Image ImageImage Image

Josh Giddey - Conundrum Killer

Moderators: HomoSapien, Ice Man, dougthonus, Michael Jackson, Tommy Udo 6 , kulaz3000, fleet, DASMACKDOWN, GimmeDat, RedBulls23, AshyLarrysDiaper, coldfish, Payt10

Dez
General Manager
Posts: 7,708
And1: 9,263
Joined: Jul 23, 2011
Location: Melbourne, Australia
 

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#301 » by Dez » Fri Jan 3, 2025 8:12 pm

Chi town wrote:AK gonna pay this kid.

He has shown what he can do with his triple doubles and improved defense.

Let’s talk about his disappearing act, leading the tank in games like the Wiz where he literally makes us worse and can not score, and his awful 3pt heave that looks worse than ever.

I don’t like a team built with Giddey as a starter. He doesn’t provide enough 3s, defense, or gravity to help a 5 man unit win.

The only way he becomes good enough is if he has a Lonzo like transformation in that 3 ball with makes and volume.

I wouldn’t make that bet.


Can't score when Coby decides to dominate the ball.

He was looking much improved and comfortable until these last few games where Coby decided he needed 20+ shots to score 20 points.
Chi town
RealGM
Posts: 29,433
And1: 9,100
Joined: Aug 10, 2004

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#302 » by Chi town » Fri Jan 3, 2025 10:16 pm

Dez wrote:
Chi town wrote:AK gonna pay this kid.

He has shown what he can do with his triple doubles and improved defense.

Let’s talk about his disappearing act, leading the tank in games like the Wiz where he literally makes us worse and can not score, and his awful 3pt heave that looks worse than ever.

I don’t like a team built with Giddey as a starter. He doesn’t provide enough 3s, defense, or gravity to help a 5 man unit win.

The only way he becomes good enough is if he has a Lonzo like transformation in that 3 ball with makes and volume.

I wouldn’t make that bet.


Can't score when Coby decides to dominate the ball.

He was looking much improved and comfortable until these last few games where Coby decided he needed 20+ shots to score 20 points.


And he’s 7/30 from 3 over his last 5 games.

That doesn’t include him passing them up and then making it even more difficult to get a good shot for the team.
scottyg
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,261
And1: 89
Joined: Oct 23, 2009

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#303 » by scottyg » Sat Jan 4, 2025 3:07 am

Trade Coby White to the spurs for our picks back, then trade the Portland pick back to Portland for Robert Williams and see what happens from there !
Dez
General Manager
Posts: 7,708
And1: 9,263
Joined: Jul 23, 2011
Location: Melbourne, Australia
 

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#304 » by Dez » Sat Jan 4, 2025 4:33 am

scottyg wrote:Trade Coby White to the spurs for our picks back, then trade the Portland pick back to Portland for Robert Williams and see what happens from there !

Coby isn't getting us our pick back through a trade, he will if he continues chucking though.
Indomitable
RealGM
Posts: 25,462
And1: 6,408
Joined: Jul 11, 2001
Location: Yelzenbah!
     

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#305 » by Indomitable » Sat Jan 4, 2025 5:24 am

Chi town wrote:
Dez wrote:
Chi town wrote:AK gonna pay this kid.

He has shown what he can do with his triple doubles and improved defense.

Let’s talk about his disappearing act, leading the tank in games like the Wiz where he literally makes us worse and can not score, and his awful 3pt heave that looks worse than ever.

I don’t like a team built with Giddey as a starter. He doesn’t provide enough 3s, defense, or gravity to help a 5 man unit win.

The only way he becomes good enough is if he has a Lonzo like transformation in that 3 ball with makes and volume.

I wouldn’t make that bet.


Can't score when Coby decides to dominate the ball.

He was looking much improved and comfortable until these last few games where Coby decided he needed 20+ shots to score 20 points.


And he’s 7/30 from 3 over his last 5 games.

That doesn’t include him passing them up and then making it even more difficult to get a good shot for the team.

But he got a trash triple double.

24 shots to get 21 points. Plus crappy defense.
:banghead:
Indomitable
RealGM
Posts: 25,462
And1: 6,408
Joined: Jul 11, 2001
Location: Yelzenbah!
     

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#306 » by Indomitable » Sat Jan 4, 2025 5:28 am

scottyg wrote:Trade Coby White to the spurs for our picks back, then trade the Portland pick back to Portland for Robert Williams and see what happens from there !

Williams does have the skillset we need. He is a rim protector and rebounder. How is his knee.
:banghead:
Chi town
RealGM
Posts: 29,433
And1: 9,100
Joined: Aug 10, 2004

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#307 » by Chi town » Sat Jan 4, 2025 4:36 pm

Indomitable wrote:
scottyg wrote:Trade Coby White to the spurs for our picks back, then trade the Portland pick back to Portland for Robert Williams and see what happens from there !

Williams does have the skillset we need. He is a rim protector and rebounder. How is his knee.


He never plays.
Indomitable
RealGM
Posts: 25,462
And1: 6,408
Joined: Jul 11, 2001
Location: Yelzenbah!
     

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#308 » by Indomitable » Sat Jan 4, 2025 9:06 pm

Chi town wrote:
Indomitable wrote:
scottyg wrote:Trade Coby White to the spurs for our picks back, then trade the Portland pick back to Portland for Robert Williams and see what happens from there !

Williams does have the skillset we need. He is a rim protector and rebounder. How is his knee.


He never plays.

Is it a numbers situation?
:banghead:
sco
RealGM
Posts: 27,390
And1: 9,201
Joined: Sep 22, 2003
Location: Virtually Everywhere!

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#309 » by sco » Sat Jan 11, 2025 8:47 pm

It is certainly a small sample size, but I have definitely seen defensive improvement from Giddey of late and he's averaged 50% from 3 over past 5 games. If he stays competent at both through the end of the season, I'd be thrilled.

Next season, I'd like to see him at the 4 and Matas at the 3 (and Pat traded for someone better).
:clap:
User avatar
ImSlower
Head Coach
Posts: 6,316
And1: 7,597
Joined: Jan 06, 2011
Location: STL-ish
   

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#310 » by ImSlower » Sat Jan 11, 2025 11:06 pm

I think his shooting % this season is mostly irrelevant simply because I believe he needs to completely rebuild his form from the bottom up - quite literally. He's tall enough that a high and quick release shot like so many modern sharpshooters have now would make him an invaluable PG. He misses badly left or right so often with his slow and low push shot from under his chin that I'm surprised to even see 33% for the year.
GuardianEnzo
Senior
Posts: 721
And1: 425
Joined: Jul 12, 2014
         

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#311 » by GuardianEnzo » Sun Jan 12, 2025 12:17 am

The funny thing is that Giddey has always graded out pretty well defensively according to advanced stats (he and Lonzo are the only regulars in positive territory this season). Is that a total mirage, or with his height and reach is he overall more of an asset than he's given credit for?
Guru
Analyst
Posts: 3,698
And1: 780
Joined: Oct 29, 2001

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#312 » by Guru » Sun Jan 12, 2025 6:12 am

ImSlower wrote:I think his shooting % this season is mostly irrelevant simply because I believe he needs to completely rebuild his form from the bottom up - quite literally. He's tall enough that a high and quick release shot like so many modern sharpshooters have now would make him an invaluable PG. He misses badly left or right so often with his slow and low push shot from under his chin that I'm surprised to even see 33% for the year.


He pops his elbow like a kid with no upper body strength would do.

He needs someone to invest him and let him reset that shot.
JRoy
RealGM
Posts: 16,790
And1: 14,127
Joined: Feb 27, 2019
 

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#313 » by JRoy » Sun Jan 12, 2025 7:03 am

Indomitable wrote:
Chi town wrote:
Indomitable wrote:Williams does have the skillset we need. He is a rim protector and rebounder. How is his knee.


He never plays.

Is it a numbers situation?


POR is limiting his minutes.

Keeping him healthy enough to move maybe.
Edrees wrote:
JRoy wrote:Monta Ellis have it all


I was hoping and expecting this to be one of the first replies. You did not disappoint. Jroy have it all.
Indomitable
RealGM
Posts: 25,462
And1: 6,408
Joined: Jul 11, 2001
Location: Yelzenbah!
     

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#314 » by Indomitable » Sun Jan 12, 2025 10:11 am

JRoy wrote:
Indomitable wrote:
Chi town wrote:
He never plays.

Is it a numbers situation?


POR is limiting his minutes.

Keeping him healthy enough to move maybe.

He is what this team needs.
:banghead:
JRoy
RealGM
Posts: 16,790
And1: 14,127
Joined: Feb 27, 2019
 

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#315 » by JRoy » Sun Jan 12, 2025 3:12 pm

Indomitable wrote:
JRoy wrote:
Indomitable wrote:Is it a numbers situation?


POR is limiting his minutes.

Keeping him healthy enough to move maybe.

He is what this team needs.


He’s an excellent player but those injuries are a real concern.
Edrees wrote:
JRoy wrote:Monta Ellis have it all


I was hoping and expecting this to be one of the first replies. You did not disappoint. Jroy have it all.
Indomitable
RealGM
Posts: 25,462
And1: 6,408
Joined: Jul 11, 2001
Location: Yelzenbah!
     

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#316 » by Indomitable » Sun Jan 12, 2025 3:55 pm

JRoy wrote:
Indomitable wrote:
JRoy wrote:
POR is limiting his minutes.

Keeping him healthy enough to move maybe.

He is what this team needs.


He’s an excellent player but those injuries are a real concern.

Honestly we need a player like him to instill intimidation.

Mateas will help too. Getting two or three good shotblockers will really change teams plans.

Ball, Ayo, and even Zach getting some steals will flip the way are attacked.

He make 10 million. We have a Leroy on the bench earning 8 not being of any value.
:banghead:
Indomitable
RealGM
Posts: 25,462
And1: 6,408
Joined: Jul 11, 2001
Location: Yelzenbah!
     

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#317 » by Indomitable » Sun Jan 12, 2025 8:20 pm

sco wrote:It is certainly a small sample size, but I have definitely seen defensive improvement from Giddey of late and he's averaged 50% from 3 over past 5 games. If he stays competent at both through the end of the season, I'd be thrilled.

Next season, I'd like to see him at the 4 and Matas at the 3 (and Pat traded for someone better).

If Pat is trash how do you get someone better?
:banghead:
Infinity2152
Veteran
Posts: 2,634
And1: 951
Joined: Jul 19, 2023
       

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#318 » by Infinity2152 » Mon Jan 13, 2025 3:37 am

MrSparkle wrote:
Infinity2152 wrote:I can't imagine any team has had more starters out for injuries than the Bulls during AK's time either. If I'm mistaken, please correct me. The Bulls have literally been starting two-three bench players every night for the last few years, between Zach, Ball, and Pat's injuries. A team built thru strength in numbers can't afford that as easily as a team with two top tier stars as long as the stars are healthy. Add in the fact that the one out the longest is the QB of the offense and defense and maybe the only high BBall IQ player on the team, exacerbates the problem. I bet the metrics when all are healthy are entirely different. Injuries happen, but we've had multiple guys out damn near entire seasons.

So yeah, our team minus 2-3 starters is not as good as most teams with their starting lineups primarily intact. Is that surprising?


The Lonzo injury was as bad/unfortunate as it gets, and our injury rates that first season were ridiculous (Pat/Coby/Caruso/DJJ). But overall, besides Lonzo, I'd say the Bulls have been on par with the average NBA team that sees a lot of ups and downs with health.

Clippers? They keep staying over 500, with tons of vet min guys playing heavy minutes. Kawhi and George during his time there.

I can't remember the last time Middleton made it through a season. He was a key part of the Bucks' chip.

Celtics lost Porzingis most the year and won a ring.

Grizzlies have been making do with or without Ja (wisely tanking when he was entirely out).

Hawks have had a deluge of injuries to their core (Hunter, Okongwu, etc.). Magic keep winning, with Franz/Paolo nursing serious injuries. Cavs had a rough stretch last year- now they're healthy and loaded.

My point is, it was an excuse until it wasn't an excuse. Sorry, but you don't get to say for 4 years straight that injuries are the reason you can't make it to .500. At that point, you just suck, and you're not doing anything smart to get out the treadmill.


You can't just say aside from Lonzo though. Without looking up the stats, I can pretty much guarantee Bull's not having Lonzo vs Clippers not having George, or Celtics not having Porzingas, Bucks not having Middleton, the Bull's net rating, defensive rating, offensive rating are far more impacted than when those guys were out. I'm sure he has the highest +/-, almost any positive advanced metrics as far as team impact.

There are 30 teams in the league. We don't have a top 15 player. Missing the most impactful player. How is being a mid-team bad? Where could you realistically expect to be? There are no moves he could have made to make us a contender with Lonzo out. Trading zach, Debo, or Vuc, we're still a mid-team at best. Just a different mid-team.

If we made it to .500 two of those seasons, then what?
They were 46-36 2021-2022 season, so definitely not 4 years straight.
40-42 2022-2023 no Ball, so one win away from being .500.
39-43 2023-2024 missing Lavine and Ball plus Pat half the season, two wins from being .500.

If Pat Will had given us anywhere near the impact you'd hope from a recent #4 pick, are those teams better than .500 teams even without Ball? Since they missed by 1 and 2 games?

2020 draft, we could have traded down and still drafted Haliburton, Maxey, Desmond Bane, Deni Avidja, or Devin Vassell. That miss has hurt us more the past 3-4 years than any inactivity in the trade market.
WesPeace
Senior
Posts: 706
And1: 334
Joined: Jan 12, 2025
Location: Planet Earth
     

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#319 » by WesPeace » Tue Jan 14, 2025 6:55 am

Giddey is still young and can improve his defense (must improve, really must) and his shooting stroke.
I would keep him but not for starter salary money,up to 20M per season,sure.. Lonzo is still my preferrable point guard of this team.

Lonzo, Zach, PWill at 3 or new SF, Buzelis, Smith/New C with bench mob of Giddey, Ayo, Terry, Phillips, Smith/New C etc..
PJSteven22
Starter
Posts: 2,197
And1: 918
Joined: Feb 04, 2022

Re: Josh Giddey Conundrum 

Post#320 » by PJSteven22 » Wed Jan 22, 2025 6:02 am

Dez wrote:
Chi town wrote:AK gonna pay this kid.

He has shown what he can do with his triple doubles and improved defense.

Let’s talk about his disappearing act, leading the tank in games like the Wiz where he literally makes us worse and can not score, and his awful 3pt heave that looks worse than ever.

I don’t like a team built with Giddey as a starter. He doesn’t provide enough 3s, defense, or gravity to help a 5 man unit win.

The only way he becomes good enough is if he has a Lonzo like transformation in that 3 ball with makes and volume.

I wouldn’t make that bet.


Can't score when Coby decides to dominate the ball.

He was looking much improved and comfortable until these last few games where Coby decided he needed 20+ shots to score 20 points.

He can’t score because he can’t break down his defender.

Return to Chicago Bulls