Agreed. You also don't know if their plan was solid but their hands were tied by ownership. Also hard to know what the alternatives would've done.dougthonus wrote:Betta Bulleavit wrote:So then Rapaport and Schefter (two pretty credible guys) have conflicting takes on where things stand with Johnson.
I’m inclined to believe Rap more given how all in the Bears seem to be on McCarthy. Perhaps the “rolling out of the red carpet” is a preemptive move to get a guy who likely is in their top group (while the getting is good) instead of missing out for a guy that’s a maybe at best. Is this the right approach? Not sure. But for the BJ or bust fans, this is very discouraging.
I get why fans get hung up on GM / Coach hires, because they're critically important, but the reality is they are extraordinarily hard for fans to gauge their effectiveness. I've never understood when fans just get hyper focused on a coordinator as the guy and have this absolute level of certainty that he's the one we should hire.
I sort of get it if a guy like Harbaugh enters the market, and you know someone is awesome and available, but coordinators are always risks. GMs are even tougher because you never really know what alternatives they had or considered and everyone is playing with a different hand and people often conflate the parts that were lucky with the parts that were skill.
Sent from my SM-S928U using Tapatalk

















