Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden?

Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285

UglyBugBall
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,910
And1: 1,736
Joined: Sep 04, 2022
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#101 » by UglyBugBall » Fri Jan 17, 2025 4:42 pm

RRR3 wrote:
Reeko wrote:
JM00n69 wrote:
You've nailed it with the Drose/Glove example. Rose a better single season and would've 100% been better career wise than Payton if he didn't get injured (crazy to think how good Rose would've been if he didn't blow his knee out) but he did and while he made a very good comeback all things considered, you can't compare that to someone who's a first ballot HoFer that had a long career playing top level basketball while rarely missing games.

Kahwi showed everyone he was a top all time defensive wing for years and that he can also be the 1A on a Championship Team but injuries before and especially after make it a very short career. He's in the Grant Hill/Brandon Roy/DRose what if- could've been top AT tier.

No, Kawhi isn't in that tier. He won 2 championships, he has two Finals MVPs, he's a 2X DPOY, he's a 6X All Star, 7X All Defensive Team. He's just way more accomplished than any of the guys you mentioned.

Rose might have a ring if LeBron got injured in the 2011 playoffs. Would he be better than Gary Payton then?


With an FMVP and an MVP? Yes, obviously.
RRR3
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,095
And1: 5,008
Joined: May 26, 2019
   

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#102 » by RRR3 » Fri Jan 17, 2025 4:46 pm

UglyBugBall wrote:
RRR3 wrote:
Reeko wrote:No, Kawhi isn't in that tier. He won 2 championships, he has two Finals MVPs, he's a 2X DPOY, he's a 6X All Star, 7X All Defensive Team. He's just way more accomplished than any of the guys you mentioned.

Rose might have a ring if LeBron got injured in the 2011 playoffs. Would he be better than Gary Payton then?


With an FMVP and an MVP? Yes, obviously.

"Rose would be better at basketball if LeBron got injured"

:crazy: :crazy: :crazy:
RRR3
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,095
And1: 5,008
Joined: May 26, 2019
   

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#103 » by RRR3 » Fri Jan 17, 2025 4:47 pm

It boggles my mind how some of you can't figure out how circumstances do not dictate talent.
User avatar
Reeko
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 26,213
And1: 38,359
Joined: Jan 04, 2015
Location: East side, in a deluxe apartment in the sky.
   

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#104 » by Reeko » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:00 pm

RRR3 wrote:
Reeko wrote:
JM00n69 wrote:
You've nailed it with the Drose/Glove example. Rose a better single season and would've 100% been better career wise than Payton if he didn't get injured (crazy to think how good Rose would've been if he didn't blow his knee out) but he did and while he made a very good comeback all things considered, you can't compare that to someone who's a first ballot HoFer that had a long career playing top level basketball while rarely missing games.

Kahwi showed everyone he was a top all time defensive wing for years and that he can also be the 1A on a Championship Team but injuries before and especially after make it a very short career. He's in the Grant Hill/Brandon Roy/DRose what if- could've been top AT tier.

No, Kawhi isn't in that tier. He won 2 championships, he has two Finals MVPs, he's a 2X DPOY, he's a 6X All Star, 7X All Defensive Team. He's just way more accomplished than any of the guys you mentioned.

Rose might have a ring if LeBron got injured in the 2011 playoffs. Would he be better than Gary Payton then?

I don't know why you think that comparing Rose to Payton is the same as comparing Kawhi to Harden.
Clay Davis wrote:COMPOSED ONLY OF THE COOLEST WOMEN AND THE HOTTEST GUYS, THE TORONTO RAPTORS REALGM BOARD HAS LONG BEEN KNOWN FOR ITS HIGH-QUALITY DISCUSSION, PASSIONATE LOYALTY, TEMPERATE CELEBRATIONS OF VICTORY, AND GRACE IN DEFEAT.
Haldi
Senior
Posts: 541
And1: 584
Joined: Jan 07, 2020
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#105 » by Haldi » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:03 pm

_NoMas wrote:
Haldi wrote:
UglyBugBall wrote:
Harden is a great player to have in games that don't matter. He'll put up numbers in the regular season and fall off in the playoffs. He's like the anti Luka. Guys like Leonard, Lebron, Luka get better in the playoffs. Harden goes from a top 3 player to a Demar Derozan. Kawhii has had multiple playoff runs more impressive individually (even if we remove the rings argument, which we shouldn't) than Hardens best. Harden is like that kid in class that get straight A's throughout high-school but never amounts to anything after he graduates. Kawhii is the kid that drops out and then goes and builds Microsoft.


Put Kawhi on any of Hardens teams instead of the ones he got to play on and he would have exactly 0 championships as well and would’ve performed worst as well - tends to happen when the defense can just focus on you the entire time cause you’re on the floor with 4 guys like Gordon, Ariza, Tucker and Cappela. Literally only Gordon is an offensive threat in that group lol, the others you can just leave absolutely wide open without a care in the world. Kawhi would’ve done dick all with a group like that in the regular season and even less so in the playoffs. Add Chris Paul to that roster for one more half of basketball, and that roster wouldve beat the Durant Warriors, aka the best team of all time, and Harden would have one of the best rings of all time. Hell, just don’t Scott Foster game 7 and he still wins that without his second best player lol.

The next year in 2019, without Chris Paul for 2 and half months at the start of the season and for most of the middle of the season and without Clint for a month and a half, Kawhi doesn’t even make the playoffs with guys like Gordon, House, Tucker, Macklemore and rookie Hartenstein. That team probably finishes in like 10th or 11th in the West, and Im imagining a world where Leonard actually plays 78 of 82 games like Harden, which we know what a joke that is lol. Meanwhile, Harden had 36, 7.5 and 6 and led that team to 4th place in a stacked west.

This whole “oh but he elevates his game in the playoffs” thing is so dumb and the most casual take ever, completely lacks any understanding of how the game of basketball is played. TEAMS win rings, not any single players and Harden is raising floors, ceilings and skies as much as one man can.


Put harden on the raptors. Do they beat Philly or Milwaukee?


Prime Harden with Kyle, Powell, Siakim, Gasol, Fred and Ibaka… I’d say that Philly series doesn’t go anywhere near a game 7 buzzer prayer to win it. And the Bucks were a very strong regular season team that year but very much lacked playoff experience so although Leonard was very useful for the wall defense they set up against Giannis, Nurse can do the same damn thing with that roster as well. Team defense >>> than individual defense.

The 6 guys listed there are levels and levels above the 2018 or 2019 rockets team that Harden had to work with. Again, Mbah Moute I don’t think ever played NBA basketball again lol. Ariza got a fat 2 year contract the next year which the team realized was a huge mistake and traded him and after never played NBA basketball again. Gordon hasn’t exactly shined in Houston after Harden left and is he still even in the NBA?? Clint seems to be playing less and less minutes every year, cause he has Trae instead of Harden now. Tucker was a decent 20 ish minute role player on that championship Bucks run, but he was playing 40 minutes a game with Harden lol. As for Danual House and Macklemore… yea. And Hartenstein is a solid backup in the NBA but was a rookie at the time. Im never gonna say anything bad about Paul’s play obviously, dude was amazing but missed the most important game and a half in 2018 and most of 2019, and was not himself that playoff run.
RRR3
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,095
And1: 5,008
Joined: May 26, 2019
   

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#106 » by RRR3 » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:03 pm

Reeko wrote:
RRR3 wrote:
Reeko wrote:No, Kawhi isn't in that tier. He won 2 championships, he has two Finals MVPs, he's a 2X DPOY, he's a 6X All Star, 7X All Defensive Team. He's just way more accomplished than any of the guys you mentioned.

Rose might have a ring if LeBron got injured in the 2011 playoffs. Would he be better than Gary Payton then?

I don't know why you think that comparing Rose to Payton is the same as comparing Kawhi to Harden.

Nothing is a 1:1 comparison, but you could combine Kawhi and Embiid's careers and they'd still have less minutes played than Harden does. Kawhi was also not better than Harden for a lot of his career, only in his fifth season did he reach that level. Longevity matters. It's pretty debatable to say the least if Kawhi has been better than peak Harden on the Clippers, so that leaves you with 3 full seasons TOPS Kawhi had playing at a higher level than Harden.
User avatar
sashaturiaf
Analyst
Posts: 3,503
And1: 3,922
Joined: Jan 18, 2021
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#107 » by sashaturiaf » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:10 pm

Haldi wrote:
UglyBugBall wrote:
Haldi wrote:
Thats funny considering the actual best player in the NBA that very year, is the guy he’s compared to in this very thread lol.

Harden averaged 36, 7.5 and 6.6 on elite efficiency absolutely carrying a squad that was trying to fit the leftovers of Carmelo which caused them to start something like 10-14 record with no Chris Paul. After that Chris Paul AND Clint both missed another 2 months each in the middle of the year and Harden was out there with Tucker, House, Macklemore, Gordon and rookie Hartenstein averaging 40 pts triple doubles for what seemed like 2 months. Most of these guys aren’t even real NBA players anymore, and no, its not because of age, except maybe Tucker.

Harden took that rockets team to 53-29 and 4th place in a much stronger west conference and the only reason he wasn’t back to back mvp was cause the Bucks had a measly 7 more wins despite playing against much weaker opponents in the east most of the time - and in those days, ‘muh team record’ was still sadly one of the top arguments in mvp voting, something we finally saw come to an end recently with jokic winning as a 6th seed and such (which I have zero problem with, always should be like that, team record should matter but context should matter more).

Harden has BOTH a better peak and much better career than Kawhi. Unless you’re the type to overvalue team rings as individual accomplishments (hint: they’re not), then it should be pretty clear. And that’s not to take anything away from Kawhi, he was a beast too, but he’s also benefited from playing on much better structured teams than Harden, and THATS what matters for rings, not how great one individual guy is.


Harden is a great player to have in games that don't matter. He'll put up numbers in the regular season and fall off in the playoffs. He's like the anti Luka. Guys like Leonard, Lebron, Luka get better in the playoffs. Harden goes from a top 3 player to a Demar Derozan. Kawhii has had multiple playoff runs more impressive individually (even if we remove the rings argument, which we shouldn't) than Hardens best. Harden is like that kid in class that get straight A's throughout high-school but never amounts to anything after he graduates. Kawhii is the kid that drops out and then goes and builds Microsoft.


Put Kawhi on any of Hardens teams instead of the ones he got to play on and he would have exactly 0 championships as well and would’ve performed worst as well - tends to happen when the defense can just focus on you the entire time cause you’re on the floor with 4 guys like Gordon, Ariza, Tucker and Cappela. Literally only Gordon is an offensive threat in that group lol, the others you can just leave absolutely wide open without a care in the world. Kawhi would’ve done dick all with a group like that in the regular season and even less so in the playoffs. Add Chris Paul to that roster for one more half of basketball, and that roster wouldve beat the Durant Warriors, aka the best team of all time, and Harden would have one of the best rings of all time. Hell, just don’t Scott Foster game 7 and he still wins that without his second best player lol.

The next year in 2019, without Chris Paul for 2 and half months at the start of the season and for most of the middle of the season and without Clint for a month and a half, Kawhi doesn’t even make the playoffs with guys like Gordon, House, Tucker, Macklemore and rookie Hartenstein. That team probably finishes in like 10th or 11th in the West, and Im imagining a world where Leonard actually plays 78 of 82 games like Harden, which we know what a joke that is lol. Meanwhile, Harden had 36, 7.5 and 6 and led that team to 4th place in a stacked west.

This whole “oh but he elevates his game in the playoffs” thing is so dumb and the most casual take ever, completely lacks any understanding of how the game of basketball is played. TEAMS win rings, not any single players and Harden is raising floors, ceilings and skies as much as one man can.



Could, shoulda, woulda. Count the rings baby

Harden shrinks when the lights get bright and teams actually start playing D, and he's still a traffic cone on the other side of the court. There is no way he can be remembered as better than Kawhi
User avatar
dolphinatik
General Manager
Posts: 7,736
And1: 4,710
Joined: Oct 20, 2008
     

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#108 » by dolphinatik » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:11 pm

Harden. Longer peak.
Changed the game with how stepback and continuation are viewed. Then changed his game to add more assists. Best peak is kawhi but longevity and impact to the game is not close.
1. Herro 2. Bol Bol 3. Seko 4. Bruno
unless we trade up for Barrett or trade down for PJ Washington
Haldi
Senior
Posts: 541
And1: 584
Joined: Jan 07, 2020
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#109 » by Haldi » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:13 pm

RRR3 wrote:It boggles my mind how some of you can't figure out how circumstances do not dictate talent.


I will never understand this. If you replace all of Jordans teams with girls from a high school basketball team and he never wins a single championship, is he all of a sudden a worse basketball player and not a winner and therefore a loser. This is how much people on this forum know how to analyze players lol. I guarantee some will even come at me and be like, Jordan would at least win one lol. Some brain dead stuff around here
RRR3
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,095
And1: 5,008
Joined: May 26, 2019
   

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#110 » by RRR3 » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:14 pm

Why do people keep saying Kawhi is better peak wise as if that is the only factor on the all-time list? No one thinks Joe Dumars was better at basketball than Tracy McGrady, but I'm sure there's plenty of lists that rank Dumars higher.
Haldi
Senior
Posts: 541
And1: 584
Joined: Jan 07, 2020
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#111 » by Haldi » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:14 pm

sashaturiaf wrote:
Haldi wrote:
UglyBugBall wrote:
Harden is a great player to have in games that don't matter. He'll put up numbers in the regular season and fall off in the playoffs. He's like the anti Luka. Guys like Leonard, Lebron, Luka get better in the playoffs. Harden goes from a top 3 player to a Demar Derozan. Kawhii has had multiple playoff runs more impressive individually (even if we remove the rings argument, which we shouldn't) than Hardens best. Harden is like that kid in class that get straight A's throughout high-school but never amounts to anything after he graduates. Kawhii is the kid that drops out and then goes and builds Microsoft.


Put Kawhi on any of Hardens teams instead of the ones he got to play on and he would have exactly 0 championships as well and would’ve performed worst as well - tends to happen when the defense can just focus on you the entire time cause you’re on the floor with 4 guys like Gordon, Ariza, Tucker and Cappela. Literally only Gordon is an offensive threat in that group lol, the others you can just leave absolutely wide open without a care in the world. Kawhi would’ve done dick all with a group like that in the regular season and even less so in the playoffs. Add Chris Paul to that roster for one more half of basketball, and that roster wouldve beat the Durant Warriors, aka the best team of all time, and Harden would have one of the best rings of all time. Hell, just don’t Scott Foster game 7 and he still wins that without his second best player lol.

The next year in 2019, without Chris Paul for 2 and half months at the start of the season and for most of the middle of the season and without Clint for a month and a half, Kawhi doesn’t even make the playoffs with guys like Gordon, House, Tucker, Macklemore and rookie Hartenstein. That team probably finishes in like 10th or 11th in the West, and Im imagining a world where Leonard actually plays 78 of 82 games like Harden, which we know what a joke that is lol. Meanwhile, Harden had 36, 7.5 and 6 and led that team to 4th place in a stacked west.

This whole “oh but he elevates his game in the playoffs” thing is so dumb and the most casual take ever, completely lacks any understanding of how the game of basketball is played. TEAMS win rings, not any single players and Harden is raising floors, ceilings and skies as much as one man can.



Could, shoulda, woulda. Count the rings baby

Harden shrinks when the lights get bright and teams actually start playing D, and he's still a traffic cone on the other side of the court. There is no way he can be remembered as better than Kawhi


Thanks for proving my point above lol
JM00n69
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,294
And1: 1,016
Joined: Nov 26, 2023
Location: London, England
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#112 » by JM00n69 » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:16 pm

Reeko wrote:
JM00n69 wrote:
RRR3 wrote:Walton played 123 games (plus 21 in the playoffs) at his prime level. Pierce was possibly at least all-star level from 1999-2013. This isn't a debate. It's like saying Derrick Rose had a better career than Gary Payton.


You've nailed it with the Drose/Glove example. Rose a better single season and would've 100% been better career wise than Payton if he didn't get injured (crazy to think how good Rose would've been if he didn't blow his knee out) but he did and while he made a very good comeback all things considered, you can't compare that to someone who's a first ballot HoFer that had a long career playing top level basketball while rarely missing games.

Kahwi showed everyone he was a top all time defensive wing for years and that he can also be the 1A on a Championship Team but injuries before and especially after make it a very short career. He's in the Grant Hill/Brandon Roy/DRose what if- could've been top AT tier.

No, Kawhi isn't in that tier. He won 2 championships, he has two Finals MVPs, he's a 2X DPOY, he's a 6X All Star, 7X All Defensive Team. He's just way more accomplished than any of the guys you mentioned.


Don't be daft, he obviously is. All time great player when healthy and potentially a top-10 AT if they never got injured and could've carried on at that level.
RRR3
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,095
And1: 5,008
Joined: May 26, 2019
   

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#113 » by RRR3 » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:19 pm

Yeah if Kawhi had Harden's durability, he'd be ranked extremely highly. Ignoring longevity is crazy when ranking who had the greatest CAREERS, if we're just ranking who was better at their best, I would take Kawhi over Harden but even that is not as one-sided as some people in this thread are acting like it is.
User avatar
Reeko
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 26,213
And1: 38,359
Joined: Jan 04, 2015
Location: East side, in a deluxe apartment in the sky.
   

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#114 » by Reeko » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:20 pm

RRR3 wrote:
Reeko wrote:
RRR3 wrote:Rose might have a ring if LeBron got injured in the 2011 playoffs. Would he be better than Gary Payton then?

I don't know why you think that comparing Rose to Payton is the same as comparing Kawhi to Harden.

Nothing is a 1:1 comparison, but you could combine Kawhi and Embiid's careers and they'd still have less minutes played than Harden does. Kawhi was also not better than Harden for a lot of his career, only in his fifth season did he reach that level. Longevity matters. It's pretty debatable to say the least if Kawhi has been better than peak Harden on the Clippers, so that leaves you with 3 full seasons TOPS Kawhi had playing at a higher level than Harden.


Your only argument is minutes played/longevity. In terms of peak it's Kawhi, in terms of accomplishments and accolades it's still Kawhi. Kawhi has accomplished more despite having a chronic injury, than Harden has as one of the NBA's iron men.
Clay Davis wrote:COMPOSED ONLY OF THE COOLEST WOMEN AND THE HOTTEST GUYS, THE TORONTO RAPTORS REALGM BOARD HAS LONG BEEN KNOWN FOR ITS HIGH-QUALITY DISCUSSION, PASSIONATE LOYALTY, TEMPERATE CELEBRATIONS OF VICTORY, AND GRACE IN DEFEAT.
User avatar
Reeko
Forum Mod - Raptors
Forum Mod - Raptors
Posts: 26,213
And1: 38,359
Joined: Jan 04, 2015
Location: East side, in a deluxe apartment in the sky.
   

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#115 » by Reeko » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:23 pm

JM00n69 wrote:
Reeko wrote:
JM00n69 wrote:
You've nailed it with the Drose/Glove example. Rose a better single season and would've 100% been better career wise than Payton if he didn't get injured (crazy to think how good Rose would've been if he didn't blow his knee out) but he did and while he made a very good comeback all things considered, you can't compare that to someone who's a first ballot HoFer that had a long career playing top level basketball while rarely missing games.

Kahwi showed everyone he was a top all time defensive wing for years and that he can also be the 1A on a Championship Team but injuries before and especially after make it a very short career. He's in the Grant Hill/Brandon Roy/DRose what if- could've been top AT tier.

No, Kawhi isn't in that tier. He won 2 championships, he has two Finals MVPs, he's a 2X DPOY, he's a 6X All Star, 7X All Defensive Team. He's just way more accomplished than any of the guys you mentioned.


Don't be daft, he obviously is. All time great player when healthy and potentially a top-10 AT if they never got injured and could've carried on at that level.

None of those guys have his resume. If he retires today, Kawhi is a top 30 player of all time.
Clay Davis wrote:COMPOSED ONLY OF THE COOLEST WOMEN AND THE HOTTEST GUYS, THE TORONTO RAPTORS REALGM BOARD HAS LONG BEEN KNOWN FOR ITS HIGH-QUALITY DISCUSSION, PASSIONATE LOYALTY, TEMPERATE CELEBRATIONS OF VICTORY, AND GRACE IN DEFEAT.
User avatar
sashaturiaf
Analyst
Posts: 3,503
And1: 3,922
Joined: Jan 18, 2021
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#116 » by sashaturiaf » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:24 pm

RRR3 wrote:Why do people keep saying Kawhi is better peak wise as if that is the only factor on the all-time list? No one thinks Joe Dumars was better at basketball than Tracy McGrady, but I'm sure there's plenty of lists that rank Dumars higher.


What? Dumars vs Tmac is nothing like Harden vs Kawhi

If anything it's more like Bird vs Malone. Regular season longevity vs playoff excellence
JM00n69
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,294
And1: 1,016
Joined: Nov 26, 2023
Location: London, England
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#117 » by JM00n69 » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:33 pm

RRR3 wrote:Yeah if Kawhi had Harden's durability, he'd be ranked extremely highly. Ignoring longevity is crazy when ranking who had the greatest CAREERS, if we're just ranking who was better at their best, I would take Kawhi over Harden but even that is not as one-sided as some people in this thread are acting like it is.


Exactly. Some people can't follow what the question was. And while I'll say Kahwhi 100% would've been a top 15 AT player if never got injured you just never know. He might have been a Ben Simmons at IND if Pop never traded for him.
UglyBugBall
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,910
And1: 1,736
Joined: Sep 04, 2022
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#118 » by UglyBugBall » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:49 pm

RRR3 wrote:
UglyBugBall wrote:
RRR3 wrote:Rose might have a ring if LeBron got injured in the 2011 playoffs. Would he be better than Gary Payton then?


With an FMVP and an MVP? Yes, obviously.

"Rose would be better at basketball if LeBron got injured"

:crazy: :crazy: :crazy:


He would be an MVP and FMVP, no? So clearly he'd be ahead of Gary.
JM00n69
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,294
And1: 1,016
Joined: Nov 26, 2023
Location: London, England
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#119 » by JM00n69 » Fri Jan 17, 2025 5:55 pm

Reeko wrote:
RRR3 wrote:
Reeko wrote:No, Kawhi isn't in that tier. He won 2 championships, he has two Finals MVPs, he's a 2X DPOY, he's a 6X All Star, 7X All Defensive Team. He's just way more accomplished than any of the guys you mentioned.

Rose might have a ring if LeBron got injured in the 2011 playoffs. Would he be better than Gary Payton then?

I don't know why you think that comparing Rose to Payton is the same as comparing Kawhi to Harden.


Payton an all time great PG that never missed games due to injures and Rose, a potential best ever PG if he never got injured. Like KL, he came back and had a few years in him still but will never be considered to have had a better career than Payton.
JM00n69
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,294
And1: 1,016
Joined: Nov 26, 2023
Location: London, England
 

Re: Who's higher all-time: Kawhi or Harden? 

Post#120 » by JM00n69 » Fri Jan 17, 2025 6:03 pm

Reeko wrote:
JM00n69 wrote:
Reeko wrote:No, Kawhi isn't in that tier. He won 2 championships, he has two Finals MVPs, he's a 2X DPOY, he's a 6X All Star, 7X All Defensive Team. He's just way more accomplished than any of the guys you mentioned.


Don't be daft, he obviously is. All time great player when healthy and potentially a top-10 AT if they never got injured and could've carried on at that level.

None of those guys have his resume. If he retires today, Kawhi is a top 30 player of all time.


Kawhi is not top 30 AT career wise, not even close with the injuries he's had. No point wasting my time on this.

https://www.basketball-reference.com/players/l/leonaka01.html#totals_stats

^someone link that as a pic, does that number of games played each season look like someone who's top 30AT?

Return to The General Board