unprotected to take on 14(prorated)/12/12/13 in salary for future years.
I think I’d say yes from Detroit.
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 14,579
- And1: 4,415
- Joined: Jun 19, 2012
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
No thanks Zimpy, you've lost me again, go back to the Utah trade where you won me over
My Go Team
Magic, Jordan, Pippen, Duncan, Shaq
My Counter
Stockton, Kobe, Bird, Rodman, Dirk
Today's Team
Luka, SGA, Tatum, Giannis, Wemby
Magic, Jordan, Pippen, Duncan, Shaq
My Counter
Stockton, Kobe, Bird, Rodman, Dirk
Today's Team
Luka, SGA, Tatum, Giannis, Wemby
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
- zimpy27
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 45,467
- And1: 43,615
- Joined: Jul 13, 2014
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
axeman23 wrote:If I were Lakers, I'd add another swap to keep Knecht, or just remove Knecht altogether. Larsson isn't setting the world on fire, and despite hearing for years about Paul Read being some "advances stat/per 48 monster", his ACTUAL stats, and GAMETIME haven't really backed that up, imo... This also leaves the Lakers pretty thin on the guard spots. I'd see what other offers I had to beat before putting this out there as my initial off, from Lakers pov.
Well Knecht and Christie is the value that makes Heat actually choose this path. I'm not sure a swap is tempting to Heat unless it's in 2030.
"Let's play some basketball!" - Fergie
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 4,642
- And1: 469
- Joined: Jun 10, 2005
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
Is Knecht worth that much? I know he’s had some good games but really?
The rest is low value.
The rest is low value.
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
- zimpy27
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 45,467
- And1: 43,615
- Joined: Jul 13, 2014
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
Xman wrote:Is Knecht worth that much? I know he’s had some good games but really?
The rest is low value.
Knecht and Christie
"Let's play some basketball!" - Fergie
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,057
- And1: 5,694
- Joined: Feb 27, 2020
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
zimpy27 wrote:Lakers get Butler, Burks, Reed, Larsson
Lakers give Rui, Vincent, Vando, Christie, Knecht, JHS, LAL28swap
Heat get Knecht, Christie, Rui, Vincent
Heat give Butler, Burks, Larsson
Pistons get Vando, JHS, LAL28swap
Pistons give Reed
Lakers go for a big 3: Reaves, Butler, DFS, LeBron, Davis -- Burks, Larsson, Reddish, Wood, Reed
Heat get Christie+Knecht (combined for $12m in 2026 offseason, which doesn't eat their space much at all). They also get Rui and Vincent that expire in 2026. Importantly the Heat duck the tax entirely this season.
Pistons get Vando who is expected back on the court this month. They also get a look at JHS. But mainly they get the unprotected swap when they should be a strong playoff team and Lakers will probably be without LeBron and Butler.
All else aside Reed cannot be traded this season. He was released and resigned.
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
- zimpy27
- Forum Mod
- Posts: 45,467
- And1: 43,615
- Joined: Jul 13, 2014
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
winforlose wrote:zimpy27 wrote:Lakers get Butler, Burks, Reed, Larsson
Lakers give Rui, Vincent, Vando, Christie, Knecht, JHS, LAL28swap
Heat get Knecht, Christie, Rui, Vincent
Heat give Butler, Burks, Larsson
Pistons get Vando, JHS, LAL28swap
Pistons give Reed
Lakers go for a big 3: Reaves, Butler, DFS, LeBron, Davis -- Burks, Larsson, Reddish, Wood, Reed
Heat get Christie+Knecht (combined for $12m in 2026 offseason, which doesn't eat their space much at all). They also get Rui and Vincent that expire in 2026. Importantly the Heat duck the tax entirely this season.
Pistons get Vando who is expected back on the court this month. They also get a look at JHS. But mainly they get the unprotected swap when they should be a strong playoff team and Lakers will probably be without LeBron and Butler.
All else aside Reed cannot be traded this season. He was released and resigned.
Can he not be traded at all? I just thought he couldn't be aggregated
"Let's play some basketball!" - Fergie
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,040
- And1: 5,547
- Joined: Jun 03, 2023
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
Seems like the Heat would be better off keeping Butler and playing hardball.
Warspite wrote:Billups was a horrible scorer who could only score with an open corner 3 or a FT.
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,057
- And1: 5,694
- Joined: Feb 27, 2020
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
zimpy27 wrote:winforlose wrote:zimpy27 wrote:Lakers get Butler, Burks, Reed, Larsson
Lakers give Rui, Vincent, Vando, Christie, Knecht, JHS, LAL28swap
Heat get Knecht, Christie, Rui, Vincent
Heat give Butler, Burks, Larsson
Pistons get Vando, JHS, LAL28swap
Pistons give Reed
Lakers go for a big 3: Reaves, Butler, DFS, LeBron, Davis -- Burks, Larsson, Reddish, Wood, Reed
Heat get Christie+Knecht (combined for $12m in 2026 offseason, which doesn't eat their space much at all). They also get Rui and Vincent that expire in 2026. Importantly the Heat duck the tax entirely this season.
Pistons get Vando who is expected back on the court this month. They also get a look at JHS. But mainly they get the unprotected swap when they should be a strong playoff team and Lakers will probably be without LeBron and Butler.
All else aside Reed cannot be traded this season. He was released and resigned.
Can he not be traded at all? I just thought he couldn't be aggregated
Spotract says ineligible to be traded until March. Which makes sense as a newly signed player.
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
- AmusingFiddle
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,187
- And1: 375
- Joined: Jun 17, 2008
-
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
Hard Pass from Lakers. Knecht from what we hear is untouchable. Not trading our flexibility and youth to take on a headache that wants a 120M extension to play 60 games a year.
Miami won't do this either.
Sent from my SM-N986U1 using RealGM mobile app
Miami won't do this either.
Sent from my SM-N986U1 using RealGM mobile app
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,550
- And1: 5,081
- Joined: Nov 04, 2017
-
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
Trade machine takes this (but unsure if its correct since LAL taking in a bit more $. Can get rid of Larsson if needed)
Not moving Max in this deal
Lakers get Butler, Larsson
Lakers give Rui, Vincent, Vando, Knecht, JHS, Cam/Hayes, LA 26 swap, LAL28swap
Can move a 1st if needed, but then trying to see if we can swing Wood and 2 1sts (protecting 1) for Kessler
Reaves, Butler, DFS, Bron, AD
Milton, Christie, Cam, Kessler
Pretty great top 7 of AD, Bron, Butler, Reaves, Kessler, DFS, Christie,
Sign DSJ/Fulz, RoCo, and some other vets
If Miami wants a 1st, take out a swap and get another cheap C, but not many good Cs at 3M or less
Not moving Max in this deal
Lakers get Butler, Larsson
Lakers give Rui, Vincent, Vando, Knecht, JHS, Cam/Hayes, LA 26 swap, LAL28swap
Can move a 1st if needed, but then trying to see if we can swing Wood and 2 1sts (protecting 1) for Kessler
Reaves, Butler, DFS, Bron, AD
Milton, Christie, Cam, Kessler
Pretty great top 7 of AD, Bron, Butler, Reaves, Kessler, DFS, Christie,
Sign DSJ/Fulz, RoCo, and some other vets
If Miami wants a 1st, take out a swap and get another cheap C, but not many good Cs at 3M or less
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,709
- And1: 3,618
- Joined: Jul 31, 2009
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
zimpy27 wrote:axeman23 wrote:If I were Lakers, I'd add another swap to keep Knecht, or just remove Knecht altogether. Larsson isn't setting the world on fire, and despite hearing for years about Paul Read being some "advances stat/per 48 monster", his ACTUAL stats, and GAMETIME haven't really backed that up, imo... This also leaves the Lakers pretty thin on the guard spots. I'd see what other offers I had to beat before putting this out there as my initial off, from Lakers pov.
Well Knecht and Christie is the value that makes Heat actually choose this path. I'm not sure a swap is tempting to Heat unless it's in 2030.
We've seen various attempts at the "3rd star" next to Lebron and AD, and I just don't think it works. The year they had 2 stars and depth, they won the title. Since they've lost that depth, they've come up short. I don't see gutting their current depth and future assets for Jimmy Butler's final years changing that. Knecht and Christie may be what the Heat need to part with Jimmy. That doesn't mean the Lakers need to PAY that price, especially when Lebron and AD are not (to my knowledge...) clamoring for him to be targeted.
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,203
- And1: 669
- Joined: Jan 02, 2015
-
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
Jimmy always leave his teams on bad terms, so imo the LAL should stay away from him.
But if the alternative is doing nothing i think i'd take it.
I do think LA can do better, though.
But if the alternative is doing nothing i think i'd take it.
I do think LA can do better, though.
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- Head Coach
- Posts: 6,755
- And1: 2,495
- Joined: Jan 18, 2019
-
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
I think pistons days as dumpingground is over
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
-
- Retired Mod
- Posts: 57,317
- And1: 18,436
- Joined: Jun 23, 2001
-
Re: Butler to Lakers with Pistons
No thanks for Miami. We have two goals in a Jimmy trade - no salary beyond 2026 and players who can help us get to the playoffs. This, from my estimation, accomplishes neither goal.
Return to Trades and Transactions